Great band releases another great song. If I'm being honest it doesn't quite live up to the best from A Black Mile to the Surface, but it's still beautiful just in a more delicate, less polished way.
|
| |
Gorgeous song. Yeah, it doesn't quite live up to the absolute best of A Black Mile but it definitely would have been a favourite had it been featured.
|
| |
I never listened to them before, but I always thought they were actually an orchestra. I'm mildly disappointed.
|
| |
wow, this is incredible
|
| |
Absolutely beautiful, my SOTY so far.
Fuck I love this band so much.
|
| |
Very nice. Would have been up there with Silence and Wolf as the best from the album
|
| |
I think people are underselling what a great closer 'The Silence' was and still is. This song is great, and I think it would have further bolstered Black Mile had they found a spot for it on the tracklisting, but I'm glad they didn't sub this in for The Silence. That song gives me chills every time.
|
| |
yeah The Silence is a fantastic closer don't get me wrong. I guess it's just that if they added this in the final tracklist it would've been the cherry on top for me.
|
| |
Yeah I could've gotten behind that I suppose
|
| |
-round of applause- I almost wish it was there now.
|
| |
It's beautiful, Manchester Orchestra has been a band I've been following since 2011. I thank my brother for getting me into them.
|
| |
It's good but I struggle to think of where it would fit on Black Mile. It's a great b-side, though I think After the Scripture still bests it in that category
|
| |
It couldn't fit, but I could see this as a bonus track.
|
| |
prolly gonna slide this on there instead of the Mistake if I'm being honest
|
| |
I initially agreed with Rowan but thought it wouldn't make sense in the tracklisting. Then I relistened. Yeah, swap this with The Mistake directly and a great album gets even better
|
| |
I can't say that would work. Keeping in mind the album's story is a coal worker who ends up mass-murdering people, it's hard to see where this song fits in. It's a good song, but removing "The Mistake" to make room would hurt the narrative flow.
|
| |
there is no explicit narrative tho Andy has said as much
if there was if anything this song would be more important to the album, the chorus resolves one of the major lines in The Maze, it melodically follows on from the trilogy etc
|
| |
Gonna reconstruct Black Mile with this song as well, but not sure how yet. It was already my album of 2017, so it's intriguing to think it could get better.
|
| |
There's more of an implied narrative. It's hard to ignore the lyrics detailing as much.
|
| |
Take out The Maze and The Parts, and have I Know How To Speak in as a separate mini EP.
After the Scripture (and 42 from Bad Books II) to take the place of The Parts in ABMTTS.
The three songs are the most personal for Andy and belong in their own little triple, like Alien/Sunshine/Grocery in ABMTTS.
ABMTTS was my AOTY last year, but I'd love to have seen the original concept of "songs from 100 years of a houses occupants" that was the original plan.
|
| |
Dude lives and breathes great lyrics and songwriting.
|
| |
Lovely song
|
| |
"I'd love to have seen the original concept of "songs from 100 years of a houses occupants" that was the original plan."
that almost sounds like La Dispute's Rooms of the House
|
| |
I'd definitely put this on the album. It's a bit of an uplifting track, and it kinda contrasts with all the gloom and doom.
|
| |
I'm currently liking it in place of The Parts.
|
| |
I could see this as a hidden track or bonus somewhere.
|
| |
Amazing
|
| |
Soty for me
|
| |
7” release was announced, it’s on their store!!
|
| |
