JohnnyoftheWell
01.13.23 | nominate noise plz
and (actually much more important, since it doesn't take that many votes to push the noise tag into most of these artists):
PLEASE NOMINATE **any EXTRANEOUS NOISE ROCK tags** on non-rock artists, so I can make a list to forward as a one-piece for deletion |
ArsMoriendi
01.13.23 | Wolf Eyes
Black Dice |
Bedex
01.13.23 | https://www.sputnikmusic.com/bands/Controlled-Bleeding/14011/
https://www.sputnikmusic.com/bands/Absolute-Hell/69629/
https://www.sputnikmusic.com/bands/Sewer-Election/50570/
https://www.sputnikmusic.com/bands/Vomir/46657/
https://www.sputnikmusic.com/bands/Ramleh/15268/ @Johnny this one has noise rock!!
for all of these drop all their tags and add noise plz |
Bedex
01.13.23 | https://www.sputnikmusic.com/bands/Eon-Noise/57765/
also i think this artist can be renamed Eon and just tagged noise lel |
ArsMoriendi
01.13.23 | I will blindly tag all of these noise if you do the same for new wave |
JohnnyoftheWell
01.13.23 | have done !
and cheers Bedex dope content, keep it coming!!
for the artists in the list, I'm minded to request noise rock deletion from all cases except Fushitsusha and the Goslings (which imo warrant both) and am unsure whether Pan Sonic warrants Noise in its top 3 (though it obviously qualifies) - open to other opinions on any |
DadKungFu
01.13.23 | Grim (JPN)
Ramleh
Controlled Bleeding
Hanatarash
Pure
Madonna
Nurse With Wound
Whitehouse |
ArsMoriendi
01.13.23 | Throbbing Gristle only has 2 tags currently, I bet noise would fit well with industrial and experimental based off of their Annual Report albums |
GhandhiLion
01.13.23 | No it wouldn't. Keep them out of the noise charts |
DadKungFu
01.13.23 | I'm with Ghandi, sput needs to get more meticulous with genre tags and TG's status as noise is extremely debatable |
gschwen
01.13.23 | wolf eyes is good music |
ArsMoriendi
01.13.23 | If you guys say so |
GhandhiLion
01.13.23 | They have a few noise songs but, if you can, tags shouldn't be used for artists that have slight influence from a style or a few songs.
See jazz + rap |
gschwen
01.13.23 | It's okay Ars, I agree with you. But then again I'm not a huge TG or noise person. But the Second Annual Report sounds like a noise record to me. 20 Jazz Funk Greats does not. And RYM doesn't give them a noise tag either, so I think I'm just completely wrong about the whole thing. |
GhandhiLion
01.13.23 | yeah they are adjacent to noise music at least |
Havey
01.13.23 | balloon journey |
JohnnyoftheWell
01.13.23 | updated with all acts who still need votes
DadKung are Pure or Whitehouse's noise rock tags warranted (assuming no for the latter)? |
SharkTooth
01.13.23 | https://www.sputnikmusic.com/bands/Uboa/110875/ |
DadKungFu
01.13.23 | Hard no for both, same with Ramleh |
JesperL
01.13.23 | jj allin |
Jasdevi087
01.13.23 | the rita
the cherry point
Werewolf Jerusalem
God Pussy
sissy spacek
also do Nurse With Wound really count as a noise band? I would've thought industrial + experimental would be closer to the truth |
DadKungFu
01.13.23 | Fair NWW is also debatable I remember Thunder Perfect Mind being pretty noise-heavy, here and there on Chance Meeting as well but if we're not including TG maybe NWW shouldn't be included as well |
Jasdevi087
01.13.23 | Thunder Perfect Mind has a kinda power electronics vibe yeah |
Sharenge
01.14.23 | guessing that even if every deserving artist/project got its 'noise' tag, this genre still doesn't have enough ratings to fill the chart
then again I guess there are others where this is the case too... never really fuck with any of the genre features |
Sharenge
01.14.23 | get Alberich and Wolf Eyes tagged
Sissy Spacek too |
Bedex
01.14.23 | As I recall NWW I'd say it's a band where it is potentially worth keeping the industrial tag alongside noise, whereas the ones I listed above can be just tagges noise |
DadKungFu
01.14.23 | Jason Crumer
Kevin Drumm
Werewolf Jerusalem |
Mort.
01.14.23 | 19? is that all you could muster? pathetic johnny. browse rym for noise bands then post them here til you reach 100, coward. |
porcupinetheater
01.14.23 | Johnny don't get rid of my noise rock pie chart slice like this |
JohnnyoftheWell
01.14.23 | PORC WE WILL JAM MORE NOISE ROCK
Sissy Spacek sandblasted itches I did not know needed scratching and I am whelmed :] |
FrozenFirebug
01.14.23 | toshimaru nakamura |
JohnnyoftheWell
01.14.23 | ugh onkyo tag when |
DadKungFu
01.14.23 | Consumer Electronics
Crank Sturgeon
Emil Beaulieau
Kleistwahr
|
ArsMoriendi
01.14.23 | Made a synthpop list for this idea, please help |
Bedex
01.15.23 | there's an all time noise chart now wowzers thanks for your service |
DadKungFu
01.15.23 | Emptyset
Shurayuki-Hime
Cremation Lily
Propergol
Shum |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
01.15.23 | alice in chains |
Jasdevi087
01.16.23 | damn Leichenschrei #1 on the charts |
Sharenge
01.16.23 | Wolf Eyes needs more votes/tags |
DadKungFu
01.16.23 | LEICHENSCHREI AIN'T NOISE DAMMIT
Edit: added pseudocommando and Mayuko Hino, need some tags though |
cylinder
01.16.23 | that's sweet that there's a 'noise' tag now. now we just need: harsh noise, harsh noise wall, power electronics, death industrial, ambient noise, black noise, gorenoise, noisegrind, noisecore, power noise and chiptune lol
just joking, but having tags for harsh noise wall and power electronics would be nice though.
|
Sharenge
01.16.23 | welp... if you can't beat 'em, join 'em...
vote/tag everything listed and mentioned here as 'noise rock' for the trollolols |
Jasdevi087
01.17.23 | Incapacitants need a noise tag and noise rock dropped |
DadKungFu
01.17.23 | Tagged and bookmarked to check later |
neekafat
01.18.23 | soccer mommy |
ThyCrossAwaits
01.23.23 | Government Alpha
Knurl
Vincent Dallas
Moozzhead
666 Volt Battery Noise
T.E.F.
Black Leather Jesus
Worth
Kyle Flanagan
Legless
Scald Hymn
Kakerlak
Sissisters
Shredded Nerve
Phocomelus
Heat Signature
MSBR
Being
Rotat
Skin Graft
Ram Ventilation
Dead Body Love
Kiran Arora
Kjostad
Deterge
Fecal Dam
David Gilden
Skin Crime
Unexamine
Rusalka |
ArsMoriendi
01.25.23 | Wow that’s a long list, nice |