JoyfulPlatypus
10.22.25 | You ever tried out Saidan? They were one of the my own gateways into BM, even though I still wouldn't say it's my favorite kind of metal. |
Hawks
10.22.25 | Satyricon - Nemesis Divina
Emperor - In the Nightside Eclipse
Immortal - Sons of Northern Darkness
Cradle of Filth - The Principle of Evil Made Flesh
Mayhem - De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas
Ulver - Bergtatt
Summoning - Minas Morgul
Panopticon - Autumn Eternal
Agalloch - Pale Folklore
Enslaved - Vertebrae
Dimmu Borgir - Puritanical Euphoric Misanthropia
Old Man's Child - In Defiance of Existence
Graveworm - Engraved in Black
Rotting Christ - Non Serviam
Gorgoroth - Pentagram
Judas Iscariot - Distant in Solitary Night
Leviathan - Massive Conspiracy Against All Life
Ash Borer - 2009 Demo
Sargeist - Let the Devil In
Xanthochroid - Blessed He With Boils
Persefone - Truth Inside the Shades |
botb
10.22.25 | Mgla - exercises in futility
Drudkh - microcosmos
|
ThyCrossAwaits
10.22.25 | Yeah the first two Emperor albums [1000] |
AlkemestRedux
10.22.25 | I feel like black metal is a genre that's definitely easier to get into working backwards. These guys are a handful of pretty fun modern bands:
Spectral Wound
Wolves in the Throne Room
Archgoat
Paysage d'Hiver
Hulder
Blackbraid
Hellripper |
veryhandyman
10.22.25 | scalding - nuclear winter spell |
pyroflare77
10.22.25 | Melodic black metal also makes the riffs cleaner. Good starter pack for that:
Dissection - Storm of the Light's Bane
Sacramentum - Far Away From the Sun
Lord Belial - Enter the Moonlight Gate
Lots of other great recs I'm seeing so far (and a few things I need to check out), but Taake - Hordalands Doedskvad is also standing atop riff mountain. Flirting with meloblack but standing on the normal bm line. |
Wildcardbitchesss
10.22.25 | Oathbreaker - Rheia
idc if it ain’t kvlt that albums goated |
Rowhaus
10.22.25 | The Ruins of Beverast - Exuvia
Panzerfaust - The Suns of Perdition - Chapter IV
Shining - V. Halmstad
Ascension - Consolamentum
Cobalt - Gin
Akercocke - Words That Go Unspoken, Deeds That Go Undone
Just a few I've jammed somewhat recently that I think are fairly "accessible" m/ |
Wildcardbitchesss
10.22.25 | ooh fuck yeah Gin is damn good. I like Slow Forever more but Gin is definitely closer to that classic bm sound
Hard RIP, Erik Wunder was a master of his craft tbh |
Beardog
10.22.25 | Yeah just go Deafheaven, Saor, Winterfylleth, Fen, White Ward, atmospheric stuff like that. I think Saor was my gateway band. Der Weg Einer Freiheit's later stuff is also quite accessible. Enslaved also goated but not that black metal per se. |
Wildcardbitchesss
10.22.25 | Ya ngl as much as hardcore bm dudes will roast you for it, Deafheaven is probably the best gateway black metal band. Sunbather really made a lot of it click for me back in the day |
Rowhaus
10.22.25 | [2]
Shame I didn't discover Cobalt until after he passed. Hard RIP m/ |
Hawks
10.22.25 | Cobalt slays yeah. |
Wildcardbitchesss
10.22.25 | They played at a bar near me not long after Slow Forever dropped but it was a 21+ show… I really regret not even trying to get in now : / |
botb
10.22.25 | Oh hey also listen to my stupid band, it’s pretty accessible as far as BM goes. https://augurrva.bandcamp.com/album/arcane-insurgency |
Wildcardbitchesss
10.22.25 | It’s metal brother, all of it is stupid : D
I’ll check it out |
Hawks
10.22.25 | Botb's band's album kicks ass agreed. |
brickhed
10.22.25 | ight, all sounds dope. i'll pick out a few albums from each pile, i can only listen to so much. especially if i want to do mini reviews. i'll get started next week. |
vult
10.22.25 | Aara - Eiger
Saidan - Visual Kill: The Blossoming of Psychotic Depravity
Havukruunu - Uinous Syomein Sota
as a more recent bm convert, these are really my favorites right now. |
Zac124
10.22.25 | Lord Belial - Enter the Moonlight Gate
Moonlight Sorcery - Horned Lord of the Thorned Castle |
evilford
10.22.25 | Bm is aight, never have dug it anywhere as much as dm tho |
Keyblade
10.22.25 | Summoning discog, stat |
ThyCrossAwaits
10.22.25 | Ooh you've got a good list going here b-hed. I'll second that new Aara album there vult, it is STUNNING. |
Hawks
10.22.25 | Lots of good choices here. |
Sevengill
10.22.25 | these days it's just a bunch of guys who look like girls making astrology-core BS for autistic leftists and purple-haired commies and slapping titles on it full of words they found in witch-tok videos like "hiraeth" and "petrichor"
(if you're into that, check out my bm band) |
Wildcardbitchesss
10.22.25 | I am, what’s your band |
Valzentia
10.22.25 | Here's some recs:
Innoruuk - Finis Bonorum
Sacramentum - Far Away From The Sun
Dimmu Borgir - Enthrone Darkness Triumphant |
Sevengill
10.22.25 | beardog on point with "Deafheaven, Saor, Winterfylleth, Fen, White Ward, atmospheric stuff like that"
@wildcard lol its Dzö-nga |
brickhed
10.22.25 | sevengill i'm here for the music, whats the band |
Hawks
10.22.25 | That is the band lol. |
Veldin
10.22.25 | Enslaved- Axioma Ethica Odini |
Sevengill
10.22.25 | [2] Axioma is a great entry point. it's structured like prog and has a nice balance of harsh and melodic vocals. |
pyroflare77
10.22.25 | iirc super cornball dimmy burger only shows up later with Puritanical Euphoric Misanthropia onward (though that one is at least still fun) |
Hawks
10.22.25 | All of Dimmu's stuff, up to and including In Sorte Diaboli, slays extremely hard. |
budgie
10.22.25 | burzum - aske
sterbend - dwelling lifeless
shining - halmstad
gehenna - first spell
immortal - diabolical fullmoon mysticism (esp since you like under the sign of the black mark) |
ComeToDaddy
10.22.25 | Since you want riff variation, good production and with all the disso stuff in your 4.5s and 5s, I think Deathspell Omega - Paracletus would be right up your alley.
Other than that, definitely supporting the recs like Saidan, Der Weg Einer Freiheit, Spectral Wound - a lot of that newer ilk of melodic / riff heavy bm is really easy to get into |
Wildcardbitchesss
10.22.25 | Yeah he’s got Gorguts 5’d, DSO is just black metal Gorguts imo, especially that record |
Sevengill
10.23.25 | and from DSO, those Icelandic bm bands are an obvious jump. Svartidaudi, Zhrine, Misthyrming, etc. |
AlkemestRedux
10.23.25 | Hmm after looking at your ratings, you'd probably like war metal. It's definitely my favorite flavor of black metal. A nice blend of black/death/grind. Or really nightmarish noise black metal like Uranium. |
botb
10.23.25 | Don’t miss that Mgla record, essential BM listening imo |
Hawks
10.23.25 | Agreed, Mgla's whole discog rules so hard. |
zaruyache
10.23.25 | listen to Old Man's Child it's super clean and riffs all day |
Hawks
10.23.25 | [2] |
JoyfulPlatypus
10.23.25 | Wow vult wtf what kind of schmuck would recommend Saidan, could never be me. |
Scoot
10.23.25 | agalloch is responsible for getting me into black metal |
budgie
10.23.25 | imagine listening to agalloch lol |
Wildcardbitchesss
10.23.25 | Ya Deafheaven is much better |
Scoot
10.23.25 | don't start up with me jerk |
Scoot
10.23.25 | all the bm purists get in here, someone is championing a gateway band |
Keyblade
10.23.25 | Pale Folklore is a pretty good starting point agreed |
Scoot
10.23.25 | i went from agalloch to fucking catamenia of all bands |
Keyblade
10.23.25 | aren't they pretty melodic themselves? I also recall them being one of my first lol |
Scoot
10.23.25 | yeah they are
my first real exposure to bm was on mxtabs where everyone used to make fun of call of the wintermoon
i thought it sounded like ass but i think i eventually started getting into it more, and eventually i heard storm of the lights bane and that was it |
ScuroFantasma
10.23.25 | Enslaved - Axioma Ethica Odini |
Keyblade
10.23.25 | I had some metal "friends" on fb back in the day made from discussing shit on like metal groups, and one of them would have these new sick pfps of their albums with the wolves lol and I was like okay I need to check these guys. I honestly can't remember much about them, this had to be over 15 years ago now. those album covers stick in my mind tho |
Beardog
10.23.25 | This bloke actually picked the Winterfylleth record I enjoy the least lol. Perhaps you enjoy it though! |
ThyCrossAwaits
10.23.25 | Yeah I tend to think most niches of extreme metal are acquired tastes but starting from your perspective it’s gotta be almost impossible to not find something you enjoy in this |
arthropod
10.23.25 | Living Colour |
budgie
10.23.25 | he dont added any of my recs cuz he jealous i am more beautifuler than hims |
Demon of the Fall
10.23.25 | 'Falls of Rauros - Keys to a Vanishing Future' (atmo stuff with variety and definitely decipherable creative riffage)
'Scarcity - Aveilut' (okay this is totally different, it's very layered and repetitive but isn't overly 'lo-fi' / is decipherable and a unique enough take on BM that you don't exactly have to be a connoisseur to appreciate it imo. It's not my fave genre either yet this is an exceedingly rare Demo 5, so...) |
brickhed
10.23.25 | beardog you didn't rec a specific album so i don't want any complaining
budgie fine i'll add one. i tried bm burzum a few times and it did not click. in fact, second wave black metal is something that i can't truely enjoy right now. that's the main reason why i ignored your post.
i tried scarcity and i remember it being too repetitive for me. i listened to the whole thing and it bored me. i can put it at the end and see what i think. |
vult
10.23.25 | "Wow vult wtf what kind of schmuck would recommend Saidan, could never be me."
(: |
Hawks
10.23.25 | Saidan slays agreed. |
budgie
10.23.25 | y r u such a lil pussy brik |
Get Low
10.23.25 | ctrl + f Moonsorrow 0 results found
If you're still looking for recs, try Moonsorrow's album Verisakeet. It's on the folkier side if you like that. |
Deez
10.23.25 | thantifaxath - sacred white noise |
Keyblade
10.24.25 | Hawks is somehow the only one who rec'd it, but Ulver's Bergtatt is a classic and relatively very easy to get into |
Sevengill
10.24.25 | Moonsorrow is peak but the vocals aren't easy to get into, based on the decent sample size of people I've had as a captive audience on road trips |
brickhed
10.24.25 | closing submissions at 30, any more and this will never get done. currently at 28. |
Sevengill
10.24.25 | Dzö-nga - Thunder in the Mountains. get your questing fix. |
budgie
10.24.25 | darude - sandstorm |
RVAHC13
10.24.25 | You know he had other songs budgei |
budgie
10.24.25 | i dont listen to that crap lol |
RVAHC13
10.24.25 | poseur |
budgie
10.24.25 | ur a poser !!! |
Gestapo
10.24.25 | dark funeral |
Sevengill
10.24.25 | darude funeral? |
Hawks
10.24.25 | Finally another Dark Funeral fan lmao. One of my fav bands ever. |
Sevengill
10.24.25 | Nils is a monster yeah |
brickhed
10.27.25 | starting tomorrow morning with a half hour demo, watch out |
Hawks
10.27.25 | Best bm demo ever made. First track is also in the running for best bm song ever. |
brickhed
10.27.25 | we got the first one done, it's pretty dope |
Hawks
10.27.25 | Hell yeah!!! |
Sevengill
10.27.25 | I somehow never spun Ash Borer. I circled all around it with WITTR, Weakling, Leviathan, Vanum, Fauna, etc but left that and Fell Voices for later. Is today the day?? |
Hawks
10.27.25 | It damn well better be!!! |
Keyblade
10.27.25 | 2009-2012 Ash Borer/Fell Voices usbm era *Vince McMahon gif* |
Hawks
10.27.25 | M///// |
brickhed
10.28.25 | summoning is done, i'll revisit let mortal heros sing your name sometime |
Hawks
10.28.25 | LMHSYF sucks. Go to Nightshade Forests, Dol Guldur and Stronghold next. |
Sevengill
10.28.25 | I think they basically just got better every album, peaking with Oath Bound and Old Mornings. those are also probably the most approachable. |
Hawks
10.28.25 | I don't like Oath Bound either lol. Only two that I'm not a fan of. They both bore me to tears. OMD rules though. |
Sevengill
10.28.25 | u r so weird. it's got Streaming Tide AND Beleriand. |
budgie
10.28.25 | lmhsyf is boring for the first 15 years but eventually u will fall in love with it |
brickhed
10.29.25 | done with spectral wound |
AlkemestRedux
10.29.25 | I think you're pretty spot on for that Spectral Wound album. It's fun but I think their previous album riffs a little harder. All their songs are awesome live though, nonstop headbanging. |
brickhed
10.30.25 | yeah i've been meaning to check out pagan bm anyway, will do so when this list is over. in short looking forward to 33. |
Hawks
10.30.25 | Nice Hulder rating! Love that band. |
Rowhaus
10.30.25 | fuck yeah Hulder |
jrlikestodance
10.30.25 | I felt the same about Dimmu but embrace the cheese, it's so worth it. Also they riff fuckin ahrd |
Hawks
10.30.25 | Everything Dimmu did up to and including In Sorte Diaboli is amazing. |
gabba
10.30.25 | This Hulder album starts amazing. It has a 1 sec intro and then we're in deep waters. |
AlkemestRedux
10.30.25 | Hulder rips! They're amazing live too if you get a chance to see them. I think they're actually starting a West Coast tour tonight through mid-November. |
CaliggyJack
10.30.25 | Check out Antestor - Martyrium |
Brabiz
10.30.25 | Benighted Leams - Astral Tenebrion
Never hear this one mentioned anywhere, super weird shit |
brickhed
10.30.25 | guys sorry to inform you i closed submissions a while back. should have added that into the list. also i like weird shit so i'll eventually give benighted leams a shot. i'm just working on this one and soon another so it'll be a while. |
budgie
10.30.25 | shut up |
CaliggyJack
10.30.25 | Yea, shut up |
budgie
10.30.25 | yea |
CaliggyJack
10.30.25 | YEA |
Aids
10.30.25 | woah long thread
i'll assume someone has already made a poop joke so i'll just leave |
CaliggyJack
10.30.25 | Nights still young for an AIDs joke |
brickhed
11.04.25 | yo we back hood n shiet we finna finish dis |
mindleviticus
11.04.25 | check Kvist - For kunsten maa vi evig vike |
brickhed
11.04.25 | check the disclaimer about NO SUBMISSONS |
mindleviticus
11.04.25 | listen to it anyway |
Jurtz
11.04.25 | WINDIR - ARNTOR |
Jurtz
11.04.25 | Listen to this one as well, it's criminal that it wasn't recommended yet! |
brickhed
11.06.25 | ight moving on i did a few more mini reviews |
bach
11.06.25 | Arizmenda - without circumference nor center
|
bach
11.06.25 | some of the most unusual riffs ive heard in a bm album |
botb
11.06.25 | I lowkey feel like an idiot for being like “hey my band isn’t too abrasive or hard to get into” and then everyone else gives you the heaviest hitters in the whole genre but I hope you like it lol |
brickhed
11.06.25 | yeah i'm always down to support sputnik homies, but i'll still be honest about it. |
brickhed
11.07.25 | i've seen people argue storm of the lights bane just as melodeath as meloblack and man are those people on something
also i see that people only want to rec albums but not try to engage with me anymore as i review them. i'll just update it silently if thats the case. |
Hawks
11.07.25 | SOTB is not melodeath at all agreed. |
Rowhaus
11.07.25 | [2]
The first I'm hearing of that comparison actually. Can't say I get it |
Hawks
11.07.25 | I never have gotten it lol. I've heard that for many years now. |
Keyblade
11.07.25 | first 2 tracks on 7 are 2 of the best for me, but great to see ur enjoying that album |
Eakflanderyof
11.07.25 | I think people hear twin guitar harmonies and just think melodeath for whatever reason |
Rowhaus
11.07.25 | yeah Cradle of Filth is my favorite melodeath band lol |
Hawks
11.07.25 | LMAOOOOOOO |
pyroflare77
11.07.25 | Well it's been a hot minute since I've spun Dissection so I have nothing to say there other than the dungeon synth vibe I actually get. I did rejam hordalands and while I'd like more riffs than the one closing track 2 to stick around in my head it is indeed quite varied. I like that he doesn't stick in one lane and dances around. |
bach
11.09.25 | 28 is one of my faves bro. Excited to hear your take on it. I think their later albums are without a doubt tighter sounding and heavier but its my favorite immortal. |
brickhed
11.10.25 | sounds promising
also pls don't flame me for not worshipping a well loved band right out the gate |
Hawks
11.10.25 | Thats quite an opinion for The Ruins of Beverast lol. |
Rowhaus
11.10.25 | Ouch! I actually recommended that album because I think it's fairly accessible lol. My boomer dad likes Exuvia and he pretty much dislikes anything that isn't Led Zeppelin or Frank Zappa. Rain Upon the Impure may be more up your alley if you wanna give that one a go m/ |
brickhed
11.11.25 | well for now colbalt is done
might listen to rain upon the impure later, the band has good ideas and i'm sure i'll find something that i really like from em. |
Sevengill
11.11.25 | Exuvia was the album where Beverast clicked for me but yeah, what Row said. Rain on the Impure. |
brickhed
11.12.25 | not liking oathbreaker but hey i'm getting through it |
Rowhaus
11.12.25 | never been a fan either tbh |
brickhed
11.12.25 | this album did not get better as i tried to get through it. kind of got more and more of a slog. flay me sputbros i don't care |
Sevengill
11.12.25 | why would anyone flay you for giving it an honest go and deciding it's not for you |
demigod!
11.12.25 | i know darkthrone is already here but you gotta listen to under a funeral moon |
budgie
11.12.25 | yeah under a funeral moon and aske are the purest and truest black metal albums |
brickhed
11.13.25 | ight ive been warming up to that type of bm recently, ill give em a shot again a bit later |
brickhed
11.13.25 | uh yeah augur rules, has another stamp of approval |
Hawks
11.13.25 | Yeah, Botb killed it. |
botb
11.13.25 | 🫡🫡🫡🫡 thanks for checking it, happy you liked it! |
Beardog
11.13.25 | Love to see the Augur love, curious what you think about my recs! |
brickhed
11.14.25 | i'll be sure to check out more winterfylleth, there's some excellent songwriting that i'm sure is honed on in later releases. |
Hawks
11.14.25 | Winterfylleth's whole discog kicks ass. |
brickhed
11.17.25 | honestly for a mixed bag this could be a whole lot worse
yeah i'm getting a sense of what i do and don't want out of black metal now |
Hawks
11.17.25 | Jam the first two Sargeist albums asap. |
Beardog
11.17.25 | Yeah Winterfylleth is great. You'd probably like earlier Der Weg Einer Freiheit records more |
Hawks
11.17.25 | Agreed. Der Weg's first album is a masterpiece. |
brickhed
11.18.25 | 14 albums left (!11!!!11!) |
brickhed
11.20.25 | okay i'm back, doing a lot of stuff as of right now but i'm still on it |
solrage
11.20.25 | I'm not the biggest fan of traditional BM. I tend to either go for the proggier, more experimental stuff or the "black 'n' roll" stuff that harkened back to Motorhead and thrash. So here's recs based on that:
Emperor - Prometheus: The Discipline of Fire & Demise (proggy)
Deathspell Omega - Paracletus (proggy)
Thy Darkened Shade - Liber Lvcifer I (proggy)
Immortal - At the Heart of Winter (black n' roll)
I - Between Two Worlds (black n' roll)
Midnight - Satanic Royalty (black n' roll) |
Eakflanderyof
11.20.25 | Never got the hype for midnight but to each their own. Might've been the most boring live show ive ever seen though |
solrage
11.23.25 | Haven't seen them live. It's not like the best metal out there, but I'm just a sucker for well-done old-school-ish metal. I also don't think the stuff they did after their debut was all that memorable. |
Emim
11.23.25 | I feel like you normally want the bm to get out, no? |
brickhed
11.24.25 | we are BACK and with a banger |
Sevengill
11.24.25 | and set up for another when you get to Enthrone 🍻 Mourning Palace is a pillar in the black metal pantheon |
Hawks
11.24.25 | Mourning Palace is in the running for best bm song ever made easily agreed. |
brickhed
11.25.25 | okay dimmu borger did not hit has hard as expected, but its still a solid listen. |
Sevengill
11.25.25 | it's not a hard hitter, true. the vibe is more Eggers than Romero. |
Hawks
11.25.25 | It is a hard hitter yes agreed, but 3.5 is acceptable. |
BigTuna
11.25.25 | Drudkh - Microcosmos
Coldworld - Melancholie
These are the two that got me into bm. |
Hawks
11.25.25 | ^^^^^^ Amazing choices. |
Sevengill
11.25.25 | it appears Hawks and I use the term "hard hitter" differently |
brickhed
11.30.25 | double feature to make up for the days i missed |
Dedes
11.30.25 | For your particular tastes I get the vibe you might reallllly dig The Voice of Steel by Nokturnal Mortum if you're a big Drudkh fan
Not to say they're terribly similar but if you could take that same autumnal folk-tinged atmosphere and make it EPIC i feel it'd be sorta that |
Sevengill
11.30.25 | amazing dedication to still be going on this list
makin me nervous about Dzö |
botb
11.30.25 | Man I love that mgla record. So much energy, so many riffs, so many little drum fills |
Hawks
11.30.25 | Mgla's whole discog slays. |
Dedes
11.30.25 | Honestly
With Hearts Towards None could very well actually be on par with Exercises
The moroseness and nihilism are unfuckwithable |
Hawks
11.30.25 | With Hearts Towards None is their best indeed. |
Sevengill
11.30.25 | I've got their compilation cassette and I'm thinking it's time to break that out for the dark winter days |
Hawks
11.30.25 | Would be a good choice. |
brickhed
12.01.25 | can't sleep so i might as well write this up
also i gotta stop listening to these albums tired, since it might skew things a little. |
budgie
12.01.25 | if your favorite bm so far is folk bc of the folk instrument passages you gotta listen to finntroll (and cruachan) at some point |
brickhed
12.02.25 | i've heard of finntroll and anything pagan bm piques my interest.
scarcity is for sure out there but its clicking |
Hawks
12.02.25 | Yeah, if you're veering towards viking/folk/pagan stuff then you have to hear the first three Enslaved albums and the first two Satyricon albums asap. |
budgie
12.02.25 | cruachan - pagan is super underrated, has violins n shit |
Sevengill
12.02.25 | waffling on whether to keep Dzö TITM as my rec or suggest The Sachem's Tales instead. TST is prolly a better album even though it's garbage production. |
brickhed
12.03.25 | if I can hear the riffs, then i'll give it a shot. |
brickhed
12.03.25 | couldent review 32 until most of the day had past so i can't remember much right now. i'll write an actual review on a relisten. |
Sevengill
12.06.25 | yeah that's what I was worried about |
brickhed
12.09.25 | okay we done, now time to add this whole list to my website |
Hawks
12.09.25 | First Spell rules so hard. |
Sevengill
12.09.25 | pretty amazing follow-through on this one. well done, lad, well done. |
Rowhaus
12.10.25 | [2]
Love seeing lists like these actually get finished |
brickhed
12.15.25 | got it all added to my website, plz take a look
https://underground-mementos.neocities.org/ |
naughtcturnal
12.15.25 | Not sure if it counts but Sigh - Imaginary Sonicscapes |