ArsMoriendi
12.08.14 | If you guys could add some reasonable additions to the tagging system, what would they be? |
laughingman22
12.08.14 | glam |
Pheromone
12.08.14 | New Wave |
Artuma
12.08.14 | damn arse some of these suggestions are actually good. honestly the lack of screamo tag is just dumb |
Gameofmetal
12.08.14 | we need a deathcore tag hard |
ArsMoriendi
12.08.14 | @Phero: Agreed hard on that one.
@Art: Thank you.
|
treeqt.
12.08.14 | if you wanna add baroque and romantic might as well add them all |
ArsMoriendi
12.08.14 | @treeqt: I actually agree on adding them all, I just went with 2 of the most well known ones to generalize. |
TheGreatQ
12.08.14 | we need a deathcore tag hard [2] |
Asdfp277
12.08.14 | electropop or synthpop or something, so people will stop tagging every with "electronic" |
thacoconut94
12.08.14 | Deathcore needs added so fucking whitechapel and suicide silence can stop getting labeled metalcore or death metal |
RonnieRadke
12.08.14 | cant wait for these genres when the site is updated in 2025[2] |
Gameofmetal
12.08.14 | yeah so why is the owner never around anyway?
that's the mods excuse for everything they can't do
"the owner can fix it whenever he turns back up again", I might just not have been around long enough to understand that, idk |
Ryus
12.08.14 | deathcore [2] yeah because a lot of bullshit is labelled death metael |
Artuma
12.08.14 | deathcore wasn't even invented when mx last visited the site |
InFlamesWeThrash666
12.08.14 | DJENT |
Gameofmetal
12.08.14 | don't even start there lol |
Asdfp277
12.08.14 | please add the djen djuntin |
deathschool
12.08.14 | Funk Metal, Ska Punk, Blackgaze, Grindcore, and similar things
I know a lot of these are just two genres that melded together, but a lot of them reach a point where labeling them as one of their base genres is really misleading. |
Ryus
12.08.14 | "deathcore wasn't even invented when mx last visited the site"
lol
|
Artuma
12.08.14 | @deathschool umm, grindcore? |
Ryus
12.08.14 | what the fuck is with tags like "other" and "all genres" occupying people's pie charts though |
Cygnatti
12.08.14 | New wave over disco tbh. Electropop would be rly rly nice. |
deathschool
12.08.14 | Idk. Maybe not Grindcore. I kind of just threw that one on at the end. |
Cygnatti
12.08.14 | Ryus, is this your first account? |
Slut
12.08.14 | Scrramo agreed |
Ryus
12.08.14 | @cyg nope |
Slut
12.08.14 | What was your first acc |
Ryus
12.08.14 | idk |
Ryus
12.08.14 | nobody you'd have heard of tbh |
Slut
12.08.14 | I'll tell you mine if you tell me yours ; ) |
Cygnatti
12.08.14 | Bc if it was then you'd be to young (new) to understand the meaning of 'other' and 'all genres'. |
Ryus
12.08.14 | @Slut enticing offer but ;) no thanks
@cyg huh what is the purpose of them though, what music falls under those categories |
Cygnatti
12.08.14 | Those two genres are relics of an earlier time in Sputnik. They are no longer relevant. However, they are still stored in Sputnik's database, and can only be seen when viewing the outdated pie chart on a user's ratings. |
YakNips
12.08.14 | would be a miracle if they updated anything |
deathschool
12.08.14 | It's funny how there are actually more users now, but less ability to change the site |
ChoccyPhilly
12.08.14 | hmm, I kind of agree with you there.
need 'Latin' |
Cygnatti
12.08.14 | We need alternative r&b tbh. |
demigod!
12.08.14 | POWERVIOLENCE |
Artuma
12.08.14 | crust punk tbh |
Ryus
12.08.14 | doo wop hard |
thacoconut94
12.08.14 | True Jedi spacesynth naboocore |
RonnieRadke
12.08.14 | yeah we need something for falling in reverse too like show some recognition for my band smdh
something like progressive melodic death metal junz skramz electropop dubstep political rap. |
Cygnatti
12.08.14 | Name 5 doo wop bands than have ever been relevant pls. |
Pheromone
12.08.14 |
There is more than one music group named The Wrens: a New Jersey indie rock band, and a 1950s doo-wop band from Brooklyn. |
ParanoidAndroid96
12.08.14 | In terms of rap, I would like to see tags/genres like jazz rap, trap rap, noise rap, and alternative rap (as suggested in the list) |
Cygnatti
12.08.14 | Less essential fantasy genre tbh |
RonnieRadke
12.08.14 | 'I say alternative hip hop specifically because despite having the world "alternative" in it.
