So sales officially makes a band good? Wow.
Where the hell is Rush?

Curious as to how all those bands got over 450 when it appears that that is the maximum score.

AS much as I like seeing Zeppelin top a "best" list, your article comes off as really biased.

Completely and utterly ridiculous. "Best" lists already suck, but this one reaches new heights of stupidity. It's a bunch of BS is what it is. Absolutely craptastic.....

EDIT: Queen, lol...Metallica...hahahaThis Message Edited On 06.29.06

QUeen is logical they are in their the are great in fact I think they should go higher, and Led Zeppelin should be lower.

I can't believe that no talent ass clown Bob Marley is up there...No Who? No Rush? No Nirvana (Even though I'm not the biggest fan)?

Blows ass does this list

rush is #14^^^^ if u would look at the web site

I like Van Halen....they shouldn't be on that list though. Neither should the Eagles, Metallica or Marley.

Why are the Black Eyed Peas in the top 100? I didn't expect to see Primus or the Roots though. STP is pretty damn high too. How did Rage get a 26 for live performance, their shows are insane and I hear the Roots shows are intense also.This Message Edited On 06.29.06

The Black Eyed Peas were only ten spots lower than radiohead and the Dixie Chicks were higher than Lynyrd Skynyrd.

I don't totally agree with this list.
I don't see how Bob Marley or Van Halen can be on the Top 10.
I was, on the other hand, glad to see Tool and Radiohead on there, they could've been higher up, but whatever. It's just a poll.

Its no surprise a band of Led Zeps calibour would top a list such as this. Its just al the bands poeple collectively love really, with Pink flyod, the Beatles and such like. Very generic.

Red Hot Chili peppers were ranked very low, very odd.This Message Edited On 06.29.06

Surprised at all the Marley hate. He should actually be closer to the top, and is one of a small handful who truly deserve to be on any "best of" list....

You people have no culture :pThis Message Edited On 06.29.06

Id say that nobody has the right to say whos the top 10 bands of all time. words wise i think the best time for music was the 60s and early 70s. It has the most soul. What Led Zeppelin did was incredible. every album was made so good. i mean they suposibly sold their souls, so i suppose their music should be good

This list is definately a load of Bullsh*t even though I like to see Led Zeppelin on top. How did Van Halen get on there?
U2 don't even deserve a spot in the top 100, let alone 10.

Where the f*ck are deep purple, black sabbath, Rhcp, Nirvanna? Absoulute Sh*t

How the fuck is this news? This list is shit and Robert Plant/Jimmy Page are shit. Songwritting? Fucking lol.

I'll respect their opinion it could be alot worse. Like have Nirvana in the top 25.
Ha Frank Zappa got 5 for album sales, poor dude. Oh god didn't see ones and stuff.
I just disagree with their score for the Stones but whatever.This Message Edited On 06.29.06

Rofl @ The Bee Gees having more technical ability than Radiohead and The Rolling Stones. Also, the lack of Stevie Ray Vaughn is disturbing.This Message Edited On 06.29.06

i only agree with the first 4 of the top ten and some of the ones out of 100. Bob Marlkey wtf man.

The Eagles are on it, so the list can automatically be dismissed.

Rush sucks...thats why they aint on there...U2 sucks too but oh well...im suprised Aerosmith or The Rolling Stones didnt get on there, they've been round for a very long time and were stong forces back in the day

Rush sucks...thats why they aint on there...

Yes at #19. Black Sabbath at #70.

Thumbs up avrev.com

This list could have been alot worse, but still the Black Eyed Peas have had like 2 albums. Has anyone in the black eyed peas played an instrument ever?This Message Edited On 06.29.06

the stone temple pilots score over the chilis in both technical ability and innovation..

Thats because RHCP suck.
Yes is great. Prog needs to stop being shit on.

Dude, who cares what these douche bags think. I mean, look at the list, these aholes think record sales make a band Great or worth listening too. Songs/songwriting, live performance, and consistency vs. longetivity should be worth way more points.


what a bunch of dildos.This Message Edited On 07.01.06

'Well a good band gets there record sold a bad band doesn't, I too only buy albums of the truly great bands and if everyone did that the list would be better ;)

bad bands get records sold. Panic! At The Disco must be selling some records (not the only examples).

led zeppelin the beatles and floyd dont surprise me all the rest do though. actually i can understand marley he sold so many albums and almost all of his records were highly praised and bringing reggae to the mainstream
pretty dumb list songwiting,live performance,and all that is important but sales should have been lower.

Awful

I couldnt beleive the Black eye peas where on their, poor really.

zeppeling, floyd, the beatles all deserve to be there.

eagles are there due to hotel california being the best selling album ever, i dont think van halen should be there, i think there shit, but many people do like them. Queen are one of teh greatest bands ever, and should be higher, hendrix is teh greatest guitarist ever, and has influenced millions of people, so no suprises.

I only think U2 shoudlnt be on there, ive never thought they were great.

Edit: My bad.This Message Edited On 06.30.06

Crappy list. Wheres the stripes if the black eyed pies can make it on.This Message Edited On 06.30.06

Yay Led Zeppelin!

eagles are there due to hotel california being the best selling album ever,

Van Halen with a higher technical ability than Yes? As a band?

Wasn't happy to see The Velvet Underground and the Kinks so much lower than the Dixie Chicks, but you know, it's opinion. And with album sales thrown into the grading scale... whatever.

I could think of a ton of bands much more consistant than Van Halen or Led Zeppelin. Both of those got really mediocre in their later years. Stones and Beach Boys really should've been top ten.

Led Zeppelin Kicks ass but not that much.
Also why the hell is Metallica and Van Halen on here?
THEY SUCK BIG DONKEY COCK!

ahh come on weres the classic acdc ikinow led zeplin were good and do deserve to be in the top ten of the rock history but acdc were classic guitar solos and everything shameful!!!!!!!!!!

why the fuck is Van Halen on here?!
and where's the Who?!!!