took me fucking ages so check it out
|
| |
checking now!
|
| |
Kinda surprised Endgame wasn't on there.
|
| |
List is alright... I strongly disagree with many of them, but am glad to see some new faces like The Pax Cecilia and Have A Nice Life.
|
| |
1 and 2 deserve it.
pretty good list nonetheless.
|
| |
good.
|
| |
took me fucking ages so check it out
If you re-edit the news article I think you can extend the title character length if you think it is sitting awkward.
|
| |
lot of good albums on there, but meh
|
| |
9 should be 1.
|
| |
If you re-edit the news article I think you can extend the title character length if you think it is sitting awkward.
What do you mean?
|
| |
45 and 46 should be higher.atleast above btbam.isis should've made the cut
|
| |
fuckin jane doe
|
| |
What do you mean?
well I thought you might have been going for R&M's "Top" Albums of the Decade for a news title
|
| |
oh right, yeah that's a good idea, i'll fix that now 
|
| |
OH WHAT A SUPRISE CONVERGE FIRST
fagz
|
| |
Points Received: 11
Isis – Panopticon
Lame. Should be higher.
|
| |
jane doe first.. yuck. Glad Crimson 2 made it in the top 20, doesnt get enough recognition compared to the likes of As the Roots undo and Bath.
|
| |
wtf Jane Doe ****ing rules **** you
|
| |
Jane Doe wins. We are all so surprised...
|
| |
Kinda surprised Blackwater Park isn't in the top 5
|
| |
idk i'm not as the regular forum users *generally* have waaaay better taste than the review site and so
|
| |
hot!
|
| |
i'm pretty pleased with the list, lots of good albums were mentioned, though of course with any collective thing like this some people will be disappointed. the criticism so far mentioned here is ridiculous though, i dont doubt a better list would be extremely hard to find, especially one with the opinions of the reviews site.
though there's some stupid fucking shit on here, like mastodon coming ahead of neurosis
|
| |
i like this list for the most part.
but traced in air is 11th
|
| |
traced in air sux
|
| |
I thought Madvillainy was pretty random.
|
| |
traced in air sux
my point exactly
|
| |
I thought BWP would be a very strong #2.
|
| |
no surprises here
|
| |
I thought BWP would be a very strong #2.
Traced in Air made it work really hard in the second round too.
no surprises here
there were quite a few surprises actually, some good some bad
|
| |
awesome, some surprising picks though
|
| |
traced in air sux
no it does not poop head
|
| |
traced in air is lame
|
| |
Kris is lame.
The fact that Lost Horizon made it on the list (21) made me like extremely happy.
|
| |
greg is lame
|
| |
The fact that Lost Horizon made it on the list (21) made me like extremely happy.
you and some other dude did give it like 10 points each so i'm sure that had something to do with it
|
| |
Pretty content with this list
|
| |
you and some other dude did give it like 10 points each so i'm sure that had something to do with it
Oh shit, well woo us lol.
|
| |
pretty surprised MLIW is up that high.
and no Kidcrash, what the fuck?
|
| |
lol jane doe lol
|
| |
lol pretty much all the albums you like lol
|
| |
damn rasputin beat me to it
|
| |
*Generic Sputnik List*
lol jk! some of those albums are really good.
|
| |
deleted
|
| |
nicely done berkay, glad I participated
|
| |
oh and I'm so happy Madvillian ended up at 12, didn't see that coming
|
| |
Converge are gods amongst men. I listen to them every single day :D
|
| |
Um what no Worship And Tribute, Everything You Wanted To Know About Silence, The Illusion Of Safety, or Full Collapse (and that's only my own glaring omissions)? And Jane Doe is the best album of the decade? FUCKING FAIL
|
| |
nice work rasputin.
|
| |
lol at the idea of either Thrice or Glassjaw making one of the best albums of the decade.
|
| |
Um what no Worship And Tribute, Everything You Wanted To Know About Silence, The Illusion Of Safety, or Full Collapse (and that's only my own glaring omissions)? And Jane Doe is the best album of the decade? FUCKING FAIL
did not vote, stfu
|
| |
What a fucking surprise
|
| |
Shitty list is shitty. I don't understand why everyone loves metal so much.
|
| |
i'm kinda unimpressed there was no Lady GaGa in the top 50
|
| |
1 and 2 totally deserve it. I would have switched them, but both rule
|
| |
i'm kinda unimpressed there was no Lady GaGa in the top 50
I voted.
