Top 50 Albums of 2017: Voting Open

2017-12-11 by Jom STAFF | 67 Comments
Greetings, friends: it's that time once again for you to have your say!

Voting is now open for the Top 50 LPs of 2017 feature.

As in years past, we will also be including EPs in a separate category. We heard your feedback from last year, so for the EPs section, you may also include Compilations and Live Albums.

There is a new twist this year with voting (courtesy of resident Statnik macman), so for details, check out the ballot submission thread here:

[Ballots are closed! Thanks for participating. If you forgot to submit a ballot, shoutbox Jom.]

Tagged: Sputnikmusic

Comments:Add a Comment 
bloc
December 11th 2017
46091 Comments


Fuck this is always a challenge for me. Especially since I don't come around to my yearly favourites after months and it's too late to make a decision

But oh shit, I like this new points system

Digging: Carly Rae Jepsen - Emotion

Jom
Staff Reviewer
December 11th 2017
3036 Comments


>> But oh shit, I like this new points system

All credit goes to statnikmac for wanting to try something new!

doomes
December 11th 2017
242 Comments


before voting you guys should listen to the new pole younger album which hasn't come out yet but it will soon and looks like aoty is finally here

Wildcardbitchesss
December 11th 2017
259 Comments


Links are broken or I'm retarded

TwigTW
December 11th 2017
2887 Comments


Links are broken[2]

Digging: Nadah El Shazly - Ahwar

SandwichBubble
December 11th 2017
5179 Comments


Macman bringing this site to the 21st century of AOTY voting

Digging: The Keyhole - The Way In

SteakByrnes
December 11th 2017
5829 Comments


Will post my top ten in the forum in about an hour

doomes
December 11th 2017
242 Comments


but i haven't uploaded my album yet and it's 30 minutes long, you need to rearrange your schedule

dbizzles
December 11th 2017
10782 Comments


Fuck yeah. I will go through my ratings and put this together. Great year for music.

doomes
December 11th 2017
242 Comments


too bad you stopped making artwork for my records

doomes
December 11th 2017
242 Comments


we should work on summink next year

doomes
December 11th 2017
242 Comments


https://poleyounger.bandcamp.com/album/-

aoty is now

Toondude10
December 11th 2017
11895 Comments


shit, I'm not prepared yet, now I have to bullshit through my ratings.

Digging: Dead Letter Circus - This Is The Warning

Ignimbrite
December 11th 2017
6287 Comments


brb putting 91 points on Lil Pump

Digging: Employed to Serve - The Warmth Of A Dying Sun

macman76
Staff Reviewer
December 11th 2017
1934 Comments


Motivation for the new scoring system:

Whenever I read articles or listen to pods/interviews with people struggling to rank things, it’s often because they usually don’t like the big drop-offs or tiers that they see in the quality of whatever they’re ranking. It’s still not super accurate, but it makes sense to appropriate points rather than rankings to relieve this issue.

macman76
Staff Reviewer
December 11th 2017
1934 Comments


Also, inspired by this https://electology.org/score-voting

It might end in disaster, but I wouldn’t mind it for government elections

Toondude10
December 11th 2017
11895 Comments


are you compiling all the points together yourself?

macman76
Staff Reviewer
December 11th 2017
1934 Comments


Yeah, but Jom wrote up the instructions and is gonna help clean up the entries. It’s always a group effort

SteakByrnes
December 11th 2017
5829 Comments


I wish you guys the best of luck compiling all of the information together

Jom
Staff Reviewer
December 11th 2017
3036 Comments


mac has the technical knowledge and experience; I just have the patience to fix all the screwed-up entries. Rather than waiting on people to fix them, I'll just get them all at the end so mac is working with as clean of data as he can.

Papa Universe
December 11th 2017
10518 Comments


are you in contect with mx at all?