I'd live in alternative world tbh |
Ryus
12.08.14 | @cyg the five satins
frankie lymon and the teenagers
the drifters
the platters
the flamingos |
Pheromone
12.08.14 | Chamber Pop
Neo-Psychedelia
and Art Rock for the times everyone wants to be a bit wanky |
Cygnatti
12.08.14 | Fine.
Also, don't we have a bluegrass tag, and if so, why does no one listen to it? |
Cygnatti
12.08.14 | I def would like art pop and art rock tags. But then I'm the guy who thinks that pink Floyd is barely prog so idk. |
deathschool
12.08.14 | I listen to Trampled By Turtles. They're Bluegrass. |
Cygnatti
12.08.14 | Make a bluegrass list! :D |
eddie95
12.08.14 | Proto-punk, New Wave, Celtic Punk are also needed |
Greyvy
12.08.14 | can we have a lolicore tag? |
Ryus
12.08.14 | oh how did i forget. VAPORWAVE! |
Angelboros
12.08.14 | The only two coming to mind at the moment are mathcore and comedy rock. I would've mentioned avant-garde, but since I figure that's fairly synonymous with experimental, there ain't any point. |
Jasdevi087
12.08.14 | VAPORWAVE! [234223] |
treeqt.
12.08.14 | this kinda list always functions excellently as bait for clueless idiots |
SharkTooth
12.08.14 | Garage rock |
ArsMoriendi
12.08.14 | "I def would like art pop and art rock tags"
I hate using the word "art" to describe a genre. All music is art, so by calling something "art rock" you're basically implying other rock genres are less artistic.
@treeqt: Oh, you think so? ;)
|
treeqt.
12.08.14 | the thread thinks so |
Mort.
12.08.14 | "All music is art, so by calling something "art rock" you're basically implying other rock genres are less artistic."
good lord no
|
RonnieRadke
12.08.14 | "I'm shitposting"
"Is it blissful?"
"It's like a meme"
"I want to meme" |
Avagantamos
12.09.14 | vaporwave
crust punk
musique concrete/sound collage |
Funeralopolis
12.09.14 | technical death metal, screamo and deathcore are sorely missing
|
Asdfp277
12.09.14 | choccyphilly: "need 'Latin'" -and what would that mean tho? what artists would you tag as 'latin', and why? serious question, because latin used to be a genre here in sputnik, didn't it? |
Deviant.
12.09.14 | Perhaps this list would be the perfect place to inform all the twits tagging every 70s rock act as "garage" to stop. If that was the appropriate tag it would have been called "garage rock"
"In terms of rap, I would like to see tags/genres like jazz rap, trap rap, noise rap, and alternative rap (as suggested in the list) "
Good god no |
ChoccyPhilly
12.09.14 | @Asdfp277 Cos how else do you describe stuff like this? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nb1VOQRs-Vs
I know it's not a big genre here on sputnik, but I don't see why it couldn't be here |
Asdfp277
12.09.14 | choccyphilly: "Cos how else do you describe stuff like this?"
- probably just pop rock, or bachata or balada or something. so, i guess i see it, it would be used for genres born in latin america, right? |
Supercoolguy64
12.09.14 | agreed on 7 |
Asdfp277
12.09.14 | it feels a little too broad tho, and a metric fuckton of artists have 'latin' influences, i think it could be misused too much. also i think there'd be a trend of tagging latin american artists as 'latin' even when no 'latin' influences are present
but yeah, diego torres |
ChoccyPhilly
12.09.14 | yeah, kind of. Rather than having stuff like "bachata" or "balada", which I'm totally unfamiliar with, you could just have "latin" as that kind of umbrella term. I also think that's more reasonable than adding the other genres lol |
TwigTW
12.09.14 | world music (which is vague but better than nothing), glam, and new wave |
climactic
12.09.14 | no to almost everything suggested in list and comments |
ArsMoriendi
12.09.14 | "no to almost everything suggested in list and comments"
Which ones do you say yes to then? |
demigod!
12.09.14 | powerviolence |
RVAHC13
12.09.14 | Funk Rock
Techno
New Wave
Synthpunk
Alternative Metal
Glam
Rap Metal
Jazz Rock
Art Rock
Groove Metal
Crossover Thrash
Powerviolence [623424]
Vaporwave/Chillwave [2390482]
Breakbeat
Acid House
Krishnacore [lol]
Southern Metal
Rockabilly
|
deathschool
12.09.14 | Surf rock needs to be one too. |
ArsMoriendi
12.09.14 | @RVAHC: a lot of those are way too specific, especially southern metal. Also, techno is already a tag, but good effort.
|
ChoccyPhilly
12.09.14 | What even is 'alternative metal'? |
fallenbird
12.09.14 | Don't forget polka |
RVAHC13
12.09.14 | oops ¯_(ツ)_/¯ |
betray
12.09.14 | we need a deathcore tag hard [5]
'meme' would also be a good tag |
RonnieRadke
12.09.14 | "What even is 'alternative metal'?"
Disturbed
|
ArsMoriendi
05.20.15 | The list about "stupid genre" tags reminded me of this list. :P |
Supercoolguy64
05.20.15 | we really do need 'noise' and 'screamo' tags |
Jasdevi087
05.20.15 | Noise definitely needs a tag because Torturing Nurse definitely aren't noise "rock". |
SharkTooth
05.20.15 | we need a garage rock tag |
Snowdog808
07.10.15 | Why we only have one classical tag and two jazz tags by now is honestly beyond me. |
Cyberduck
07.10.15 | Dub is one of the most obvious genres not included here, despite being established for decades.
Big Beat would make sense too, given the big scene in the 1990's, as well as Synthpop to avoid confusins with Industrial or "Electronic". |
ArsMoriendi
09.09.15 | Bump lol |
MyNameIsPencil
09.09.15 | We need more hip-hop tags [∞] |
ArsMoriendi
09.09.15 | Seriously, Rock n' roll should be a tag too. I mean if we're going to give metal like 20 different tags can the original rock wave be defined by at least 1? |
LotusFlower
09.09.15 | Mongolian Throat Singing |
SharkTooth
09.09.15 | Garage rock needs to be a genre tag, I mean just look at Deviant's comment |
ArsMoriendi
09.09.15 | Yeah, but if we made garage rock a thing, we'd probably have to make college rock a thing and I always thought that term was dumb. |
SharkTooth
09.09.15 | Also trap music since its one of the most popular genres in mainstream music |
MyNameIsPencil
09.09.15 | Mongolian Throat Singing [2]
Garage Rock [69]
Is Math Rock a tag?
|
ArsMoriendi
09.09.15 | Yeah math rock is a tag.
AND YEAH WTF TRAP ISN'T A TAG ON HERE? weird.... |
SharkTooth
09.09.15 | College rock is nowhere near as well known or popular as garage rock so there's no need for that tag anyhow |
ArsMoriendi
09.09.15 | Good because college rock is a shitty term. In that case I'm all for garage rock. |
Ashen
09.09.15 | avant-garde maybe. |
Cygnatti
09.09.15 | No college rock
And more hip hop genres outside of instrumental hip hop and "alt hip hop" are superfluous tbh. |
Cygnatti
09.09.15 | Replace nu metal with alt metal |
Ashen
09.09.15 | "more hip hop genres outside of instrumental hip hop and "alt hip hop" are superfluous tbh"
agreed. there are other things that need to be addressed instead of adding pointless microgenres. |
SharkTooth
09.09.15 | "avant-garde maybe"
Maybe, the "experimental" tag is way too broad to cover avant-garde acts
But at the same time the are much more important tags needed as of right now |
parksungjoon
05.21.22 | agree |
JohnnyoftheWell
05.21.22 | reconstruct my club |
GhandhiLion
05.21.22 | I use to listen to 8 like every week |