Hawks
12.15.25 | Based ranking. 1 is 1 and 8 is 8. |
zakalwe
12.15.25 | 12 and 14 are too low
13 is 14
|
Demon of the Fall
12.15.25 | I've weirdly never done this here and never will (in list form, lol). 14 and 13 are correct at least. BWP seems about right. Nice to see Orchid relatively high.
I'll begrudgingly accept this ranking. |
bighubbabuddha
12.15.25 | Cheers broskis! M// |
Kimm
12.15.25 | You had me up until 4 |
bighubbabuddha
12.15.25 | 4 rules dude |
Hawks
12.15.25 | 4 rules insanely hard indeed. |
e210013
12.15.25 | Nice ranking, Buddha. My only big difference with your ranking is Blackwater Park. It's placed too low to my taste. A very difficult band to rank. I love all their works, really. |
Hawks
12.15.25 | This isn't my list brother lol. I do agree with the placement of BWP here though. |
Galbador
12.15.25 | Can't agree here Buddha. 1st is 5th and 4th is 8th or 9th |
e210013
12.15.25 | I also think Pale Communion is too low too. |
Hawks
12.15.25 | "1st is 5th and 4th is 8th or 9th"
Maybe on opposite day agreed. |
Gyromania
12.15.25 | 1st is 100% 1st. 4th is second for me, then probably 2 is 3. Heritage is wayyyyy too low |
Retter42
12.15.25 | 12, 9, 8, and 4 are too low. 3, 5, and 6 too high. Everything else is perfectly placed. |
Hawks
12.15.25 | 3 too high? Meth for breakfast perhaps? |
RVAHC13
12.15.25 | moaropeth |
Gyromania
12.15.25 | Nah 3 def too high imo. Actually, agreed with all of that--5 and 6 are also way too high on the list. |
DominionMM1
12.15.25 | 8 is 1
9 and 10 actually kinda suck |
Hawks
12.15.25 | 3 is too low tbh. Top 2 for me easily. |
Gyromania
12.15.25 | 8 is 8. 10 kind of sucks but 9 was a great comeback tbh |
Dwap
12.16.25 | It’s going to be a “no” from me |
bighubbabuddha
12.16.25 | Amazing discography. Only album I dislike is 14 |
Ectier
12.16.25 | I really wish 14 had better prod theres some decent songs there but the prod fucks them |
Demon of the Fall
12.16.25 | true, as the live versions were admittedly much better |
Ectier
12.16.25 | Era and the title track slap |
thatdeftkid
12.18.25 | Any list with Deliverance below BP or GR is false |
gagnonov
12.18.25 | pretty standard ranking for me aside from Heritage, which I like more than the average person i think
1- Blackwater Park
2- Still Life
3- My Arms, Your Hearse
4- Morningrise
5- Heritage
6- Ghost Reveries
7- Deliverance
8- Damnation
9- Watershed
10- Orchid
11- The Last Will and Testament
12- In Cauda Venenum
13- Pale Communion
14- Sorceress |
Confessed2005
12.18.25 | 11 is way too low. |
Retter42
12.18.25 | 14. Sorceress
13. Orchid
12. Pale Communion
11. ICV
10. Moringrise
9. Deliverance
8. MAYH
7. Damnation
6. TLWAT
5. Ghost Reveries
4. Heritage
3. Still Life
2. Blackwater Park
1. Watershed |