Digging: Horna / Pure - Split

starboystargirl
December 11th 2017
263 Comments


Link is broke.

fix this god damn site god damn it

ZombieToyDuck
December 11th 2017
3277 Comments


he says you gotta copy and paste it not click it

Digging: Tonight Alive - Underworld

Jom
Staff Reviewer
December 11th 2017
3036 Comments


>> are you in contect with mx at all?

we try to contect with him on the ragular

just depends on how busyboi he is

dbizzles
December 11th 2017
10782 Comments


ALL WRIT UP, THX

brainmelter
December 11th 2017
4856 Comments


IT IS TIME

Digging: Elephant Gym - ??WORK

loulou
December 11th 2017
66 Comments


Link is broken, Am I the only one?

BlackwaterPork
December 11th 2017
3026 Comments


Nope

Digging: Summoning - Oath Bound

zaruyache
December 11th 2017
18267 Comments


"[NOTE: please copy-paste the links, since clicking on one leads to yet another reminder that something is broken here.]"


nobody ever listens to me when I say it but I'll say it for the millionth time:
stop using https links since sput hates those. Use a regular www link and it'll work fine.

dbizzles
December 11th 2017
10782 Comments


inb4 Sach submits:

1_Chief Keef_Thot Breaker 100

SandwichBubble
December 11th 2017
5179 Comments


Use a regular www link and it'll work fine [2]
or you can make it an http link. sputnik hates security

zaruyache
December 11th 2017
18267 Comments


sput's an https site automatically now so w/e link you click will just redirect to https anyway

neekafat
December 11th 2017
8084 Comments


When does this close? Trying to get my cram-list done :/

SandwichBubble
December 11th 2017
5179 Comments


"Submissions will be accepted until the 18th at the earliest and 20th at the latest."

neekafat
December 11th 2017
8084 Comments


Oh I see I'm dumb (:

SandwichBubble
December 11th 2017
5179 Comments


No problem

BlackMalachite
December 11th 2017
2361 Comments


Alright guys voted for Falling in Reverse, we're all good.

Digging: Black Veil Brides - Vale

JohnnyOnTheSpot
Staff Reviewer
December 11th 2017
6489 Comments


disqualified due to improper formatting, best of luck for next year tho ^

theBoneyKing
December 11th 2017
13477 Comments


Question: If you choose to give all your albums 10 points, is your ranking irrelevant, or are both the rankings and the point values themselves being taken into account?

Digging: Lambchop - Nixon

Jasdevi087
December 11th 2017
4728 Comments


disgusting fucking list as always snide, well done

Jom
Staff Reviewer
December 11th 2017
3036 Comments


>> Question: If you choose to give all your albums 10 points, is your ranking irrelevant, or are both the rankings and the point values themselves being taken into account?

Door #2.

BlackMalachite
December 11th 2017
2361 Comments


"disqualified due to improper formatting, best of luck for next year tho ^"
=[

Divaman
December 11th 2017
1719 Comments


While I appreciate the innovation, I don't like the new points system. I'd rather just rank.

Digging: The High Kings - Decade: The Best of the High Kings

macman76
Staff Reviewer
December 11th 2017
1934 Comments


@divaman living up to your name lol.

Jom didn’t mention it in his instructions, but if someone forgets to give scores, I’ll assign default values to the ranks I.e your highest rank will have more points than your lowest ranked album

theBoneyKing
December 11th 2017
13477 Comments


I'm on the same page as Divaman. While in theory the points system could help lesser-known albums I can't help but feel the opposite will happen and more popular albums will just snuff others out even more.

Divaman
December 11th 2017
1719 Comments


I'm going to do it the way everyone else is this year, but thanks for the option macman. I'm just saying that for the future, I prefer the straight ranking system. (In my case, it won't make that much of a difference anyway, as I'm pretty sure only two of the albums I'm including in my Top Ten will have much chance to be included in the site's Top 50).

Dewinged
December 12th 2017
7593 Comments


Done and done!

