wojodta
01.27.21 | I wouldn't have SH4 in my top 2 but I think it's a great game. Origins was always my favorite non-Team Silent game. It's nothing new, but out of the later games it felt the most like a traditional SH to me. Series needs a reboot now. |
Shuyin
01.27.21 | SH4 is a great game, man I remember the first time playing I almost lost my shit when the room turned hostile. Still one of the best horror games I've ever played. SH2 is the best in the series, won't be a lot of people disagreeing with that |
TheAntichrist
01.27.21 | fuck yeah |
Trebor.
01.27.21 | The first four games should be in the smithsonian |
SuicycoManiac7
01.27.21 | Should I make a top silent hill creatures? |
Supercoolguy64
01.27.21 | Only ever played the first 2 |
CaliggyJack
01.27.21 | 1. Silent Hill 3
2. Silent Hill
3. Silent Hill 2
4. Silent Hill Downpour
5. Silent Hill Origins
6. Silent Hill 4: The Room
7. Silent Hill Shattered Memories
8. Silent Hill Book of Memories
Homecoming is an entirely different game and shouldn't be compared to the others tbqh. It doesn't even take place in Silent Hill. |
0GuyMan0
01.27.21 | I'm a silent hill fanatic and speedrun SH3 on and off again. It's easily my favorite in the series, but SH2 truly is one of the greatest games ever made. I'm a little annoyed at how far SH1 has slipped in people's memories though. That game was groundbreaking, and IMO remains by far the scariest of the series. |
MyNameIsPencil
01.27.21 | homecoming pissed me off i stopped playing after like an hour lol
im glad more people are coming around towards 4. it's flawed as all hell but i can look past most said flaws |
naughtcturnal
01.27.21 | Kudos for puttin SH4 so high!! It is my personal favorite |
rabidfish
01.27.21 | 4>1??? nah, mate. Also 1 still got my favorite soundtrack of them all, too.
can't wait for the next false rumor to surface, so i can again have some shred of hope and get my heart ripped apart again by konami. |
rabidfish
01.27.21 | Strictly subjective ranking based on emotion and nostalgia. Don't @me or ELSE.
1. SH1.
2. SH3
3. SH2
4. SH4
Rest. Rest |
Shuyin
01.27.21 | First game looks prehistoric when compared to 2 and 3 but it is still ground breaking af. That initial part when you follow the girl on the alley and it all turns to shit.. yeah, that got me real good when I was a kid, I was mostly used to Resident Evil and Dino Crisis, SH was genuinely scary |
Shuyin
01.27.21 | rabid digs the first game so much he even ranked it twice |
rabidfish
01.27.21 | lol fix'd. My only gripe with SH2 is that it's so objectively amazing that people that didn't already fall in love with SH1 will most likely never care as much for it. |
americanohno
01.27.21 | I never played any of the silent hill games but in lieu of completing a college essay in 2013 I watched lets plays of all the silent hill games released at that time and honestly IV: The Room is the one that most stuck with me. |
Brabiz
01.27.21 | 3 I will always be my favorite. Used to play that shit nonstop when I was a kid |
ConcubinaryCode
01.28.21 | BoM was just some deluded high ups idea to have wayforward do a rogue like. I don't think any big fan considers anything past the room Canon anyway. The biggest shame is a lot of the talent is still at Konami, the company just isn't interested past pimping out Pyramid head for other games since it's such a good sales prospect. Which I think says a lot about how little faith they have in their team to make something different.
Can also agree with 3's endings kinda being lame especially after how satisfying 2s were
|
americanohno
01.28.21 | honestly the aaa games industry across the board has gon in thge tubes. no good madden game in 7 years, no new gta in 7 years just online and ports to other consoles and gta online, no new elder scrolls in 9 years just eso online. the games as service model kinna ruined the industry. |
Shuyin
01.28.21 | I'm stuck in the past with a potato computer and a PS3 but I know there were great games released this year like the new Doom. Most of the companies that go for the games as service scheme either score big time or fail miserably from what I've seen, they know they can't milk single player games |
ConcubinaryCode
01.28.21 | Yeah, this generation the battle Royale was king so that kinda set the standard. Resident Evil got good again though and the indie scene blew up big so that's cool. |
EyesWideShut
01.28.21 | I would have loved a Silent Hill 2 remake over anything RE tbh. And yes the OG Silent Hill was really creepy, that school level haha |
Ecnalzen
01.28.21 | I think I have only played 1, 2, and part of Homecoming |
Morningrise767
01.28.21 | 1 is 1 |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
01.28.21 | "While it has some flaws such as backtracking, this game remained inside me long after I played it"
Why didn't you take it out? |
Sharenge
01.28.21 | I need to get around to Silent Hill 2 & 3... I finally got most of the way through the original like a year or so back (I quit at some irritating part near the end, I didn't feel like I was really gonna be missing out on much) |
MillionDead
01.28.21 | It's 2, 1, 3 and fuck the rest for me. lol |
SuicycoManiac7
01.28.21 | Good to see some love for the room, it's a misunderstood gem that crawls under your skin. I feel like more people should give a chance to SM and Downpour. |
CaliggyJack
01.28.21 | Anyone who doesn't at least try Downpour is doing themselves a massive disservice.
Underrated gem of a game filled with great mechanics and classic Czech horror. |
rabidfish
01.28.21 | what? lol no. it's a mediocre game that's barely playable. |
Shuyin
01.28.21 | The only non team silent that I played was Origins and it was so underwhelming that I gave up around 40 minutes in. It was also the last SH game I ever played
"Silent Hill was really creepy, that school level haha"
That school legit gave me nightmares, I was too young to play that game ahaha |
CaliggyJack
01.28.21 | "what? lol no. it's a mediocre game that's barely playable."
Played fine on my PS3. Also wrong opinions. |
Gyromania
01.28.21 | nice, i'm all for placing the room above 3. they're about on par for me, but one thing's for sure, 2 is untouchable |
Gyromania
01.28.21 | also downpour is extremely underwhelming, sh rly lost its sense of atmosphere after the 4th game. i wish they'd release competent remasters of the first 4 but konami sucks balls so |
ConcubinaryCode
01.28.21 | The Room is on steam now |
CaliggyJack
01.28.21 | "sh rly lost its sense of atmosphere after the 4th game."
Disagree but honestly 4 is one of my least favorite SH games, but it was another game that shouldn't have been called a SH game since it again takes place in a different city. It wasn't even supposed to be called SH4 Konami just retroactively added it before release. |
Shuyin
01.28.21 | I'm fine with SH4 being its own thing |
SuicycoManiac7
01.28.21 | @CalliggyJack Actually this has been denied by Team Silent itself. In fact Walter Sullivan's murder are quoted even in Silent Hill 2 during Trick or treat quiz show |
CaliggyJack
01.28.21 | "Actually this has been denied by Team Silent itself. In fact Walter Sullivan's murder are quoted even in Silent Hill 2 during Trick or treat quiz show"
makes it even worse tbqh. It just doesn't feel like a good SH game imho. Imma stick to the original trilogy and Downpour. |
Gyromania
01.28.21 | silent hill 4 is fine as its own thing imo. for a while re7 seemed very much like its own thing (but i think 8 will bring major tie-ins). sh4 has a very classic feel to me, even though it's noticeably different from the first 3 games. downpour isn't the worst game ever, but if you ask me that feels very far removed from sh, as do most of the new games. homecoming was prob my favourite out of the newer titles but even then it wasn't that good.
resident evil, on the other hand, has had this amazing revival that started with 7. i really hope 8 is as solid. imagine if konami didn't blow ass and silent hill saw a similar renaissance |
CaliggyJack
01.28.21 | If I included it in the list, Homecoming would be my favorite Silent Hill game out of all of them. It's amazing imho. However, it's just not a Silent Hill game, it is completely it's own thing and shouldn't be compared to SH in all honesty. |
rabidfish
01.28.21 | downpour isn't a bad game, it's just mediocre and quite forgettable. the story is trash too, and the enemy and enviromental design leaves much to be desired. |
SteakByrnes
01.28.21 | just making sure sh2 was number 1, good job |
SuicycoManiac7
01.28.21 | @rabidfish agree on most of the enemies (the dolls and wheelman are great tough, the bat's and bogeyman were fine) but Imo the story was great like the environment as well |
Atari
01.28.21 | I have good memories of playing The Room while working at blockbusters back in the day. I could check out around 5 games or movies at a time and I'll never forget how challenging but addicting that one was |
Gyromania
01.28.21 | a lot of people have a hard time detaching from the pov that a game is just bad right off the bat for being out of place in the series . personally i've never had a problem with looking past that. franchises go in starkly different directions sometimes. like i used to give resident evil shit for 5 and 6 and complain that they ditched their survival horror roots. for what they are tho they're enjoyable couch coop action games if you can get past the fact that they're a part of the numbered franchise. |
Gyromania
01.28.21 | i wholeheartedly miss blockbuster. i know it doesn't make sense to have anymore, but renting games for $7 and binging them to wring out every bit of content was a cost-effective and fun time. |
CaliggyJack
01.28.21 | The Revelations games shoulda been 5 and 6
And 5 and 6 shoulda been the numbered games
6 is fucking awesome though. Lots of ball busting Capcom action and deep RE lore. Sherry and Jake's campaign is my personal favorite. |
SuicycoManiac7
01.28.21 | Just made a list of best Creatures from Silent Hill games |
ConcubinaryCode
01.28.21 | I think people are more lenient now of 5&6 now that we got some games that follow up the formula of the ogs. Revelations were praised but their pacing is ass and coop in 2 is so lame. They're ok but just kinda mediocre experiences. |
Shuyin
01.28.21 | Resident Evil has great ideas when managing the franchise, like attaching a sub title to the series dethatched from the main games: Outbreak, Revelations, etc.. But then they also change the main series from survival horror into action and then horror again in first person.. what a mess. I love Resi tho, it's my all time favourite franchise even being inconsistent af |
Atari
01.28.21 | Same gyro. Miss the days of video rental stores :/ |
CaliggyJack
01.28.21 | @Darius
Of the outsourced ones, Homecoming and Downpour are the best, Origins is pretty good but flawed as Hell. |
0GuyMan0
01.29.21 | Homecoming, Downpour and Shattered Memories all have something to offer. IMO homecoming gets a really bad rap. It's a step down from the classics, but, objectively, so was 4. It wasn't even developed by Team Silent, and Hostel had taken America by storm and the SH movie clearly was an influence for the game. There's still great atmosphere, some AMAZING creature design, and most importantly, Akira Yamaoka was still on top of his game.
Downpour was....a big mess. Lots of misses. Occasionally it scratches that classic itch, like when you're able to explore town and do some sidequests...but man. No Akira hurts BIG.
Shattered Memories is WAY different than the others, but it's a pretty interesting take on SH1. Worth, imo. |
budgie
01.29.21 | wat is silent h1ll about |
naughtcturnal
01.29.21 | it is about a mute hill and he have to help it get its voice back |
budgie
01.29.21 | ooo sounds fun |
rabidfish
01.29.21 | quiet mound |
budgie
01.29.21 | return to shush knoll |
naughtcturnal
01.29.21 | Silent Hill 3: High Ground Gets Hushed Again |
CaliggyJack
01.29.21 | I liked Downpour's soundtrack
R.I.P. Daniel Licht |
0GuyMan0
01.29.21 | As a standalone entity, it might not be bad.
Unfortunately, imo Akira Yamaoka is more important to silent hill than literally anyone else, and I couldn't possibly approach it from a reasonable position. |