No Nick Cave either.
|
| |
checking it out now
|
| |
really happy that circle takes the square was up there
|
| |
Really good list. Not surprising that Jane Doe topped it up, not my favourite but hey. Hey.
Most of my top 2000's albums are on here so I'm happy. Good work, forums.
|
| |
Good list, nice to see Close To A World Below up near the top
|
| |
interesting......
|
| |
such a sputnik list
whole 50 should just be everything toby driver has done and everything he's going to do
|
| |
List is good although I kinda expected Opeth to be higher. Also Jane Doe's victory margin is astonishingly high really.
|
| |
I think the list is pretty good, minus the Jane Doe nonsense.
So happy R&M knows there Hip Hop and picked Madvillain – Madvilliany. Probably the best Hip Hop album of the decade.
|
| |
lol okay
|
| |
Oh brillant review site goer, what would you pick otherwise?
@Roach.
|
| |
are you talking to me because
|
| |
Oh I see your actually on the forums.
|
| |
nvm
Cannibal Ox
Deltron 3030
Cyne
Black Milk
Eminem
Dalek
The Roots
Orphans of Cush
Raekwon
etc etc
|
| |
there's a link to the list at the end of the article are you retarded
|
| |
eh? you don't have to sign in to the forums to view the list
|
| |
though there's some stupid fucking shit on here, like mastodon coming ahead of neurosis
This.
|
| |
better than anything than the people who only frequent the review site could come up with fo sho
|
| |
Of course, that's obvious.
Cannibal Ox
Deltron 3030
Cyne
Black Milk
Eminem
Dalek
The Roots
Orphans of Cush
Raekwon
All of em are great but you'd be tripping if you didn't think MadVillian wasn't up there with em.
|
| |
Who snuck Blind Guardian into #50? Because nicely done.
Should have voted
|
| |
lol at the idea of either Thrice or Glassjaw making one of the best albums of the decade.
a.) LOL at the idea of Worship And Tribute not being one of the best albums of the decade
b.) I never go on the forums ever so I had no idea this was going on
|
| |
Actually... not a fail
|
| |
I'm not a forum-goer either, so maybe I'm out of line for being confused... but if this was supposed to be rock and metal, then why are their hip-hop albums on the list???
Also, The Opposite of December is somewhere way near the bottom, but it doesn't fit the criteria because it was released in the 90s. Also, the fact that Tear From the Red made it on the list yet You Come Before You and The Tropic Rot did not is unacceptable. I didn't vote, so this is just my opinion, but You Come Before You is certainly a glaring ommission in my book.
|
| |
It's the regular R&M goers, so if the Punk, ALT + Indie, Hip Hop, and Other section of the forums were polled they would show different results. That's not to say ppl who frequent sections other than R&M didn't vote though.
|
| |
All of em are great but you'd be tripping if you didn't think MadVillian wasn't up there with em.
its up there sure i just disagree with it being the clear best
|
| |
This might be the most sputnik'd out list ever.
|
| |
Did Jane Doe really win? *barf*. I knew this place was full of Converge fanboys but damn. You guys really are mediocre music fellators.
hey everybody, let's all laugh at the 10 albums Userword thinks are the best of the decade
1. Lost Horizon - A Flame to the Ground Beneath
2. Blind Guardian - A Night at the Opera
3. Wintersun - Wintersun
4. Cynic - Traced in Air
5. Summoning - Oath Bound
6. Psycroptic - Scepter of Ancients
7. Agalloch - Ashes Against the Grain
8. Symphony X - Paradise Lost
9. Sonata Arctica - Silence
10. Gorod - Leading Vision
LOL
|
| |
mediocre music fellators
|
| |
1. Lost Horizon - A Flame to the Ground Beneath
2. Blind Guardian - A Night at the Opera
3. Wintersun - Wintersun
4. Cynic - Traced in Air
5. Summoning - Oath Bound
6. Psycroptic - Scepter of Ancients
7. Agalloch - Ashes Against the Grain
8. Symphony X - Paradise Lost
9. Sonata Arctica - Silence
10. Gorod - Leading Vision
hahaha oh wow
|
| |
The only one I really cared about was 1. 2-10 was just filler.
And I'm sure you two would have Blackwater Park and Hornets of the Pogrom in your top 10.
i didn't vote for blackwater park but it's a better album than every single one in your list
i dunno why you keep trying to defend yourself, i've voided your opinion on pretty much everything about 4 times now. maybe you should go back to being top of your class in high school, leave listening to good music for the grown ups
|
| |
I totally missed this, guess I should visit the forums more.
Kinda surprised Blackwater Park is only 10th tbh. Mine would probably be (in no order)
Blind Guardian - A Night at the Opera
Coheed and Cambria - In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3
Converge - Jane Doe
Glassjaw - Everything You Ever Wanted to Know about Silence
Glassjaw - Worship and Tribute
Godspeed you! Black Emperor - Slow Riot For New Zero Kanada
Kayo Dot - Choirs of the Eye
maudlin of the Well - Bath
Opeth - Blackwater Park
Thrice - Vheissu
A bit stereotypical actual.
|
| |
Deathconsciousness and Close to a World Below ranking above BWP makes me sad. Even given the typical R&M tastes, those 2 albums surprised me. I would have had Paradise Lost in my top 10 probably, but it didn't make the top 50 but thats just one of those things I guess. Also, I can't believe Blind Guardian made the top 50 but I suppose they've always had quite a following on mx, even though it seems to be much less so now.
|
| |
Roach: "lol at the idea of either Thrice or Glassjaw making one of the best albums of the decade."
# 45 is Vheissu. Are you lol-ing now?
|
| |
you guys need to realise that with the system of voting all it took was two people to give an album a high score for it to be in the top 50. only 30 - 35 people contributed.
|
| |
True that raputin. I think next time, there should be some word of it on the review site (unless there was and I missed it, in which case ignore this). I never go on the forums and had no idea this was happening.
Still, it's a decent list considering the minimal amount of input. I wouldn't say there's a bad album in the top 50 (although there are several I haven't heard, but their average scores are high here so....)
|
| |
I think the reviews site is going to be doing their own one. If we had included reviews site users it wouldn't necessarily be R&M's opinion anyway, though I didn't stop/exclude votes by people who weren't regular posters, I just didn't advertise the poll.
|
| |
did not vote, stfu
ha!
|
| |
^^ Not really bothered by that as I find Sputnik >>>>>>>>>>>>> Forums
|
| |
Good, stay there, enjoy the idiots.
|
| |
But since you have 2000+ posts here you qualify to be one yourself or is my math off
|
| |
Ehh I've never been a huge fan of Converge. *prepares for hate*
But CTTS is fucking respectable.
|
| |
But since you have 2000+ posts here you qualify to be one yourself or is my math off
Even more reason for what he's saying to be right. I agree with him completely.
|
| |
actually, I realized the true problem with this list.
No The Microphones- The Glow Pt. 2
CMON
|
| |
It got something like 10 points still! I voted for it at the very least, and I think it got a few points from someone else too.
|
| |
i'm still confused at Kidcrash- Jokes not even being mentioned.
riddle me this Rasputin
|
| |
JANE DOE
|
| |
