Emeritus
Reviews 172 Approval 98%
Soundoffs 200 News Articles 34 Band Edits + Tags 478 Album Edits 1,058
Album Ratings 5887 Objectivity 86%
Last Active 01-01-70 12:00 am Joined 01-01-70
Review Comments 21,030
| MarsBro's Court of 2019
Welcome to the list I'm gonna use to get through even more 2019 stuff, but with a bit of a twist to it. | 1 | | Macho Man Randy Savage Be A Man
Here are the rules:
1. Any album submitted must be from 2019.
2. I have my preferences, naturally, but all genres are welcome.
3. Each user can give up to 3 recommendations.
4. Recommendations can be either: i. a record I haven't heard, ii. a record not yet released but will come out in 2019, or iii. a record I HAVE heard but you believe I should rate higher (a 3.5 to a 4, 4 to a 4.5, etc.) | 2 | | Macho Man Randy Savage Be A Man
With regards to ii., if it's a record I already was aware of, you may rec something else instead.
Bring the new stuff or bring something for new judgement! | 3 | | Saor Forgotten Paths
from Scheumke
VERDICT: Naturally, Saor's latest offering is about as epic a black metal release as you can find. The melodies are beautiful and the song structuring is worthy of praise for its brilliant balancing of quiet, folksy moments and rousing tremolo riffs. Surprisingly, this was a brief listen--under 40 minutes--and it could have easily been longer. Certain shortcomings hold this back, chief among them being a level of predictability in how each track progresses. The vocal performance also leaves a lot to be desired. Those instances of calm could have expanded upon much more, with their accompanying transitions less jarring/expected. In sum, this was excellent, but it doesn't quite attain a greater tier. 4.0 | 4 | | De Staat Bubble Gum
from Scheumke
VERDICT: This is rather unconventional, yet despite that--or precisely because of it--it is insanely addictive, sporting uncannily-powerful choruses and lead synths/guitars/whatever they choose to do. It's delivered in a funky manner with an overarching attitude of 'yeah this is how we're gonna play, what are you gonna do about it?' It's entertaining, but incredibly well-produced. Essentially, it's how anything dubbed as 'fun music' should be, and I foresee this being stuck in my head for a long time now. 4.5 | 5 | | Heilung Futha
from Scheumke | 6 | | Otori Digitalized Human Nature
from JohnnyoftheWell
VERDICT: Couldn't find a way to listen to this, so I s'pose it's on hold for now. | 7 | | 100 Gecs 1000 gecs
from Johnny
VERDICT: Drown me in a fucking river. 1.0 | 8 | | Dots (.........) Points
from Johnny
VERDICT: There is a very pleasant, spacey sort of atmosphere that dominates the record, making it a very blissful listening experience. Coupled alongside a lofty, carefree vocal performance, Points becomes a recipe for light-hearted indie success. However, it becomes clear early on that song structures are very linear and hardly ever change, relying on basic melodies to propel themselves. It begins to morph from pleasant to drone-like, which equals to a growing sense of disappointment. 3.0 | 9 | | Wounds of Recollection You Were A Garden of Empyrean Light
from Nocte
VERDICT: Honestly, I'm not sure what made me take to this moreso than other post-black metal albums of a similar persuasion. I think perhaps what does it for me is how natural this feels and the blending of the quieter, ambient sections, with two tracks being devoted to instrumental works to set the mood. Still carried enough power inside to offer up strong tunes when the black metal riffs hit. 3.5 | 10 | | Clouds Collide They Don't Sleep Anymore
from Nocte
VERDICT: Maybe they don't sleep anymore, but I surely do after listening to this. It was as if someone desperately wished to NOT make a black metal album yet still made one out of obligation. This whole thing was so nebulous that I could hardly perceive it as it drifted away. The guitar tuning was a huge turn-off for me, as well as the amateurish clean vocals. Blackgaze can and has been done well, but this ain't how you go about it. 2.0 | 11 | | Orphalis The Approaching Darkness
from Nocte
INITIAL RATING: 3.0
NEW VERDICT: The brutality is certainly enjoyable alongside the accompanying technical elements, but the consistent song structures eventually run into the issue of blending together. Some cuts off of this are very catchy and others feel as though they simply exist and that's about it. The diminished bass presence is a definite issue, as this hampers some of the grooves that are crafted. That being said, it is still solid and I think my rating will remain as is: 3.0 | 12 | | Gaahls Wyrd Ghosts Invited
from garas
