I'm actually looking forward to this. Their albums were very weak, but not their singles.

Well, a group with very little talent, singing songs they did not write, and selling sex to sell records and the various other products girl groups are alined with, getting back together years after, looks going, with the same talent level as before, am I missing something here, or did some record head make another large mistake. This Message Edited On 09.20.06

Actually, only one of the groups members wrote anything of major importance on both their self-titled and their follow up. One out of four, co-writing music with a producer, does not seem all that significant in terms of resigning a whole group.

Sputnik is in hard times when Mods are amongst the most immature people on the site...

I made my point, you made a feeble attempt to contradict it, and I pointed out the flaw with your argument. That is debating, learn to do it without making lame comments that point out your age.

Muisee's claims:

-Talentless

Opinion

- Looks fading

Opinion

- Not writing thier own music

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saints_%26_Sinners

Three tracks on the album were produced by William Orbit, known for his work with Madonna including the first single "Pure Shores" which was written for The Beach movie. The vast majority of the songs were written by Shaznay Lewis and Karl Gordon and some contributions by Melanie Blatt.

Karl Gordon is a producer, not a member of the group, and Melanie Blatt, as you can read, only added some material to the album.

I was refering to the band at hand. Shaznay co-wrote the music with a producer, and I hardly believe Melanie adding her two cents to the album counts as much in the ways of calling her a co-writer, for the most part, she wasn't apart of the process. Looking at a track list, she is not even credited on any one song.

Man I hate bands where every member doesn't contribute to the songwriting process! The Smiths, Aztec Camera, ABBA, The Beach Boys etc. etc. etc.

Or worse, when singers sing songs written by other people (every rock artist prior to the 70s, every pop artist ever)

LOL