List was pretty terrible, I was disappointed.

I suppose so, I don't know, I actually like most of the songs on the list... it just kinda... irked me, in some inexplicable way. Maybe because they had two Girls songs in the top 10 which aren't even really that great.

Yeah I wasn't a huge fan of the list and I usually like Pitchfork.
I also really just don't like "Stillness Is The Move." The rest of the album is great though.

Two Phoenix songs in the top ten? Daniel? My Girls? I approve

Thought it was a pretty good list. Most of the songs I checked out from it that I hadn't heard were great. That HEALTH song rules.

Ehh.

lol pitchfork

i mean my girls is pretty boss but still

can't say i've listened to all of these but overall not a bad list. however...2 girls songs so high??? for fucks sake pitchfork!!!

stillness is the move rules idk why yr such a hater lewis

me either, Lewis is straight drinkin the haterade.

also list is pretty good honestly, specially the top 10. *high five!*

yeah list is good

i wouldve put gucci mane, cam'ron, and Bad Romance higher up though

stillness is the move is by far my least favorite track from bitte orca and I would put that album in my top 5 of 2009. it's entirely too poppy and feels out of place on the album IMHO. as for pitchfork's list... can't say I'm too surprised. they live in their own twisted, little world and this list does nothing to alter my perception of them.

Two Phoenix songs in the top 10? Really?

i completely hate pitchfork music. they have horrible taste in music, they are incredibly biased, and they hate on certain bands

actually have few complaints with this. top 10 is pretty good tbh

There were so many things on that list that I've never even heard of. Well, Pitchfork retains it's indie-cred I suppose.

they have horrible taste in music, they are incredibly biased, and they hate on certain bands

pretty good list. Some shit, though, and it took me all of an hour to see all of it.

'the fear' should be higher


im not sure if i like 'bad romance' all that much ;(

^ It has a great chorus, but "ra ra ra ma ma" as a verse is not exactly... er, great.

Not anywhere close to enough extreme music on here to be valid.

also imo wwiW?S>>>>>my girls

and i think temecula + two doves > stillness


but wat eva

Pitchfork choosing the Animal Collective?
Wowzers, they sure shocked me.

Your Terible at Posting.


Baned

lolwut

Not anywhere close to enough extreme music on here to be valid.

Pitchfork's Top Songs of 2009

It seems that they were more interested for the most part in using single than actually trying to find the best songs on the ablum (i.e. Two Weeks over Southern Point? really?). Not surprising to see AC take the top spot even though Bluish and Graze are far superior to their list counterparts.

phoenix rules yessss

annoying that taylor swift was on there when the song technically came out in 2008

i literally do not like 1 song on this list. i dont like good music i guess

also imo wwiW?S>>>>>my girls

i think had they reviewed it now theyd FOR SURE give my girls a huge 10

They're a fucking music publication site, of course they have biases towards their favourites, and of course they hate on certain bands. It's no different then Sputnik. They only have a "horrible taste in music" cause you don't like it. Jesus people can be so dumb sometimes.

Not anywhere close to enough extreme music on here to be valid.

...

(C)Rap HAHA duuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuudes

OMG why did you say that illmitch will kill us all

rap more like retards attempting poetry lol am i right folks

more like researchers adapting protons lolol

ghostechoes stfu you fucking moron.

...

yawn.

Nice to see Young Hearts Spark Fire, Don't Haunt This Place and Empire State but otherwise alot of meh.