Trebor.
11.16.12 | You know |
Cygnatti
11.16.12 | !!! |
InFiction
11.16.12 | I would pick 2, but 1 is still awesome. |
YoYoMancuso
11.16.12 | Surfer Rosa because of how awesome the production is, it just immerses me in the music more than 1 does. |
MUNGOLOID
11.16.12 | i like 1 more because it felt more evolved and focused than 2 but they're both fantastic albums really. still haven't heard their last two lol. |
Chortles
11.16.12 | surfer rosa |
demigod!
11.16.12 | Doolittle easily. Surfer Rosa kind of falls off around the second half, has a bit of filler.
That said, Where is my Mind is my favourite Pixies song |
Gyromania
11.16.12 | the production on doolittle is obviously better, and it's more of an actual album, whereas surfer rosa has some filler tracks and songs that just seem to fly by. i love both though |
Applebite
11.16.12 | SR is better. |
AliW1993
11.16.12 | Doolittle. Surfa Rosa is great and has some ridiculous songs (Where Is My Mind, Gigantic) but also carries quite a bit of filler. Pretty much every track on Doolittle is amazing in its own unique way. |
Cygnatti
11.16.12 | doolittle is the last name of one of my bros |
chambered49
11.16.12 | doolittle |
Cygnatti
11.16.12 | but yeah doolittle because I've never made it through all of surfer |
Minus.
11.16.12 | Bossanova beats them both |
Cygnatti
11.16.12 | no |
Minus.
11.16.12 | Considering I saw them live back in the 90's and have been listening to them longer than you've probably been alive, my vote is more meaningful than yours, Cyngatti. Besides you admitted you didnt even listen to all of SR so your opinion is void. |
TumsFestival
11.16.12 | Doolittle, by far for me. It was a much more focused and serious album. They had a ton of great ideas on Surfer, but they're more controlled and focused on Doolittle. Plus, Surfer had nothing close to Hey or Monkey Gone To Heaven on it. |