These guys are way hit and miss for me but the hits are amazing. They are at their best when employing their off kilter carnival sound and Going Hunting is absolutely one of their best imo. Barren Cloth Mother isn't as exciting but I still like it more than most of the most album, aside from a couple tracks

I'll second that. Avatar Country has a few real bangers mixed in there, but I can't remember which one because they named them all so similarly -_- Title track off Hail the Apocalypse also slaps

They're at their best when they lean into their groove metal side imo

That too. Like Hail the Apocalypse is such a classic track. They manage to keep groove metal fresh when they do it.