JoyfulPlatypus
Your #1 Most Loved Semiaquatic, Egg-Laying Mammal
User

Reviews 22
Approval 89%

Soundoffs 181
News Articles 22
Band Edits + Tags 28
Album Edits 80

Album Ratings 1476
Objectivity 87%

Last Active 01-04-23 1:10 am
Joined 06-10-15

Review Comments 806

 Lists
12.15.23 Platy's 2023 Year in Review 05.23.23 SPUT SURVEY: How Do You Approach a New
05.09.23 Platy's 2020's Recap: Pt. 105.05.23 Carly Rae Jepsen Ranked
03.30.23 S-Tier Songs Off Crappy Albums03.21.23 Pierce the Veil Ranked
03.09.23 Grouplove Ranked12.29.22 Platy's 5 Best Releases: 2010's Decade
12.29.22 Platy's 10 Worst Releases of 202212.23.22 Platy's 25 Best Releases of 2022
07.20.22 Platy's 10 All-Time Favorite Artists07.15.22 Platy's 10 Best Mid 2022 Releases
03.20.22 Why don't bad/average albums ever trend12.23.21 Platy's 25 Best Releases of 2021
12.16.21 Platy's 10 Worst Releases of 202111.18.21 Paramore/Hayley Williams Ranked
11.15.21 Poppy Ranked11.13.21 Don Broco Ranked
More »

S-Tier Songs Off Crappy Albums

Thought I'd take a break from ranking different discographies and do something a little special. Recently hit 1200 ratings so let's just call this a celebration of sorts. A couple things to note though:
1Corey Feldman
Angelic 2 The Core


"Crappy" is defined by an album that is either straight-up bad, immensely disappointing, or an album that is perceived by the general public of being terrible.
2Talking Heads
Remain in Light


"S-Tier" is defined as a song that is top notch. I'm not just considering guilty pleasures (though there are still lots of those). The songs I consider "S-Tier" have to legitimately slap, and slap HARD.
3Peppa Pig
Peppa's Adventures: The Album


Lastly - this is in no particular order. I went through my rankings and added songs as I thought of them. Enough wasting time!!
4All Time Low
Last Young Renegade


LIFE OF THE PARTY

This is All Time Low going full on pop, and doing it WELL. Every now and then I hear this song and am tempted to give LYR another shot, but I don't want to just disappoint myself again.
5Fall Out Boy
American Beauty/American Psycho


THE KIDS AREN'T ALRIGHT

Stump just sounds so good on this track, and the chorus is god damn catchy.
6Metro Station
Metro Station


SHAKE IT

Okay yeah, this is pure guilty pleasure material. Not ashamed of it.
7Nicki Minaj
Pink Friday


ROMAN'S REVENGE (FEAT. EMINEM)

Another guilty pleasure. This one I'm a little ashamed of.
8Taylor Swift
Reputation


...READY FOR IT?

Okay yeah, the rapped verses are a bit iffy, but this is otherwise top-notch Taylor Swift in my book.
9Thirty Seconds to Mars
Love Lust Faith + Dreams


UP IN THE AIR

This song is stupid and slaps way harder than it has any right to. I saw this live too when I was younger - maybe that's why I still like it.
10Linkin Park
One More Light


ONE MORE LIGHT

No explanation needed really. This song hits so much harder since Bennington passed.
11Weezer
Raditude


TRIPPING DOWN THE FREEWAY

I could've put a few songs from this trainwreck of an album on this list. Even when Weezer's at their worst, they always churn out a couple decent songs.
12CHVRCHES
Love Is Dead


GRAFFITI

Man, my hopes were SO HIGH after hearing this opening track, only for the rest of the album to nosedive in quality. This is legit one of the band's best tracks though.
13Breathe Carolina
Savages


BURY ME/SELLOUTS (FEAT. DANNY WORSNOP)

Yeah this is cheating but I don't care. Bury Me is a pop slapper and Sellouts is possibly the best "heavy" song that Breathe Carolina ever made. Kind of ironic that the whole song was about how they weren't going to be heavy anymore though. Guess they were true to their word.
14Falling in Reverse
The Drug in Me Is You


THE DRUG IN ME IS YOU

God dammit Radke is such a shit songwriter most of the time but he knows how to write a killer hook.
15Green Day
iTRE!


BRUTAL LOVE

Yeah it's cheesy as hell, but this is SUCH a good opener and it has such a satisfying climactic ending.
16Papa Roach
Ego Trip


KILL THE NOISE

Jacoby Shaddix is a bit like Ronnie Radke - even if most of the songs he writes nowadays are trash, he still knows how to write a killer chorus.
17Weezer
Pacific Daydream


MEXICAN FENDER

Yeah this is pretty much the same explanation as #11 lol
18Green Day
Father of All Motherfuckers


MEET ME ON THE ROOFTOP

The production is ass but this is an otherwise top-notch Green Day track.
19Marilyn Manson
The High End of Low


ARMA-GODDAMN-MOTHERFUCKIN-GEDDON

Oh come on, how can you NOT see that crazy-ass title and not immediately love it a little? All joking aside, I can thank Saints Row for turning me onto this song.
20Lady Gaga
Born This Way


JUDAS

This is easily Gaga's worst album, but Judas would be a highlight even on her best releases.
21Kanye West
808s and Heartbreak


LOVE LOCKDOWN

Yeah yeah I know this isn't a universally panned album or anything, I just didn't like it. With that said, Love Lockdown is still one I come back to from time-to-time.
22Architects
The Classic Symptoms of a Broken Spirit


BURN DOWN MY HOUSE

Wait a minute, I thought butt-rock was bad? How can there be a GOOD iteration of it??? Excuse me?????
23Katy Perry
Smile


NEVER REALLY OVER

Lol remember when this album got hella review bombed before it came out and had everyone thinking this was gonna be Emotion 2.0? Well pepperidge farm remembers. Anyway, this is a killer opener.
24No Doubt
Push and Shove


UNDERCOVER

I'm aware that this is hardly even a real No Doubt song, but it's such a good pop track that I don't even care.
25Twenty One Pilots
Blurryface


TEAR IN MY HEART

I'm sure if I gave this album another listen I wouldn't hate it as much as I used to, but god dammit it was so overplayed for like 2 years I don't know if I feel like it. I love this song because of how much of an earworm it is but I also kinda hate it for the same reason.
26The Naked and Famous
Recover


BURY US

Man, I LOVED their debut album and have been underwhelmed by nearly everything else they've released since. But I'm not gonna lie, Bury Us reminds me of the good ole days of PM, AY
27M.I.A.
AIM


Sinternet:

BORDERS
28Iron Maiden
Virtual XI


Bookofthefallen:

THE CLANSMAN

(went with this one because the avg rating of this album is lower)
29Weezer
Raditude


Drifter:

CAN'T STOP PARTYING (FEAT. LIL WAYNE)
30Creed
Weathered


YoYoMancuso:

WEATHERED
31Trivium
The Crusade


Irikeheavymetal:

THE CRUSADE
32Converge
Jane Doe


JeetJeet:

JANE DOE
33M83
Junk


Masochist:

DO IT, TRY IT/GO!
34Weezer
The Black Album


Drbebop:

CALIFORNIA SNOW
35I Prevail
TRAUMA


Emim:

BOW DOWN
36Deftones
White Pony


BaselineOOO:

CHANGE (IN THE HOUSE OF FLIES)
37Elbow
The Seldom Seen Kid


Shemson:

GROUNDS FOR DIVORCE
38Primitive Radio Gods
Rocket


Fogza:

STANDING OUTSIDE A BROKEN PHONE BOOTH WITH MONEY IN MY HAND
39Metallica
St. Anger


JerseyJimmy:

THE UNNAMED FEELING
40Queensryche
Rage for Order


Parallels:

I WILL REMEMBER
41Alkaline Trio
This Addiction


Onionbubs:

FINE
42Atreyu
Lead Sails Paper Anchor


Johnny:

BLOW (this album had the lowest avg of the three you suggested)
43David Bowie
Tonight


AlexKzillion:

LOVING THE ALIEN
44Bring Me the Horizon
That's the Spirit


Trebor:

DROWN
45Massacre
Promise


TheSonomaDude:

WHERE DWELLS SADNESS
46dredg
Chuckles and Mr. Squeezy


PumpOffBag:

THE TENT
47Avenged Sevenfold
Avenged Sevenfold


Wildcardbitchesss:

AFTERLIFE
Show/Add Comments (48)

STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy