Neutral Milk Hotel
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea



by Green Baron USER (159 Reviews)
December 15th, 2013 | 108 replies

Release Date: 1998 | Tracklist

Review Summary: She will live forever, all goes on and on and on

Turning Back the Clock: 15 Years Back

The initial mixed reactions to In the Aeroplane Over the Sea is one of music’s greatest unsolved mysteries. Back in the good ol' 1990s, negative reviews for this album were everywhere. How could critics trash such a masterpiece with words like “thin-blooded, woolgathering fluff”" Neutral Milk Hotel’s entire legacy is based on this one classic record, but reviewers had the audacity to vilify it as the work of a mental crackpot. None of this made any sense.

But as I think more and more about it, all of this becomes clear to me now. Taken at face value, there’s a lot to hate about this record. Nasally vocals and simple acoustic strumming would hardly make a good album, much less one of the greatest albums of all time. Yet In the Aeroplane in the Sea is so flawless in its execution; from every Anne Frank reference that comes out of Jeff Mangum’s throat to his exemplary guitarwork, everything flows perfectly into each other. Whether it’s the contrasting emotion between the three-part “The King of Carrot Flowers” or the heartfelt and tear-jerking closer “Two Headed Boy, Part 2”, Mangum turns his simple little acoustic guitar into a tool of catharsis and sentiment. And for that, In the Aeroplane Over the Sea deserves its place in music history as a classic album.

15 Years Since

What impact did this album have when it first came out"
In the days following In the Aeroplane Over the Sea’s release, critical response was mostly mixed. Some reviewers felt that it was filled with emotion and dark imagery, while others thrashed Mangum’s whiny vocals and basic instrumentation. An equal amount of critics also thought that the record had its highlights, but was too eccentric to overcome its weaknesses.

Yet now, fifteen years after it came out, In the Aeroplane Over the Sea is lauded and acclaimed for its lyrical genius, captivating melodies and the sheer amount of emotion in Mangum’s nasally voice. All of the praise that this album gets is justified; it truly is a magnificent record.

What role does this album play in the band’s discography"
Neutral Milk Hotel truly had a short career; they released two studio albums over a span of three years and promptly broke up afterwards. The band’s first record, On Avery Island, isn’t a bad one by any means, but compared to Aeroplane, it’s leagues behind. This was the band’s final album (they split following its mixed reception), and they certainly went out with a bang. Rarely can a band get everything right on its last record, but they were able to exit with their legacy defined by this album.

When people think of Neutral Milk Hotel, their thoughts immediately flow to In the Aeroplane Over the Sea. Forget about On Avery Island, that isn’t what this band is known for. This is their signature album, and will always remain that throughout time. I'd rather these guys never make another album again than to have them tarnish their legacy with a mediocre record. Their chances of topping In the Aeroplane Over the Sea with something bigger and better is around 0.0000000000000001%. This album is what made this band known; it introduced their name to legions of fans, eager to listen to one of the best records of all time.

How does the album live up fifteen years later"
It’s been fifteen years since In the Aeroplane Over the Sea, and yet it still manages to sound fresh with every listen. Every time I take this out for a spin, it struggles to show its age. This truly is a timeless album; Jeff Mangum’s passion and masterful strumming still sounds current. When he cries out "But now we must pick up every piece of the life we used to love" on "Holland, 1945", I can feel Mangum's connection to the story of Anne Frank's life. The lyricism he uses is so awe-inspiring and glorious that looking up their deeper meanings is inevitable.

One of my favorite closers of all time is here, and no, I'm not talking about Mariano Rivera. "Two-Headed Boy, Part 2" is the epitome of why this album has withstood the test of time. Mangum's melancholy yearning is filled to the brim with pure emotion, and lines like "God is a place where some holy spectacle lies, and when we break we'll wait for our miracle / God is a place you will wait for the rest of your life" choke me up with sadness every time I listen to it.

