Hawks
11.25.25 | Marrow being last makes this list invalid I'm sorry. |
Hawks
11.25.25 | 3
2
4
9
5
8
6
7
1 |
arthropod
11.25.25 | Faustian being last makes your ranking invalid, my condolences. |
Hawks
11.25.25 | Its still good, but yeah, definitely my least fav. |
arthropod
11.25.25 | All are good agreed
except for Marrow |
Hawks
11.25.25 | Idk how you like the others and don't like Marrow lmao. |
arthropod
11.25.25 | Others generally have better or more distinct riffs and either more fun or emotional vibe. As for the Serpent... I'd expect an album with a 3.3 avg to be worse. |
Hawks
11.25.25 | I don't understand, but I respect your opinion! |
DarkSideOfLucca
11.25.25 | This is pretty dope, I've been on an Agalloch kick as of recent
2 is clearly 1, 4 and 3 are tied for #2, and marrow and the white are WAYYYY too low
Faustian Echoes is awesome, but I don't see a universe where it tops The Mantle, Ashes or Pale Folklore |
arthropod
11.25.25 | Ashes and The Mantle at their length have some bits I just don't feel enthusiastic about. To be fair, Marrow would be pretty high if this was an artworks ranking.
@Hawks Same man, I don't dig Marrow but you do you. |
Hawks
11.25.25 | M//////EN |
Zac124
11.25.25 | Tbf, those tracks off Marrow are indeed phenomenal but the lack of Black Lake Niðstång is strange. Love that track.
Also, love The White EP. Honestly amongst their top 3 for me. |
Scoot
11.25.25 | marrow fucking slaps
black lake nidstang is their best song |
Keyblade
11.25.25 | 4
9
3
rest is whatever |
arthropod
11.25.25 | To be fair, 6-8 are a tossup to me. White is endearing, the instrumental work, sampling and overall atmosphere were nailed there. |
Scoot
11.26.25 | pale is their best like hawks always says
mantle close behind |
arthropod
11.26.25 | They're roughly equal, The Mantle not as consistently good but peaks higher.
By the way, I forgot about Scar of the Shattered Sky. Phenomenal track. |
Kimm
11.26.25 | "Marrow being last makes this list invalid I'm sorry." [2] |
hel9000
11.26.25 | The White is my fav these days |
PizzaBear
11.28.25 | No Grey EP? No Tomorrow Will Never Come?
Filthy casual |
arthropod
11.28.25 | I don't think 6 minutes of music should qualify as an album. |