VERDICT: Some strong riffs and equally strong songs to boot, but the repetitive nature they tend to fall into makes for an unfortunately lackluster experience at times. Those memorable guitar chords are struck ad nausea until they lose their original appeal, with the structures of tracks rarely making compelling deviations. While I'm certainly not one to take much issue with vocals in black metal, some of the choices here--namely the spoken word-esque delivery--come across as sounding uninspired. It's a sturdy offering, but it doesn't hold up too well under scrutiny. 3.0 | 13 | | Mayhem Esoteric Warfare
from garas
NEW UNTITLED ALBUM, RELEASE PENDING [Oct. 25] | 14 | | Illyria The Carpathian Summit
from Hawks
VERDICT: Perhaps my identification skills aren't what they used to be (were they anything to begin with?), but I perceived very little black metal on this; there were more leanings towards melodic death metal and post-metal/rock. That being said, the soundscapes here and their accompanying atmosphere were beautiful to behold and had me hooked from the very beginning. It's always a difficult undertaking to make an hour-long album with no filler, but it was pulled off here in incredible fashion. There are issues I have with this, mainly the lack of maturity at parts--there is undeniable room for growth--but the spectacle as a whole is a thrilling journey. This is what Falls of Rauros wish they created. My mind says 4, but my heart is set on a 4.5 | 15 | | Warmoon Lord Burning Banners of the Funereal War
from Hawks
VERDICT: Warmoon Lord doesn't put on any airs, doesn't try to disguise his work; this is striaghtforward, in-your-face black metal. It's loud, it's got a healthy static content, and boy does it have riffs. Symphonic elements are used sparingly to add that little extra touch, which works to the album's benefit. The overall presentation coupled alongside the catchy guitar compositions give this an edge over peers. An easy 4.0 | 16 | | Murg Strävan
from Hawks
VERDICT: Pretty great! Not sure what this offers that peer groups don't, but it's a nice effort nevertheless. I just don't foresee it earning much higher praise from that point. 3.5 | 17 | | Off With Their Heads Be Good
from SlothcoreSam
VERDICT: The vocals here reminded me a bit of Bear vs. Shark. Considering the nature of this album--instruments are pretty one-note and rarely embark upon memorable melodies or otherwise interesting forays--a charismatic performance from the singing section is a requirement. This guy takes the weight of the album on his back and is able to deliver hook after hook with sufficient passion and emotional weight. Despite that energetic exhibition, the flaws of the album's instrumental contributions cannot be ignored. Those performances, in contrast, are sadly quite dull and drag down the quality of the disc. It's a big no-no when your songs start to bleed together even with vocals this good. 3.5 | 18 | | We Never Learned To Live The Sleepwalk Transmissions
from Sloth
VERDICT: It's always a pleasure to listen to a post-hardcore record that's not solely concerned with technicality these days. This particular album aimed for that post-rock, grandiose, spectacle-driven form of the genre, but it sadly falls flat due to a lack of truly powerful moments. The instrumental sector is fairly plain, rendering melodies to very basic riffs that are hard to distinguish from each other. Song structures are incredibly linear and the climaxes they sluggishly strive for are unimpressive. An 'A' for effort, but definitely not a passing grade overall. 2.5 | 19 | | Yugen Blakrok Anima Mysterium
from Sloth
VERDICT: Very similar beats and an unchanging vocal delivery weigh down heavily upon this album. I can be very picky with my rap/hip-hop and this isn't really giving me anything that I generally desire. Tracks started to bleed together since neither the performer nor their supporting elements offered much. Textbook average album. 2.5 | 20 | | Two People First Body
from Uzumaki
INITIAL RATING: 3.5
NEW VERDICT: I wish this maintained that atmosphere struck from the first two minutes of "I'm Tied, To You," but such is not the case; things drift off to such a faraway place that the potential emotional payoff is too disconnected. The presentation is airy, distanced from the audience, and some of the more electronic dance-y leaning elements further create issues. It's certainly a compelling album, but one that tends to pass over without saying much. I'll stick with where I started in this case: 3.5 | 21 | | Tricot Repeat
from Uzumaki
VERDICT: I'm actually disappointed that this wasn't as strange as the opener made it out to be. It started off in such an odd manner that was somehow charming and very compelling. What followed were a handful of sturdy math rock compositions that provided a nice, soothing ambiance. If it was more 'out-there,' I think I'd feel a lot more positive about it; it feels as though an opportunity was passed up here to be something special. 3.5 | 22 | | Jay Som Anak Ko
from Uzumaki
VERDICT: This was a vibin' kinda thang. I'm not usually for this stuff since it feels more meandering to me on most records of its type. But the compositions here are tight and feature such a chill, relaxing ambiance that it's hard not to sink into the sound. It helps that I was in an emotional flux while listening; the soothing tones brought me back down to Earth. 4.0 | 23 | | Remete (AUS) Into Endless Night
from Papa Universe
VERDICT: Here be some more post-metal soundscapes to digest. There's a nice ambiance that dominates this record, with the hazy production maintaining a distant presence from the audience while still retaining a bite. My biggest gripe, and the one that precludes this from a higher score, is that there are rarely any shifts/changes within tracks; a riff is crafted and then endures until the end. Those riffs add to the atmosphere but fail to captivate on their own for the time they're given. The general composition of each riff is also lacking in terms of individual identity, making tracks essentially coalesce into a whole--a whole with a nice mood, though with low aspirations. 3.0 | 24 | | Pedigree New Freak
from Papa
VERDICT: This was a nice, quick burst of energy. Didn't do much for me to warrant high marks, but for what it strives to do--in-your-face, jam-oriented punk--it succeeds for the most part. It starts to sound like it doesn't have much to offer despite the short length, which hampers it a little bit. Part of my dilemma here is that I cannot see myself having a reason to return to this; nothing special is here. 3.0 | 25 | | Fontaines D.C. Dogrel
from Papa
VERDICT: Post-punk in general is usually something I avoid; the realization hit me long ago that it's a genre not meant for my tastes. Yet, after walking away from this album, I was rather satisfied overall. It was naturally hindered by general problems I have with the category--apathetic vocals (which I get that's the point, but can't you emote at least once?), scaled-back instruments, excessive usage of repetition, absence of an 'umph' factor, and so on. The aesthetic this album sports does click in various spots, however, making it a nice albeit flawed experience. 3.5 | 26 | | Swans The Glowing Man
from ItsTheSquirrel
NEW ALBUM, RELEASE PENDING [?] | 27 | | Slumberland Sea Sea Sea Drifter See See See Drifter
from Trifolium
VERDICT: This was a series of interesting premises that either had no payoff or a payoff so lackluster it might as well have not been there. There was an attempt to craft some kind of ambiance, but there's not much consistency to it, with the record often backtracking on its own development. Many tracks just wandered about seemingly without purpose, turning a comparatively brief 40-minute disc into an unnecessarily elongated affair. 1.5 | 28 | | Ultra Silvam The Spearwound Salvation
from zaruyache
VERDICT: I feel very similarly about this as I do for Warmoon Lord. Whereas that album featured a more melodic approach, this one gets a bit dirtier in its production quality and amps up the speed. At less than 30 minutes, it's over with fast, though that time span is spent delivering crushing riffs every second. Hard to say anything else except it feels much more black metal-y than other records and does the sound better. I dunno man, riffs! 4.0 | 29 | | Arch/Matheos Winter Ethereal
from kalkwiese | 30 | | Jordan Rudess Wired for Madness
from kalk
VERDICT: Din't find this nearly as offensive as others have, but it is certainly deserving of criticism. There is such an abundance of aimless wanderings on here that it's hard to figure out if any track on the album means anything or has any sort of instruction from its creator. Some moments were enjoyable, but they are simply not good enough to warrant a arduous voyage through an hour of prog metal's equivalent to a bog. The more I think about it, the more I feel like my time was honestly wasted, and perhaps a 2.5 gives it too much credit. 2.0 | 31 | | Periphery Periphery IV: Hail Stan
from kalk
VERDICT: I was never a fan of Periphery, but it had been so long since I listened to them that I honestly forgot what they sounded like. Despite that detachment and coming into what is apparently their most critically-acclaimed album (at least on this site) with a blank slate, I ended up being thoroughly bored. It was standard djent fare mixed in with some 'progressive' elements so that it can sound like it's grander than what it actually is. Just chug-and-chug-and-chug. Admittedly, that approach amounted to some sufficiently heavy and catchy portions, though their power is nowhere near great enough to surmount the mountain of uninspired sections. A textbook average album, if not worse--but I don't care enough to revisit and find out. 2.5 | 32 | | elend (IL) elend.
from brainmelter | |
MarsKid
07.30.19 | Hit me up Sput | Scheumke
07.30.19 | Got three completely different ones for you:
- Saor - Forgotten Paths
- De Staat - Bubblegum
- Heilung - Futha | JohnnyoftheWell
07.30.19 | Otori - Digitalized Human Nature
100 gecs - 1000 gecs
Dots (.........) - Points
many twists many funs | MarsKid
07.30.19 | Ah fuck, the meme album. I've been played. | JohnnyoftheWell
07.30.19 | Hehe meme album bangs damn hard, you won't be disappointed ;] | Gnocchi
07.30.19 | Going to do it:
Wounds of Reflection - You Were a Garden of Empyrean Light
Clouds Collide -They don't sleep anymore
Orphalis - The Approaching Darkness
| MarsKid
07.30.19 | Keep 'em coming boys. | Papa Universe
07.30.19 | Tactical dot deployed:
• | MarsKid
07.30.19 | The Papa is in position | garas
07.30.19 | I have just 2 recs:
- Gaahls Wyrd - Ghosts Invited
- The new Mayhem album coming this October. (title is yet unknown) | Hawks
07.30.19 | Illyria - The Carpathian Summit
Warmoon Lord - Burning Banners of the Funereal War
Murg - Stravan | MarsKid
07.30.19 | Updated | SlothcoreSam
07.30.19 | OK then I'm going to go with one up and coming release and 2 past releases.
Off With Their Heads- Be Good. Out 16th August.
We Never Learned To Live- The Sleepwalk Transmissions
Yugen Blakrok- Anima Mysterium | Uzumaki
07.30.19 | I totally second Johnny’s rec of Dots. That was a really good album.
Two People - First Body (let’s see if you can up your rating a wee bit)
Tricot - Repeat
Jay Som - Anak Ko (Aug. 23) | MarsKid
07.30.19 | On mobile, so updating sloooowly | Papa Universe
07.30.19 | Remete (AUS) - Into Endless Night
Pedigree - New Freak
Fontaines D.C. - Dogrel | ItsTheSquirrel
07.30.19 | Swans is dropping a new one this year, check that out when it releases | MarsKid
07.31.19 | Will update when not on mobile... too tedious otherwise. Keep the recs flowing though | MarsKid
07.31.19 | Alright, everything is set for now. I'm seeing some captivating choices for sure | MarsKid
08.02.19 | Started listening today, will be updating with thoughts. | Gnocchi
08.02.19 | Fair edification on 11 | Trifolium
08.02.19 | This is one of my absolute faves from this year:
Slumberland - Sea Sea Sea Drifter See See See Drifter
| zaruyache
08.03.19 | Ultra Silvam - The Spearwound Salvation | zaruyache
08.03.19 | also posted my list if ya wanna cheq for tons of crappy bm recs | zaruyache
08.04.19 | also also 9 rules holy hell | MarsKid
08.05.19 | Making edits now to add the new stuff. Also did some listening, so new thoughts have been added. | Hawks
08.05.19 | Glad you dug Murg bro. m/ | MarsKid
08.05.19 | Looking forward to that Illyria album, just didn't have enough time this morning to carve out a good listening session for it. Was over an hour long I think which tells me I need to be ready to soak up the details. | Hawks
08.05.19 | Yeah it’s like 75 minutes but it’s sooooo gooood. | garas
08.06.19 | Ah, I hoped you'd like Ghosts Invited more than a 3.0, but it's okay. I really loved it, it is very relaxing yet exciting album to me, especially the SaruGhaal vocals, haha. | kalkwiese
08.06.19 | Okay, I'll add something as well. I want to see whether you like them or not, the result itself isn't that important for me though. This is stuff I like from this year:
Arch/Matheos - Winter Ethereal
Jordan Rudess - Wired For Madness
Periphery - Periphery IV: Hail Stan | MarsKid
08.06.19 | A Periphery rec? Brave fellow, you are... | kalkwiese
08.06.19 | Well, it's their best album imo, so it's worth a rec I guess. ^^ There is a fair chance you won't like any of these though | MarsKid
08.06.19 | Well hey, I keep an open mind, I am definitely down for a surprise or two! | Uzumaki
08.06.19 | Well, I can respect how Two People panned out for you, and I’m happy you gave it another shot. I had to laugh though at your write up for 1000 Gecs. | MarsKid
08.06.19 | Yeah, I just think out of the options it could have committed to, it chose arguably the worst direction.
And my suffering on that Gecs record was immediate. | MarsKid
08.08.19 | Got in a bunch of listening as of late, lotta updates. | Demon of the Fall
08.08.19 | Strangely I'm now intrigued by De Staat AND Gecs, needless to say but the latter is more curiosity than anything (based on the above).
Damn you were harsh on Slumberland, I don't love it myself but that was brutal. | MarsKid
08.08.19 | Drone is just an aspect to music I can rarely tolerate, and that's all that album really amounted to when I listened to it. I repeated it a fair bit and ended up coming empty each time. Each song starts off with something potentially compelling then never does anything with it.
Repetition can be used well in music so long as it leads to something, be it an increase in intensity or the gradual implementation of other elements. When all it does is just follow a straight line with no end in sight? That's poor structuring and there's nothing to gain from a listening experience like that. | Demon of the Fall
08.08.19 | I tend to agree with you, although it's rather 'musical' for something droning, even if the style is usually irksome. It is a tad repetitive and a few of the ideas could've done with being fleshed out a little. I've slapped a placeholder 3/5 on it for now - may change later, it's certainly not blowing me away, I was just surprised by the rather extreme evaluation. | MarsKid
08.08.19 | Extreme to some I guess. For me it was a logical conclusion. | Demon of the Fall
08.08.19 | This is what happens when you speak too soon, it's getting worse by the minute (on my 3rd spin and it appears less interesting now)... | kalkwiese
08.08.19 | Well, I'm fine with you not liking the new Periphery. I just wanted you to try it out :) Let's hope the other stuff works better for you | MarsKid
08.08.19 | Yeah, they're simply not my style. Seeing that 16-minute song at the start nearly gave me a heart attack. | kalkwiese
08.08.19 | That's their best song though imo hahaha | MarsKid
08.08.19 | It lasted far too long when it could have been much shorter. It started off strong but then became nothing but basic chugging/djent riffs to various choruses that never really stood out from any others featured on the track. Seemed to me like they didn't have much else to say after the third or fourth minute mark. | Hawks
08.08.19 | Mars bro your ratings/opinions for my recs make me very happy. :] | MarsKid
08.08.19 | Your recs have kicked ass my man, definitely been enjoying the content. I'm gonna have to keep an eye on Illyria for the future. As much as I enjoyed them, they've got a long way before they can really unlock their potential. | Hawks
08.08.19 | Completely agreed with that. m/ | Trifolium
08.08.19 | :-((((((((((
It's my fave of the year thus far, approaching a 4.5 | MarsKid
08.08.19 | Sorry my man, wish I could have enjoyed it. It just didn't do anything for me. | Trifolium
08.08.19 | Haha, no prob. I'll enjoy it together with Papa U, that's enough for me < 3 | DungeonBoy
08.08.19 | that Jordan Rudess cover is hilariously awful and awesome | MarsKid
08.13.19 | Put in more listening time. Almost all done with the list except for upcoming albums, which I obviously cannot will into existence ahead of their release date.
... or can I? | brainmelter
08.13.19 | There are heaps of solid releases with no ratings from this year, especially bm
think you’ll dig this: elend (il) - elend. | MarsKid
08.14.19 | Will give it a go fo sho | MarsKid
08.19.19 | Minor edit, listened to Off With Their Heads today. | Demon of the Fall
08.20.19 | I'm struggling to think of anything you may not have heard, if you still want recs then perhaps the 'Malfet' release? It's dungeon synth.
I should probably check that 'Remete' album, despite your lukewarm verdict it sounds like something I may find interesting. | nightbringer
08.20.19 | I'd rec:
Conjurer & Pijn - Curse These Metal Hands | Demon of the Fall
08.20.19 | Thanks for reminding me that exists, need to check. | nightbringer
08.20.19 | The opener is one of the best songs I've heard this year. | MarsKid
08.20.19 | I actually just added that to my own personal list, but I'll put it on here so that I am doubly aware I need to check it. Appreciated | Demon of the Fall
08.20.19 | Conjurer are a really good band, never heard of Pijn, but I'm intrigued nonetheless. Is it a colab on every track (looks most likely), or a split? I'll check... | MarsKid
08.25.19 | Another small edit. Jay Som today | JohnnyoftheWell
08.25.19 | Lollll Gec love
Think there's a drive link to that Otori album in the review comments | MarsKid
08.25.19 | Checked it but it had expired or had been deleted | JohnnyoftheWell
08.25.19 | Oh snap, give this a crack: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1DrO1V0lDrc7e25aDnl_Q9cAp41Og7zrG | Uzumaki
08.25.19 | Love her voice, love her flow. Glad you enjoyed it! | MarsKid
08.25.19 | Was a good time for sure, thanks for the rec |
|