In 2013, we look at In the Aeroplane Over the Sea as a modern classic, an album that has changed the lives of many due to its magnificent structure and instrumentation. However, it's still important to realize that fifteen years ago, this was not the case. This record, like Pinkerton, is a perfect example of how opinion can change through time. It's the true definition of a cult classic, and it took a while, but it finally got the recognition it deserved. What we call "complete and utter bull***" today may soon be known as the next Sgt. Pepper's. Of course, the chances of that are slim, but hey, if it could happen to this album, who's to say history won't repeat itself"

Recent reviews by this author
Linkin Park One More LightIncubus 8
Highly Suspect The Boy Who Died WolfFrom Ashes To New Day One
Frank Turner Mittens3 Doors Down Us and the Night

user ratings (4305)
other reviews of this album
1 of
  • Knott- EMERITUS (5)
    And your mom would drink until she was no longer speaking, and dad would dream of all the ...

    Med57 EMERITUS (4.5)

    thebhoy EMERITUS (5)
    Some Sort of Time Machine: The Role of Time in a Work of Art, From the View of In the Aero...

    Athom EMERITUS (5)
    How strange it is to be anything at all......

  • BrentV (5)
    A beautiful, near-unparalleled masterpiece that, with a blistering vigilance, operatically...

    comissionerrr (5)
    One day we will die and out ashes will fly from the aeroplane over the sea. But for now we...

    taxidermist (5)
    World War II, Adolf Hitler, the Holocaust, Anne Frank, Neutral Milk Hotel’s magnum opus,...

    Misshaped (5)
    An eccentric but sincere indie rock classic....

  • indiancoffee (5)
    In the Aeroplane Over The Sea is not only a cult classic and an exceptional album, but it ...

    dupuisj8 (5)
    A powerful and human exploration into sound...

    Bsmith7 (5)
    In the Aeroplane Over the Sea is one of the best albums I have heard. It's got a sound of ...

    HolidayKirk (5)
    Ben Thornburgh Presents! College Quizes of the Future....

  • Zebra (2)

    CompostCompote (2.5)
    What happens when white people from Louisiana are allowed to make music: A cautionary tale...

    AndrewKaster (4.5)
    A little too lo-fi for it's own good, but Mangum's baffling mind is completely unfolded he...

    Glokta (5)
    Pardon the errors (I'm drunk) but this album has none....

  • crandynewman (2)
    Be prepared to be blessed with some of the best lyrics ever written, sung by the worst voi...

    madsmoon (5)
    Personal revelations on the greatest album ever....

Comments:Add a Comment 
Green Baron
December 14th 2013


Album Rating: 4.0

One of the most ass-kissing reviews I've ever written

60 down 40 to go

Contributing Reviewer
December 14th 2013


prolly one of the most uninteresting things I've ever heard

Contributing Reviewer
December 14th 2013


Album Rating: 3.5

Interesting review style. Kinda lazy though.

December 14th 2013


dunno why ppl like this so much, album is sooooo boring.. and that singer, is lolbad

Contributing Reviewer
December 14th 2013


Album Rating: 3.5

The lyrics are fucking phenomenal. One hell of a lyricist but other than that, I feel the same way.

December 14th 2013


Not a fan of this album, nice review though

Contributing Reviewer
December 14th 2013


hey you dunno me foo.

December 14th 2013


Album Rating: 4.5


December 14th 2013


Album Rating: 5.0

you are a good reviewer so why do you have to be a shit user?

December 14th 2013


Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

what a controversial opinion!? ?!1

December 14th 2013


"you are a good reviewer so why do you have to be a shit user?"

I want to know this too

December 14th 2013


Album Rating: 4.0

cuz linkin'

Staff Reviewer
December 14th 2013


Review style is not a very good idea. If anything, such delineations should be fairly obvious from the context of the review itself and breaking it down like this insults the intelligence of the reader a bit, I think.

But write what you want and how you like, it's a free country, etc etc.

December 14th 2013


Album Rating: 5.0

i enjoyed reading it. Pos.

December 14th 2013


Yes, this has insulted my intelligence.

December 14th 2013


Album Rating: 5.0


Green Baron
December 14th 2013


Album Rating: 4.0

well someone had to break the monotony ;)

December 14th 2013


Album Rating: 4.0

nah review is great pos'd

December 14th 2013


Album Rating: 4.5

pos for the cool review style. Sputnik tends to not try interesting styles such as this.

December 14th 2013


Album Rating: 3.0

60 reviews holy fuck

Digging: Burger / Ink - Las Vegas

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy