Is Billy Corgan Serious?

2007-07-13 by Dave de Sylvia EMERITUS | 40 Comments
The Seattle Stranger has printed an open letter, purportedly authored by Smashing Pumpkins frontman Billy Corgan, addressing music fans on the occasion of his band's long-awaited return.

Oh yeah, and he's read Hegel. Apparently.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Billy Corgan
An Open Letter from Billy Corgan

July 10, 2007

My Dear Friends,

Today is the greatest day you've ever known.

Seven years, seven months, and ten days ago, the clock struck midnight, 2000, and the world began turning faster. Back then, I disbanded the Smashing Pumpkins because the new millennium demanded it. A new age needed a new start—cleanliness and unity, not the confused, confusing wreck I let the band become.

We were once the most important band in the world, and everyone—me, you, Courtney Love—knew it. The Smashing Pumpkins drew the line between Black Sabbath, the Bee Gees, and the Cure, and that line caught a generation like a leash around a wayward puppy. We founded Alternative Nation, and the kids and advertisers flocked around. But because the band had become bloated, overbearing, headstrong, because it grew beyond my control, it had to die. I killed it before it killed me.

And now, after all those years of self-imposed obscurity, of forced poetry, of side projects mired in mediocrity and too many guitarists, I bring us, together, here, to the corner of Future Avenue and Now Street. This is our moment! This is our day! This is Zeitgeist! (That's "Spirit of the Age" in German. Trust me: I've read Hegel.)

This band has always been the headlight on the barreling locomotive of modern youth; with a title like Zeitgeist, nobody can argue. I brought back original Pumpkins drummer Jimmy Chamberlain—recovered and reverent of yours truly, he's the epitome of a new leaf turned over—plus another chick bassist and some new guitar guy. Zeitgeist (Say it! It feels good!) arrives this week, in four different forms: The Best Buy version is different from the Target version is different from the iTunes version, which is different from everyone else's version. Most zeits would've settled for a single geist, but ours demands more marketing strategies, so I offer it four.

As for the music, the critics won't get it. They never have. My old fans—the ones whose lives were changed by Gish and Siamese Dream—won't get it. They will complain that the sound is too dense, too severe, too, yes, overbearing. But the New Generation is the one I'm speaking to, the one that needs to know that My Chemical Romance and Panic! At the

Disco couldn't exist without me. Whether they want to know doesn't matter. This Zeitgeist is not consensual—it's here, whether you understand it or not.

Several weeks ago, I released "Tarantula" to prime the public for the coming onslaught. The song is the sound of one ego exploding (mine), the sound of an entire album in just one song. You'll like it because it has the same skyrocketing guitar riff as "Cherub Rock," and you liked "Cherub Rock" back in 1993. You still like it, because it is one of the best songs ever recorded. But now, instead of one guitar playing one riff, there are more—way more—guitars. And more riffs. It's awesome, in the original sense of the word. It might scare you.

Fear is the effect I'm going for. Fear and exhaustion. But "Tarantula" is not the scariest or most exhausting song on the album. That honor goes to "United States"—a triumphant teenage anthem that sounds like the closing solo of "War Pigs," refracted and stretched into nine minutes. Remember, I was subtle once: "Drown," from the Singles soundtrack, was haunting in its minimal, dissonant beauty. But the Zeitgeist has no time for subtlety, friends, and neither do you. Hence song titles like "United States" and "For God and Country" and "Pomp and Circumstance." Even more than you need more guitars, you need more meaning. And I bring it to you:

Dulcet tones whisper fast

Refuse your yearns, renounce the past

Rouse me soon, the end draws nigh

Whose side are you on

Your blood you cannot buy.

Revolution!

Revolution!

Revolution!

Yes! Zeitgeisty!

Every revolution needs a counterpoint, and that would be "Bring the Light," the one song with a discernable, singable hook, the one song that's remotely accessible. It's got a melody that burns with the same adolescent struggle as those Siamese Dream days. Naturally, it stands out: Hooks and singability are not really the zeitgeist. At least not this Zeitgeist.

Here is what you must understand: Nothing has changed since 1999, except my budget. And Pro Tools. I am still the same alt-rock messiah I was. You are still my teenage flock.

Trust me.

Your zero,

Billy Corgan
http://www.thestranger.com/seattle/Content?oid=262627

Tagged: The Smashing Pumpkins

Comments:Add a Comment 
antihippy
July 13th 2007
696 Comments


what a pretentious prat.

Daedelus
July 13th 2007
162 Comments


from other interviews i've read this is either

A.) A joke from him.

or

B.) A joke from someone else.

andy0
July 13th 2007
118 Comments


i think he's being half-serious but takin the piss at the same time, oh yes hes got some ego but i think hes just tryin to cause some reaction or somethin, who knows.................
but the new album is good, so who cares if he's a dick :P

Wizard
July 13th 2007
20627 Comments


Its almost as if he is covering his ass in case the album fails! Probably one of the worst albums Ive heard in a while, I might add.

711
July 13th 2007
1340 Comments


Idiot.

DaveBum69
July 13th 2007
699 Comments


This really seems like he's joking

astrel
July 13th 2007
2615 Comments


It would be better if it was actually funny.

thesystemisdown
July 13th 2007
416 Comments


This makes him sound like the most arrogant guy ever. "Best song ever?" Shut up, Corgan, MCR and Panic are hardly transparently inspired by you. If it's a joke, cool, but it's not clear enough.

RazorBladeLight
July 13th 2007
258 Comments


The album isn't all bad. This sounds hilarious despite the seriousness or the humerous side of the note. If it's true than he has an ego bigger than donald trump's, if false, than a funny, well-written letter that is bound to make people whine about how much they suck or how much zeitgeist was a letdown... you know, all those comments we've all grown to love from this site.

tribestros
July 13th 2007
918 Comments


This album isn't bad at all but it sounds as if he's spitting at his die-hard fans. And, hey MCR and Panic said they were inspired by the Pumpkins.

Why is he spitting at his own die-hard fans?

What is up with this guy?

StrizzMatik
July 13th 2007
4232 Comments


I almost fell over laughing when I read this. But hey, a few guys on sputnik have egos just as big as Corgan's so it's nothing new.

tribestros
July 13th 2007
918 Comments


He's gone delusional. That's all I can figure. Maybe he's completely lost his mind which is the reason for all his smiling and lack of creepy eye makeup.

BlindWriting
July 13th 2007
103 Comments


This is CLEARLY a joke written by the staff of the paper.This Message Edited On 07.13.07

sickjesus
July 13th 2007
163 Comments


what an ass hat. if he'd dropped another siamese dream this might be forgivable, but from what i've heard the new stuff is mediocre at best.

tribestros
July 13th 2007
918 Comments


Its a little bit better than mediocre. 3/5

Jimmy
July 13th 2007
736 Comments


This is great, Billy Corgan is the man! I read all of his interviews because he says amazing things.

"People are moshing for the wrong reasons"
"I truly believe that robots have feelings"
"Rock and roll is dead"

I completely agree with him on one point though... for almost every popular band out there today it seems obvious to me that the smashing pumpkins were a HUGE influence.

spoon_of_grimbo
July 13th 2007
2241 Comments


i just want to slap a load of caramel on his head and make him into a giant toffee apple, and then throw the fucker to the bees.

tribestros
July 13th 2007
918 Comments


Well think about it...rock n' roll hasn't been the same since the 90s when that statement was made.

The other two I got nothing.

HotSalvation
July 13th 2007
258 Comments


as to your question, no billy corgan is not serious.
yes, he has an ego, but not like that...go listen to his interviews sometime, he's almost a hippy from the way he talks about equal rights and equal love for everybody.

but what do I know, maybe this is the way he expresses his love.
frankly, I don't give a shit. I enjoy his music. the new cd is great on two conditions; You hear it with no mellon collie epic expectations and an open mind. and two, if you're not a blind deaf tard.

unless you don't like the sound of his voice in which case, nobody made you listen to him so shut up, you're out of your element.


Boddah
July 13th 2007
129 Comments


Pretentious prick.

descendents1
July 13th 2007
702 Comments


These are worse than youtube video comments.

tribestros
July 13th 2007
918 Comments


Yeah, I agree he may be strange and a bit idiotic at points, his music is good and so is Zeitgeist.

Aficionado
July 13th 2007
1027 Comments


Some funny news on Sputnik these days.

Electric City
July 13th 2007
15756 Comments


Ooooohhhh, he's crazy. That explains a lot.

Two-Headed Boy
July 13th 2007
4527 Comments


What a weenie. I laughed friggin hard at this.

Still a good musician though.

pulseczar
July 13th 2007
2385 Comments


This guy's got the weirdest ego complex ever.

Serpento
July 13th 2007
2351 Comments


Can you say "facepalm"?

br3ad_man
July 14th 2007
2126 Comments


I bring us, together, here, to the corner of Future Avenue and Now Street. This is our moment! This is our day! This is Zeitgeist!


lol

Pretty sure it's a joke though.

cjwbball51
July 14th 2007
14 Comments


maybe he released this letter just to get forums like this one talking. or maybe hes not that smart and is a dumbass arrogant prick.

muchtallerthanu
July 14th 2007
648 Comments


Seven years, seven months, and ten days ago, the clock struck midnight, 2000, and the world began turning faster. Back then, I disbanded the Smashing Pumpkins because the new millennium demanded it. A new age needed a new start—cleanliness and unity, not the confused, confusing wreck I let the band become.

We were once the most important band in the world, and everyone—me, you, Courtney Love—knew it.
:lol:


Ataraxia
July 14th 2007
59 Comments


Hey guys.

Satire.

tom79
July 14th 2007
3964 Comments


Zeitgeist (Say it! It feels good!)

lol

StrizzMatik
July 14th 2007
4232 Comments


He said "Zeitgeist-y". WHAT THE F*CK. What gave him the right to put a 'y' after any singular noun and use it in a sentence?

But yeah this is obviously a joke. He's definitely responding to everyone seemingly thinking of Zeitgeist as average (it's not) and making a jab at the old-schoolers that dislike the entire idea of them without Iha or D'Arcy (Who I find to be a little slow, I guess people forgot those two had virtually no input whatsoever into the music, just like Ginger, Lisa and Jeff of Pumpkins 2K7)

A_Guy
July 14th 2007
106 Comments


It's a joke everyone, The Stranger is a Seattle publication that does stuff like this all the time.

samthebassman
July 14th 2007
2164 Comments


Great work Billy, I still love ya.

dudeinthepassinglane
July 14th 2007
192 Comments


Exploding ego is right.

I just finally heard a snippet of the album though. Not bad. But it shouldn't be called Pumpkins.

JohnXDoesn't
July 15th 2007
1395 Comments


nah, thats not Corgan. joke, parody, whatever.....

emogangstascotty
July 18th 2007
472 Comments


Ego club = Tom Delonge, Jared Leto, Billy Corgan......

I heard the CD. Its good, but I agree it shoudnt be called Smashing....just Pumpkins.
Without James Iha and D'arcy, Billy is lost. This Message Edited On 07.17.07

HailToTheThief
July 21st 2007
144 Comments


Finally, some one who has to music to match the swagger.

forget those who hate the new album.

The Pumpkins are back and that's all that matters.

JAK1980
November 29th 2007
9 Comments


Hey guys, this letter was a hoax (Seattle Stranger published one other "open letter" a week later). Who here really believed that Corgan would publish that kind of crap on a Seattle newspaper ? C'mon guys, the zeitgeist wants you to read between the lines and double check so-called informations or you'll be fooled all the day.
But it's always funny to see how BC focuses critics from people who speak faster than they think, and write reviews faster than the music go to their heart and brain (if they have some).



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





MOST VIEWED NEWS

Jesse Lacey Allegations
Jayyvon Opens Up About Abuse
The Fall of Troy bassist melts do..
The Story So Far's vocalist dropk..
Deftones stream new single
R.I.P. Lemmy
Killswitch Engage debut new single
Scott Weiland dead at 48
Nothing But Thieves accusations
Lil Peep Dead At 21



OTHER RECENT NEWS

Miserere Luminis New Album
Beschwoerung let out debut LP
No/Mas tease new album
Blazon Stone are treasure hunting
Tigers Jaw's New Record/Song
A Circle Of Crows Fly 2nd Song
Let there be Hazardous dark
Above, Below go Interstellar
Teleost peruse atavism
Mors Verum tease new EP
Universe217 post new single
I, Forlorn's Eternal Winter
Future Palace are in Deep Blue
New Steve Morse Band album
2025 Year End Voting OPEN

» see all news

RELATED REVIEWS
The Smashing Pumpkins
Machina: Aranea Alba Editio
The Smashing Pumpkins
Live In Europe 1992
The Smashing Pumpkins
Aghori Mhori Mei
The Smashing Pumpkins
ATUM: Act III
The Smashing Pumpkins
ATUM: Act II
STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy