The band is marginally good... is this guy someone who contributed to it or not?

Uh yeah he's the second voice and lead guitar. Infinitely better than the Straylight Run singer for TBS, his presence will be missed.

Oh yeah, that guy from Straylight is pretty bad in both bands... so then it was the Fred guy that kicked the last two albums out of mediocre standards...This Message Edited On 10.04.07

wow, im very suprised. didn't see that coming at all.
still, im pretty interested in seeing the replacement.

Electric City's statement is so wrong, it isn't even funny.This Message Edited On 10.04.07

^That was, though.

Never liked TBS, but I always hear my friends saying he's the new guy they didn't like.This Message Edited On 10.04.07

both co vocalists were the main reasons I listened for so long.
edit to iluvatar: john nolan.This Message Edited On 10.04.07

Fred's voice is just better than john nolans which is one of the reasons why where you want to be and louder now are better than tell all your friends.

Electric City is 2 for 2, wrong statement wise.

I like John Nolan in Straylight Run, but in Tell All Your Friends, I just thought their voices didn't blend at all.

ARE U SERIOUS?! this makes me so upset he was such an important part of this band!! does anyone know who theyre thinking of replacing him with???

Fred actually wrote better material though I think. He did a lot of songwriting on Louder Now that couldn't be touched by most of TAYF.

john nolan was a better vocalist and lyricist maybe tbs will quit making music even though they are working on a new album. that would be neat

Can't say im too surprised by this one. He had a kind of a generic voice so it wont be too tough replacing him.

Why is everyone going solo nowadays?

It's in.

I like his voice, though nothing special tbh, but TBS are more interesting than TCF.

Wow this sucks hard.

Screw the Color Fred and reform Breaking Pangea. It does surprise me that he left the band, though.

nolan was alot better for TBS cause he wrote all the lyrics on tell are your friends.. tayf is much better then the other two albums.

Fred was good too though. i saw breaking pangea once in front of like 30 people and i remember thinking this guy is pretty awesome i wonder why nobody listens to them.

Oh well. TBS were never that great anyway.

fucking fuck! Are you kidding me? That's messed up. He was the best part of the band =[