Reviews 1
Approval 87%

Soundoffs 50
Album Ratings 1429
Objectivity 62%

Last Active 10-10-14 12:40 pm
Joined 04-13-14

Forum Posts 1
Review Comments 9,403

musical taste

Currently Digging:
John K. Samson
The Twilight Sad
Blood Cultures

favorite bands

shoutbox » all posts 
  • DoofDoof Knock Knock is just nicely self contained and tells a story(ish) - River Guard is one of his absolute best, and people say Sweet Treat (really sad song about adultery) is the weakest on it - that is a 5 out of 5 tune! The new one I also really like Hulk and Tugboats - add those to the two you mentioned and those are my early top 4.
    June 15 08:26 AM
  • DoofDoof If you did a top 10 of the best songs on the new one that would be unbelievably tight - but I like the thematic shifts and call backs across 20 songs. Also having recently got married, watching loved ones get older and all that, it is def the album thats spoken to me the most in a while. I listened to Knock Knock last night and upped that to my first Callahan 5 so lets say I will be amazed if this doesnt get a 5 from me at the end of the year, I might rate it higher than Benji too, another 5
    June 15 08:02 AM
  • DoofDoof I think the new one is top, but I am a sucker for double albums. I would go Shepherds, Knock Knock, Eagle, Red Apple, Dream River for a top 5.
    June 15 07:57 AM
  • zakalwe I?m still sticking with Hello Sunshine but the album is incredibly strong and yeah Stones is up there. Amazing stuff.
    June 15 07:55 AM
  • DoofDoof I rated Dream River and Eagle both 4.5s so unless something went wrong it was probably going to pick up a high rating. What is your favourite Callahan/Smog?
    June 14 03:46 AM

You have to be logged in to post a comment Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy