noooo!!!

Yeah, like Maynard's gonna be busy recording the new Tool album or something...

APC use to be my favorite band. I havn't listened to them again, but they got me
into more 'diffrent' music.This Message Edited On 05.18.06

I think Billy was always holding back his material until he had MJK on-board each time.

Now he's going it alone, at least we can expect more material that is of an APC nature, even if its not under the same name. Billy's voice may not be MJK, but the signature APC sound always came from Billy anyway

I never did like APC... not sure what it was, but I just couldn't get into them....
Oh well, as long as Tool dosen't break up

good. Emotive was crap.

Tool is a lot better anyways. It is good they are breaking apart.

Folks, learn to read. There is in no way clearly stated that APC break up. People should know by now that projects that Maynard works on always go on longer breaks. Between "13th Step" and "Mer de Noms" were 3 years, since Lateralus 5 years passed.

I think you should all chill, and safe the chaos for a time when the end of APC is officially and definately. And not just a "We won't be working on new APC material now"

[/rant]

Emotive wasn't great although Passive was a good song. APC or not, Billy Howerdel is a good songwriter so I'm interested in what he's come up with.

I only really liked 13th step but I liked it alot

havnt heard Emotive

it is better this way... mer de noms and thirteenth step were amazing, but then they just started going downhill... i agree, emotive was crap.

only good song on emotive is 'passive', 13th step and Mer De Noms' are freakin sweet, Emotive isnt good.

They introduce a new way of music, they made a perfect combination with the music and the vocals of Maynard, very inspirational music and lyrics.

Then what CD are you talking about? it better not be eMotive, because i didn't like that one as much as the other two

i wouldn't say emotive was crap....sure, it wasn't on the same level at all as mer de noms and thirteenth step, but considering the fact that most of the songs on there were covers, i think it was pretty good for what it was trying to do... besides, APC's version of imagine is way better than the original...

i agree

havent heard emotive but thirteenth step is just bloody brilliant. it always makes me get that big love feeling inside. it just so good!!!! i got into them in late-2007. a long time after APC left the world. hope they will come back but if they don't at least they've got two great albums to their name.

well commenting on this 2 yrs after the topic started, apc has officially ended their career together. i personally think that emotive was an amazing album, the reason i can see why most of you would think otherwise is because it's not really APC. all the songs on emotive with exception to passive and counting bodies like sheep were cover songs. and the vocals on fiddle and the drum were phenomenal. i wouldn't go as far as to say that imagine was better than the original by john lennon, that's pushing it, but it was an amazing album i think.