User
Reviews 37 Approval 96%
Soundoffs 22 Album Ratings 202 Objectivity 85%
Last Active 05-11-23 10:17 pm Joined 05-11-23
Review Comments 930
| gribbe solemn dungeon synth
i'll give a couple examples of what i'm looking for below | 1 |  | Burzum Daudi Baldrs
examples: Móti Ragnarokum, Illa tiðandi | 2 |  | Burzum The Ways of Yore
examples: Emptiness, From Hel and Back Again | 3 |  | Secret Stairways Enchantment of the Ring
this album mixes some melancholic atmosphere very well, examples are i dunno the whole album | 4 |  | Pumpkin Witch Hovel of the Pumpkin Witch
reced by hawks
this is way too repetitive. i do like the ultra lo fi aesthetic here, but things almost feel padded out with how very little new elements are introduced in each track. you better like the main melody, you're gonna hear it for 7-8 minutes. other than the main problem it's pretty cool, but with how repetitive it is I'm not gonna return to this often.
the last track is actually pretty good, instead letting a good loop of music do most of the work. the other loops used in the other tracks are just not good enough for 8 minutes. Dawn Breaks Over the Pumpkin Patch does justify its runtime, so go listen to that track.
final score: 3.0 | 5 |  | Summoning Let Mortal Heroes Sing Your Fame
reced by RVAHC13
yeah this is pretty overly epic music. i'm usually not a big fan of this type, since it feels like it alienates me in the process. but not in this album. this is good, but not what i'm looking for. it kinda seems like dungeon synth with a black metal flair, which is nice.
the raspy black metal vocals are pretty cool and the drum machine is used well, and not in a "lets hide it in the mix" context. the synth leads are quite catchy, too. i really love how everything is mixed, with the black metal rasps not too bold in the mix, and it kinda seems like all of the elements get their time to shine.
solemn score: not sad, which makes me sad
final score: 3.0 (may revisit, though) | 6 |  | Drowning the Light The Longing
reced by RVAHC13
(2nd listen rewrite)
The main image i associate with this album is a dark wizard exiled from the local kingdom. Being secluded in the woods, the extreme isolation has damaged his mental state. In turn, he's become depressed. His shack is sparce, but does good enough to cope in the state he's in.
With storytime out of the way, this music is very depressive. I may have even produced some tears listening to Drowning the Light and Howling Forests of Desolation. Maybe I was close on Tortured Overture. It is a bit hit or miss, but when it hits, it hits very hard. Azgorh's black metal rasps are actually kind of scary paired with the depressive nature of this record. The drumming is pretty top notch most of the time, with some of the fills leaving me that it was more than just that.
If the music can move me that much emotionally, then brownie points must be given.
solemn score: borderline suffocating. when it clicks, at least.
final score: 3.5 | 7 |  | Burzum Burzum
reced by RVAHC13
song: Channelling the Power of Souls Into a New God
damn we really have Varg pioneering this niche subgenre of music. this came out in 1992, which was the genre's absolute infancy. this feels equal parts evil and melancholic, which fits the action of channeling the power of souls into a new god. tracks like this let your imagination run wild, and i love it. it has a light aura of cheese around the synth tone, but that by no means holds it back. god damn, this might be one of my favorite dungeon synth tracks of all time.
go listen to it now, this is top tier dungeon synth. if there's a ds album out there with this level of songwriting i need to get my hands on it. seriously, how does Burzum both knock my socks off with this style of music and also make some bafflingly bad shit? it's insane.
solumn score: evilness incarnate, off the carts.
final score: 5.0 | 8 |  | Old Nick Crisp Winter Dawn of my Night Moon
reced by hawks
wow. this is sure a record. this ep prefects fun music in a way that i haven't heard. even the cover art alone should give a good indication of the wack in this album. for one, the drumming excellent, even if it is super over compressed on purpose. the dungeon synth is only a foundation for the goofy, off the wall sound. is this what i'm looking for? not in the slightest. am i all for it? hell yeah, count me in. Old Nick knows how to make a depressive genre such as black metal super fun.
solemn score: so fun i don't care.
final score: 4.0 | 9 |  | Shadowland (RUS) A
reced by budgie
this is decent dungeon synth, nothing spectacular. some of the songwriting is nice, but it does little to keep my attention. the black metal riffs do blend seamlessly with the dungeon synth. I'm just not feeling it most of the time. the whispers on the first track do suck. the drum machine serves its purpose, and is barely there when it's doing its job. the last track is pretty cool, but thats it.
solemn score: pretty nice, not too suffocating though.
final score: 2.5 | 10 |  | Castlesiege The Council of Trees
reced by ToSmokMuzyki
if i wanted to play old school runescape i would. yes i have an account i barely play on anymore, its clumps23.
