Artuma
07.06.13 | gonna get hate for liking Autotheism |
KILL
07.06.13 | i think ur overrating these :D |
JamieTwort
07.06.13 | Agree with 6. |
menawati
07.06.13 | 7 is overrated on here |
tempest--
07.06.13 | 10 is 2.5
6 and 8 have correct average |
ViperAces
07.06.13 | 4 is correct |
Artuma
07.06.13 | "7 is overrated on here"
lol |
Vespiion
07.06.13 | Agree with 5 so hard. |
KILL
07.06.13 | the incidents a 3 yea |
Artuma
07.06.13 | wouldn't mind about Incident's average otherwise but while FoaBP and IA have 4.2 average that 3.6 is
just ridiculous |
KILL
07.06.13 | theyre both overrated too yea :D |
Artuma
07.06.13 | explains a lot KILL ;) |
Vespiion
07.06.13 | I could never get into PT, and I have no idea why. What's a good starting point? |
KILL
07.06.13 | in absentia |
Artuma
07.06.13 | @Vesp, Lightbulb Sun. it is a superb combination of their old and new style |
Lowder91bird
07.06.13 | I definitely agree that 1, 4, 6 and 8 are all underrated. |
Artuma
07.06.13 | nice to see someone agreeing on so many of these |
Mongi123
07.06.13 | Neon Bible was kinda boring to me. Though they're first album was better so the average seems about right to me. |
Artuma
07.06.13 | i love that band, wasn't too big on Neon Bible at first listen either but it grew on me like hell |
NordicMindset
07.06.13 | Anberlin's New Surrender is a 4.5 to me. |
Mongi123
07.06.13 | Anberlin is so underrated in general I love them |
Artuma
07.06.13 | have only heard Cities by them but it didn't really hit me, nice album nevertheless |
sjp55555
07.06.13 | 3,6,7 & 8 are all def underrated. |
Artuma
07.06.13 | they really are |
Riviere
07.06.13 | 8 should have like a 3.9 or 4.0 average, it's ridic. |
Artuma
07.06.13 | yeah i don't really get the hate for it either |
eleventhsun
07.06.13 | Do you just mean underrated on sputnik? Because plenty of stuff that's rated high on here is unknown by most people I meet. |
Artuma
07.06.13 | well yeah, as you see my comparison is the Sputnik average
oh and forgot to put Division Bell here, that thing is really underrated too |
JamieTwort
07.06.13 | ^The Division Bell is nowhere near as underrated as The Final Cut imo. I'd say Obscured by Clouds is a pretty underrated Floyd album too. |
eleventhsun
07.06.13 | Yes I will have to agree Jamie. The Final Cut is totally underrated. |
Artuma
07.06.13 | i don't really think The Final Cut is underrated but agreed that Obscured is though |
Mongi123
07.06.13 | @Artuma Cities is quite a great album. Reclusion and Godspeed rule |
Artuma
07.06.13 | Godspeed was probably my favorite off of that album. have to listen to it again |
Mongi123
07.06.13 | Do it. Some of their best work. I like all of their albums for the most part though. |
Artuma
07.06.13 | cool |
SeaAnemone
07.06.13 | "Sputnik collectively thinks that this album is great, but my drastically different opinion worth mentioning is that it is in fact excellent!" |
Artuma
07.06.13 | umm it doesn't go straightly like that |
SeaAnemone
07.06.13 | yeah it does, that's 6 of the albums here and then 3 others are "Sputnik... excellent... me... superb!" |
Artuma
07.06.13 | these are also very much in comparison to the bands' other albums. for example Era Vulgaris has by far the lowest QotSA rating which i don't get at all |
Artuma
07.06.13 | also those "4.5 = superb" things don't always go like that, at least to me a 2.5 average rating
doesn't imply that the album is average but that the album is generally very criticized |
Veldin
07.06.13 | I absolutely agree with Neon Bible. The level of depth to the grand sound is remarkable, and in my opinion, far superior to that of Funeral. Plus, the lyrics are phenomenal. The "drop" in My Body is a Cage gets me every time. |
Veldin
07.06.13 | Sputnik rating averages that irk me are Bright Eye's "The People's Key" (Sput: 3.3, Me: 4.5) and Of Montreal's "Paralytic Stalk" (Sput: 3.5, Me: 4.5). |
Artuma
07.06.13 | yeah, Neon Bible's sound is far more ambitious than Funeral's one. i still love Funeral more but i think it's ridiculous how much Neon Bible is in the shadow of that album. gotta say i'm not a big fan of My Body Is a Cage tbh, that "drop" is amazing though |
Artuma
07.06.13 | "Bright Eye's "The People's Key" (Sput: 3.3, Me: 4.5)"
wouldn't rate it that high but agreed that it's stupidly underrated too |
Artuma
07.06.13 | yeah most people who comment here seem to loathe 10, i personally really like it |
Artuma
07.06.13 | they are totally different, as Autotheism is more like progressive metal while the older albums are
pretty much purely technical death metal. you would probably like them a lot, especially Akeldama
(easily my favorite by the band) |
facupm
07.06.13 | virtual XI |
Trebor.
07.06.13 | "Sputnik collectively thinks that this album is great, but my drastically different opinion worth mentioning is that it is in fact excellent!"
lol |
Cygnatti
07.06.13 | don't really like any of these |
Trebor.
07.06.13 | Good News is great but come on do you even jam classic MM? |
Artuma
07.06.13 | i have TM&A at a 5 |
NeroCorleone80
07.08.13 | Agree hard with 4 and 6. 7 is rated ok imo |
ButteryBiscuitBass
07.08.13 | 6 and 8 agreed |
OmairSh
07.12.13 | 9 :-) |
DikkoZinner
07.12.13 | Incantation - Diabolical Conquest |
StallionMang
07.12.13 | 3, 5, and 8 |
Keyblade
07.12.13 | say word Lunar Strain's average was 3.4 o.O |
Havey
07.12.13 | wrod |
evilford
07.12.13 | symbolic |
EaglesBecomeVultures
07.12.13 | 8 sucks bro |
NapalmCrusader
07.12.13 | 8 is ok, but is the least interesting album of Josh and Co |
EaglesBecomeVultures
07.12.13 | user artuma is so try-hard |
StallionMang
07.12.13 | 8 is definitely their worst, and it's still a 3.5-4. Should tell you a lot about how good this band is. |
evilford
07.12.13 | ^^^ yeah low to moderate 3.5 but agreed |