Digging: The Go! Team - Semicircle

Jom
Staff Reviewer
December 12th 2017
3036 Comments


>> Jom didn’t mention it in his instructions

... people who don't follow them aren't getting special treatment.

Why's everybody under the gun to get this done ASAP? You have all week! Go listen to more records.


macman76
Staff Reviewer
December 12th 2017
1934 Comments


I’m at the mercy of what clears the jom filter 😬

Sevengill
December 12th 2017
7811 Comments


eh, few if any of the albums in my top 50 are going to be on here.

Digging: Harakiri for the Sky - Arson

dbizzles
December 12th 2017
10782 Comments


'disqualified due to improper formatting, best of luck for next year tho'

Yes, you have to submit a band and album not a steaming pile of unicorn diarrhea.

doomes
December 12th 2017
242 Comments


"Go listen to more records"

thanks for promoting pole younger, could use a link in the end tho

it's https://poleyounger.bandcamp.com

SowingSeason
Moderator
December 12th 2017
25425 Comments


Fixed the links so you can click on them directly now.

I am just reading up on the new points system and I like it.

Digging: Camila Cabello - Camila

d3vianc3
December 12th 2017
35 Comments


wow ppl voting before new aa album drop smh

dbizzles
December 12th 2017
10782 Comments


If AA stands for Asking Alexandria, make sure you have your vote in, specifically, on December 32nd.

gryndstone
December 12th 2017
904 Comments


People voting before the new XCX mixtape wyd

not a huge fan of the points system, but i'm not complaining either

Kompys2000
December 12th 2017
1222 Comments


Why can't I post my votes?

Digging: Typhoon (USA-OR) - Offerings

Dewinged
December 12th 2017
7593 Comments


"a steaming pile of unicorn diarrhea" I am dying on this haha

Drubbi
December 12th 2017
212 Comments


Are we still doing that user-contribution blurb thing from last year? Was cool to take part in.

Jom
Staff Reviewer
December 12th 2017
3036 Comments


>> Why can't I post my votes?

Kompys: you never confirmed your e-mail, so you were stuck in account limbo. You should be all set to post now. Thanks!

>> Are we still doing that user-contribution blurb thing from last year? Was cool to take part in.

Yes, that will still be a thing!

someguest
December 12th 2017
29227 Comments


Ten LPs? Can the userbase count that high? You're asking a lot, Jom.

Kompys2000
December 13th 2017
1222 Comments


Ayy thanks Jom my dude

PistolPete
December 13th 2017
4557 Comments


Is it weird I look forward to this as it's the one time of year Jom really comes out of hiding and comments/posts?

New point system is awesome btw. Alright I'm done being a suck up

Digging: Altar of Plagues - Teethed Glory and Injury

theBoneyKing
December 13th 2017
13477 Comments


Am I, hypothetically, allowed to award more points to an album lower in the ranking than an album with fewer points?

neekafat
December 13th 2017
8084 Comments


I assume so yes Boney

DoofusWainwright
Contributing Reviewer
December 14th 2017
17245 Comments


someone has already tried tactical voting Boney, noticed that

Lucid
December 14th 2017
8924 Comments


i got tactical with it, that ain't my actual ranking



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





MOST VIEWED NEWS

Jesse Lacey Allegations
R.I.P. Chester Bennington
Brand new Brand New record
Black Malachite calls it quits
Glassjaw - Material Control info
The Old Taylor is Dead
Lil Peep Dead At 21
RIP Tom Petty
Decapitated accused of rape
Converge Release New Single



OTHER RECENT NEWS

2018 Applications Open
Pop Evil's Colors Bleed
GosT streams new track
Bleed from Within are 'Alive'
New Primordial LP/Song
New Machine Head Song
BTBAM Release New Track
First new Cog in a decade
Hot Snakes Return
The Eels Deconstruct
Decemberists New Album/Single
New Visigoth Single
Silverstein Suffer Whiplash
Skin of Cecile stream Ars Moriendi
BTBAM Announce Double Album

» see all news


STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy