That just ruined my day. Horrible.

This song is terrible.

Song is great.

I like Billy. I hate that he's using SP as a creative outlet for his solo stuff just because Zwan and his solo album didn't sell.

But this song was terrible. Just terrible.

Song is good

wow.... that was horrendous

ugh

Not a fan, wasn't atrocious though.

not really that bad, but certainly not as good as 'a song for a son'.

I like the actual song, I'm just not crazy with how it was recorded.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Coh1BPe-3zQ&feature=related

That's how I wanted it to sound when it was recorded. Good n' simple.
I mean, yeah, it's a poppy song, but they went overboard with all the dopey keyboards and that sort of lame piano bridge.

song is awful. And the Pumpkins are my absolute favourite band.

Hilarious, maybe this is his comedy album

i heard this last night and though "what happened Billy" this song is terrible

I didn't really HATE it. Its ok I guess.

pretty music box bullshit

Should read: "New Billy Corgan Song"

That was pretty fucking awful...

C'est une chanson terrible.

Not as good as song for a son, but its not that bad.

Edit: The version Two-Headed Boy posted is better

These guys are getting a little too old.

Était-ce à ce point mauvais?

Je ne comprends pas

This was pretty bad

»» Was that as bad as that

The Pumpkins were never that good but now that Corgan has completely lost it and is recording these
songs that leave his fucking AWFUL voice really high in the mix, well it just sounds ugly

vocals are really annoying. i like the song...probably more than i thought i would.

fuck man, that is a really bad song

i kinda enjoyed song for a son.

not this tho.



WHAT ARE YOU THINKING, CORGAN

You know, during the 20th Anniversary shows, I was starting to think Bill was coming back to Earth.

Then he starts hanging around a bunch of stoned fucking groupies and it's all going downhill from there. This may be the worst song ever written.

A Song for a Son was ok but this...i mean my god. I really want to like this new stuff but this song is dog shit.

Well he's still got 42 more chances to pull a good song out of his ass.

This is wow.... this isn't the pumpkins I know.

they haven't been the pumpkins you 'knew' since lightyears ago.

^You realise lightyears measure distance and not time right?

what are you guys talking about, this is musical bliss right here. totally excellent, 5 stars easiely.

Jesus, I used to like this band.

well, they used to be good. The beginning of A Song For a Son was really pretty...then he fucked it up..

I don't know what everyone's complaining about, the song wasn't NEARLY as bad as people are saying - It's not amazing, but I mean, it's passable. Remember, there's going to be 40+ songs in all, and they can't all be classics.

Plus, Song for a son is great, I love it.