its generic dungeon synth, for the better or worse. at times the songwriting is interesting, but it has to be somewhat top notch to get me invested in the 'stereotypical dungeon synth' sound. the nature samples are pretty interesting, but when it comes to this type of music simplicity is key. its why i tend to stick to old school dungeon synth. the semi lo fi aesthetic and simple nature is kind of lost on some of these revival acts. most of the time it's okay.
solemn score: it's there a little.
final score: 2.5 | 11 |  | Skarpseian Fragmenter Av Trolldom
reced by ScuroFantasma
now we're talking. this takes the foundations of old school ds (semi low fi production and cheap synths) and creates an intimidating and sad atmosphere. it gets downright depressive at times with Sorg I Stein. this feels like you're finding out the lore of an entire castle and village in ruins. exploring areas once vastly populated, but now nothing persists, and hasn't since it went down decades ago. Dungeon synth that really helps you fill in the blanks with your imagination, which is where the best stuff in the genre is.
solemn score: sad and at times depressing. great stuff
final score: 4.5 | 12 |  | Fortress of Mystery La Rose de Fer
reced by ScuroFantasma
now this is a dud. i get it. you want to use cheap synth presets to the fullest. that's what Burzum did on Daudi Balders, right? But it seems like Fortress of Mystery took the worst aspects of it (the awful cheesy presets) and ramps it up tenfold. and its for the entire album. if i wanted an atmosphere that would drive me insane, this would be great. all of the presets clash together like slamming a square block in a circle hole.
yeah this kinda sucked. on paper its interesting, but in execution it really feels like they're brute forcing it, hoping something works. hearing the vocal presets suddenly cut out ruins any and all potential at an atmosphere when they do appear. i'll give it another chance later but right now its not really clicking.
final score: 2.0 | 13 |  | Aindulmedir The Lunar Lexicon
reced by bach
very minimalist 'winter synth' as they call it. it mostly gives off a forest vibe, but i do get some winter vibes with some of the wind samples. it's quite repetitive but that's not a problem most of the time. it doesn't overstay its welcome with its 35-minute runtime. a highlight is Snow Above Blue Fire. everything is paced so perfectly that i'm surprised its only 3 and a half minutes. will need a re-listen but as it is i'm diggin it.
solemn score: dreary and lonely. good nuff.
final score: 3.5 | 14 |  | Vindkaldr Enchantments Of Old Lore
reced by bach
this feels very much inspired by 3. but it does feel a lot more ambient in how subtle the melodies are. but thats not to say the melodies are bad when they appear, they're pretty great. a lot of the time it's moreso dishing out sound textures, which is fine but can feel a tad played out when the album is over. the melodies feel like a special treat to reward the listener, which is nice.
when i first looked at the 1 hour and 24 minute runtime, i thought it would waste my time. but it utilized the time pretty well, but i still feel it could be trimmed down in certain places. the last track is where it could be trimmed down the most. the vibe ranges from mysterious and melancholic to somewhat depressing in one track. its a different take on most DS, which i like. pretty cool, i dig.
solemn score: mysterious indeed.
final score: 4.0 | 15 |  | Wongraven Fjelltronen
reced by mystagogus
really not feeling this one. the vocals overpower the synths a lot in a say that feels offputting, and it kind of feels like the dungeon synth was put off to the side. the fourth track does a decent job at actually doing DS, but as for the rest it kind of doesn't fit. its all right.
solemn score: its there
final score: 2.5 | 16 |  | Lunar Womb The Sleeping Green
reced by mystagogus
this type of dungeon synth does not do it for me. it feels overly epic to where i feel alienated, and i don't find the loops to be interesting enough to be invested. i've found that i like minimalistic DS best, and this is not it. there's a lot of stuff being thrown around that doesn't fully work in the beginning. also this is nowhere near the vibes i was looking for.
this feels like DS that fills in the blanks for you, complete with nature samples to make sure your mind is exactly where the artists wants it. kinda spoils the fun for me, but its a personal preference. i can see others really liking this, but not me.
solemn score: null. was the prompt read? probably not.
final score: 2.5 | 17 |  | Ornatorpet Bergtagen
reced by garas
not really finding the vibe. the typical mediveal vibe from a lot of ds is not really what i'm craving all that much. but its still a pretty good release.
solemn score: null
final score: 3.0 | 18 |  | Path of Giants Melted Ice on the Coast of Destiny
reced by ToSmokMuzyki
nice, more depressive dunegon synth. this rivals Drowning the Light (though is still outclassed) in just how bleak the atmosphere is. judging from the themes i though i wouldn't be able to take this seriously, but nah. it manages to be just minimalist enough to paint a powerful sense of despair and helplessness. theres also a very strong winter synth vibe here, which i like. cool stuff.
solemn score: borderline suffocating.
final score: 4.0 | 19 |  | Darken Wood I
reced by Pho3nix
(2end listen rewrite)
this album has good ideas, but most of them don't really stick with me. the melodies are okay most of the time, with the last 2 tracks actually getting my real interest. that being said, those are very good DS tracks. Friends in Unexpected Times has a nice melody in the back that serves as the backbone, with An Unexpected Path being great all around. it has an oppressive atmosphere paired with a more melancholic and uplifting one, trading off of each other. its a real nice track that makes me wish the rest of the album was the same.
solemn score: when it works, its very nice. but its rare.
final score: 2.5 | 20 |  | Skeld The Ghosts of Ancient Kings
reced by Pho3nix
this feels like a soundtrack to a tyrannical kingdom, like something out of Ultima 5. Its dark and brooding, and when it is sad it's with oppressive undertones. Simulacrum sounds downright evil and sinister, like some type of dank dungeon. A Light in the Ruins does a good job at sending the album off. it's a very interesting listen in how it mixes an oppressive atmosphere in different ways.
solemn score: a good mix of different types of sad atmospheres. nice.
final score: 3.5 | 21 |  | Quest Master The Twelve Temples
reced by bach
saving this for last, per recommendation
this being the last album was really the best thing. god damn, on first listen this is a perfect album. there is nothing i could wish that could be more. everything about it is perfect. let me go one step at a time.
first off: the theming. it puts just enough dressing to give you a vague plot, but lets you fill in the blanks. this is mainly due to the music. its just minimalistic enough, but not too much. this was the first album here that i didn't need to close my eyes and really use my head, the imagination aspect came very naturally.
the songwriting is top notch, rivaling the Burzum track from 7. the best aspect is that it really makes you feel like you're on a grand adventure like no other. there will be ups, downs, death, and loss. but also triumph, in rare doses. but even the closer gives a melancholic feel, making you wonder if the quest was all that it seemed. | 22 |  | Quest Master The Twelve Temples
In a lot of dunegon synth, it oversells mystical whimsy to the point where i can't take it seriously, like some type of cartoon. this album really makes sure to give a real weight and balance to all of the moods that the album has. there is some whimsy, but that's before you see the reality of your quest. on the second track it really makes you feel like you're in for it.
anyway, might be the best dunegon synth album i've heard.
solemn score: very, very well balanced with similar moods.
final score: 5.0 | |
brickhed
06.26.25 | i know that dungeon synth tends to stick to a small handful of sounds but ones outside of pure high fantasy whimsy (like most ds) would be appreciated. | Hawks
06.26.25 | Pumpkin Witch - Hovel of the Pumpkin Witch | RVAHC13
06.26.25 | Drowning the Light - The Longing
Burzum - Channeling the Power of Souls into a New God
Summoning - pretty much every album has something I think | brickhed
06.26.25 | yeah where the hell is that burzum one, its not on sput or rate your music | RVAHC13
06.26.25 | It’s the fourth track off of the self titled | Hawks
06.26.25 | If you're taking dungeon synth-infused bm then here's a good one:
Old Nick - Crisp Winter Dawn of My Night Moon | brickhed
06.27.25 | i would quite prefer just dungeon synth by itself, but i'm willing to branch out | Hawks
06.27.25 | It's a nice mashup of both styles. That band rules. | budgie
06.27.25 | this one is sick https://shadowland1.bandcamp.com/album/a-ep it does have some actual live instrumentation/percussion in it | brickhed
06.27.25 | budgie if its not dungeon synth related I'll flay you over teh interwebz (not take your recs seriously) | budgie
06.27.25 | youre kind of a cunt huh | brickhed
06.27.25 | despite my excitement for 6 imma just go in order, starting off with a solid eh | ToSmokMuzyki
06.28.25 | castlesiege - council of trees | ScuroFantasma
06.29.25 | Skarpseian - Tan Gil | ScuroFantasma
06.29.25 | I’ll give an honorable mention to Fortress of Mystery - La Rose de Fer
It’s a bit weird and unsettling, definitely pretty solemn. Could be in the ballpark of what you’re looking for outside of more traditional ds.
| brickhed
06.29.25 | yeah, traditional dungeon synth just dosent do it for me much. recs sound pretty dope, i'll get to em all soon. | ScuroFantasma
06.29.25 | Actually, swap Tan Gil for Fragmenter Av Trolldom, matches the vibe a bit better imo. | bach
06.29.25 | Aindulmedir - the lunar lexicon | bach
06.29.25 | Quest Master - the twelve temples
Vindkaldr - enchantments of old lore | garas
06.29.25 | Fragmenter Av Trolldom [2]
And a rec from me: maybe you would enjoy Örnatorpet - Bergtagen. | RVAHC13
06.29.25 | Full disclosure I only just got into dungeon synth like a year ago lol | mystagogus
06.29.25 | Wongraven - Fjelltronen
Lunar Womb - The Sleeping Green | brickhed
06.29.25 | yeah ornatorpet's album is not on sput
also i'm capping this out at 20 albums | garas
06.29.25 | @brickhed: https://www.sputnikmusic.com/soundoff.php?albumid=302646 | garas
06.29.25 | Woops, I sent that twice. But anyway, you can try any of Örnatorpet's albums. | brickhed
06.29.25 | yeah of course why dident i think that sput couldn't handle the umlaut
if a release is NOT solemn and depressive i'll be very sad but move on | ToSmokMuzyki
06.29.25 | oh u wanted depressed yeah council of trees is just hanging out with your lignin buddies if u'd rather be smushed then path of giants - melted ice on the coast of destiny is pretty bleak | brickhed
06.29.25 | 5 may not be what i'm looking for but still is cool nonetheless | RVAHC13
06.29.25 | I should’ve mentioned I was recommending the title track from 6 although you might enjoy the rest of it for similar reasons as 5 | bach
06.30.25 | Brickhed im sorry didnt even read your list thoroughly before I gave recs but hopefully you dig what I suggested anyway. Definitely some solemn sounding tracks on all three, but I would listen to quest Master last as its probably not quite what you're looking for. Still some of the best dungeon synth I've heard in a minute tho | brickhed
06.30.25 | yeah don't worry most people don't, which is why ive been mentioning the recs better be actually solumn
I'll still give everything here a shot | bach
06.30.25 | 13 is definitely solemn. almost feels like a lost silent hill ost that never was used and got repurposed as dungeon/winter synth. | brickhed
06.30.25 | okay did 6 since its kind of a late night for me anyway | brickhed
06.30.25 | 8 and 9 are both ep's so my work here is done for today | brickhed
07.02.25 | still updating this if anyone cares | ToSmokMuzyki
07.02.25 | im reporting you to the council prepare to get a sudden branch up somewhere | ScuroFantasma
07.03.25 | Heck yeah, glad you liked Skarpseian. Very curious about your take on the next one, but it’s a bit of a wild card. | garas
07.03.25 | We told you that Skarpseian is goooood. I listened to that record many times while reading the Silmarillion. (Also I own the album on vinyl too.) | brickhed
07.03.25 | yeah i may bump it to a 4.5 in the future since it took me a while to be in the dungeon synth mood to absorb what i was hearing. clicked with me on the second half.
also i've giving The Longing a relisten and jesus this is some of the most depressive music i've come across by a mile. makes Skarpseian seem somewhat joyful in comparison. good thing i revisited it. | ScuroFantasma
07.03.25 | > I listened to that record many times while reading the Silmarillion
What a good idea, I’ll do that. | bach
07.04.25 | The longing is such a great album agreed | Pho3nix
07.04.25 | A few great picks in this list! it has been ages since I listened to Vindkaldr and Path of Giants... need to give them a re-listen soon.
For "solemn and depressive" I would rec the following three: Skymningsvävd, Darken Wood and Skeld:
https://skymningsvavd.bandcamp.com/album/fragment
https://darkenwood.bandcamp.com/album/i
https://skeld.bandcamp.com/album/the-ghosts-of-ancient-kings | Pho3nix
07.04.25 | Forgot to mention Moss Troll if you're into a more specific theme / ambience:
https://mosstroll.bandcamp.com/album/yearn-ye-feeble-stonecutters
https://mosstroll.bandcamp.com/album/the-weeping-everglades
Snowspire for winter-synth:
https://snowspire.bandcamp.com/album/solace-among-the-spruce-sorrow-among-the-snow
Honorable mention similar to Skymningsvävd:
https://voldsomtapes.bandcamp.com/album/til-det-bergens-skyggene
Horror / Vampire-synth:
https://wallachiancobwebs.bandcamp.com/album/hearken-to-the-moon-whisper-4
Dwalin for reading Tolkien:
https://dwalin1.bandcamp.com/album/the-red-book
| ScuroFantasma
07.06.25 | Rip, well, worth a shot | brickhed
07.09.25 | okay got some albums done and i'm finding out what niche of ds i like
also i'll add two albums for phoenix | brickhed
07.13.25 | okay we done and damn quest master last was a great call
other than a few relistens of some albums thats it | ToSmokMuzyki
07.14.25 | rly out of everything quest master wins | brickhed
07.14.25 | yah suck it | ToSmokMuzyki
07.14.25 | i did it only had a mild flavour | bach
07.14.25 | hell yeah man I'm glad you liked quest master. Wasn't super melancholic as some of the others on this list but v dynamic stuff for dungeon aynrh |
|