Jethro42
05.17.22 | Congrats to Zig, the CHAMPION! It's well deserved. You were surrounded by lots of solid competitors, and you found your way through!
As I said, I digged Frogg Cafe, Novela, All Traps on Earth... I like all of the albums, which I gave a 4 almost everywhere. Apofenia might be my fave. |
TheIntruder
05.17.22 | Like I already said in my comment in the Finals, my favourite albums are: Movin' On, Memento Z Banalnym Tryptykiem, Apofenia, Visitation, A Drop Of Light, Barbaro, Melody Of A Muddled Mason and Bateless Edge.
This was a great tourney with so many great albums. It was a pity that I had not much time to can participate with an album and in all the votations. Maybe next year I can do so.
Congrats to all participants especially to Zig. A great thanks to Jethro that was a great new host like Friday was. |
Jethro42
05.17.22 | You're always welcome, Intruder. You helped us more than once to break the tie, and it's not an easy task. Thank you for your kind words. I created the tourney according to Friday's model, so all credit goes to him.
You're pretty much like me; You dig most of the albums. I'll most likely buy Frogg Cafe and couple others, such as Il Giardino Onirico (if I manage to find it) and All Traps on Earth. It had grown on me big time! |
SharkTooth
05.17.22 | Reminder to check out SBB's other records please
also winner is well deserved, though I do wonder if Frogg Cafe would've been the winner had it been the one to move onward |
MrSirLordGentleman
05.17.22 | One day I'll get my third win lol. Congrats Zig! I've been jamming Visitation a lot since I first listened to it, fantastic stuff!
"Reminder to check out SBB's other records please"
I downloaded two other albums by them besides the one in the contest. Great band |
someone
05.17.22 | so a good amount of sputnikers agreed that this album fucks? then so be it, i will listen to it |
Mythodea
05.17.22 | Woah, yet another plot twist in the most plot twisted tournament I have witnessed. What did Diva's curse have to do with it, I wonder.
Congrats Zig
Congrats |
Jethro42
05.17.22 | @Shark; Among the ones that haven't passed the first round, the big threats were Frogg Cafe, Supersister and All Traps on Earth. Slapp Happy was also a good avant prog pop album.
I for one will listen to other SBB's albums, that's for sure. |
Jethro42
05.17.22 | Lol, Diva's curse touched the whole tournament, which is a charm. That was a tournament with lots of reversal, lots of tiebreaking and pressure. I really liked Axis, Myth. A good road music, really. |
Jethro42
05.17.22 | @SirLord, you're close to win all the time. Patience, patience... |
zakalwe
05.17.22 | 2 is 1
Thanks Jethro for putting it all together and everyone for putting in some proper decent albums |
Jethro42
05.17.22 | It's a pleasure, zak. What makes it possible is also the participation of y'all. |
Friday13th
05.17.22 | Great job leading the tourney, Jethro. It was another great one and an unusually high level of quality among the contestants. |
Jethro42
05.17.22 | Thanks Friday. You're obviously the spirit and the inspiration behind the tournament. It's a lot of fun, and the participating was to the max. Thank you to be there, Friday. The Mercury Tree will be remembered and revisited in the future, among other nominees, oc. |
Mythodea
05.17.22 | >I really liked Axis, Myth. A good road music, really.
thanks @Jethro. Truth is I don't put too much thought as to which album to suggest, so I'm glad that this time it seemed to resonate more than other times |
Friday13th
05.17.22 | @Jethro Cheers and you're welcome! The Apofenia album really has all the trappings of a good modern prog album. Definitely a keeper! As were most of these. |
Jethro42
05.17.22 | @Myth;
Sometimes one just needs a good amount of catchiness to make a difference, while other albums don't offer enough and pass under the radar because of that. Your entry is basically jazzy throughout and well balanced, interspersed with clever prog arrangements and earworms as bonuses. It's one of the tournament's strenght for me, that's for sure. |
Jethro42
05.17.22 | @Friday, I'm a fan of modern(Italian above all) prog. The more I listen to Apofenia, the more I need to revisit. I'm never tired of that kind of symphonic prog. I'm glad you dig. Cheers! |
bnelso55
05.17.22 | Really enjoyed this. Hours of good listening and so many great takeaways. Thanks for organizing, Jethro! |
Jethro42
05.17.22 | You're welcome, bnelso, bro. It's a shared pleasure. Thanks to be there. Glad you enjoyed! |
porcupinetheater
05.18.22 | Fun as ever, Lads, see you next year. What a Circus at the end there with Pecker Porridge |
Jethro42
05.18.22 | Welcome to Pecker Porridge Circus, Lol
Man, if you didn't exist, you would have to be created. Cheers! |
porcupinetheater
05.18.22 | Cheers love, thank you so much for all your wrangling this tourney, Jeth, keeping all us late voters on the leash. You nailed it, amore |
Jethro42
05.18.22 | Reminders-s-s-s hahah |
Donchivo
05.18.22 | Big shoutout to Jethro! Great, great facitlitation of this very fun tourney.
And I agree with the level overall being very high. I already acquired three of the albums here physically! |
bgillesp
05.18.22 | Congrats Zig! Here is my final ranking:
1. Slapp Happy- Casablanca Moon 4.4 (round 8)
2. Il Giardino Onirico- Apofenia 4.4 (round 6)
3. Maquina!- Why? 4.25 (round 9)
4. Frogg Cafe- Bateless Edge 4.2 (round 1)
5. Mezquita- Recuerdos De Mi Tierra 4.15 (round 3)
6. SBB- Memento Z Banalnym Tryptykiem 4.15 (round 3)
7. Present- Barbaro 4.1 (round 10)
8. Steel Mill- Green Eyed God 4.1 (round 10)
9. Flaming Row- Mirage A Portrayal of Figures 4.1 (round 6)
10. All Traps on Earth- A Drop of Light 4.05 (round 7)
11. Pekka Pohjola- Visitation 4.05 (round 1)
12. Jono El Grande- Melody of a Muddled Mason 4.05 (round 8)
13. Novela- Sanctuary 4.0 (round 2)
14. Axis- Axis 4.0 (round 5)
15. Polis- Weltklang 3.95 (round 9)
16. The Mercury Tree- Spidermilk 3.9 (round 7)
17. Sisare- Leaving the Land 3.9 (round 2)
18. Circus- Movin’ On 3.8 (round 4)
19. Supersister- To the Highest Bidder 3.7 (round 4)
20. Brand X- Product 3.6 (round 5) |
bgillesp
05.18.22 | Given more time, Frogg Cafe could move into 3rd |
Donchivo
05.18.22 | My ranking would be the following:
1. Circus
2. Mezquita
3. Steel Mill
4. Axis
5. Maquina!
6. Present
7. The Mercury Tree
8. Novela
9. All Traps On Earth
10. Jono El Grande
11. Supersister
12. Slapp Happy
13. Frogg Café
14. Polis
15. Flaming Row
16. Il Giardino Onirico
17. Sisare
18. SBB
19. Pekka Pohjola
20. Brand X
|
Donchivo
05.18.22 | haha as you can see, I had a very clear favorite from the semis onwards! |
SharkTooth
05.18.22 | I like how the final round was between your second least favorite and your absolute favorite
Idk how to rank these albums just yet personally, but I would prob put Apofenia at the top |
e210013
05.18.22 | As I already mentioned my fave albums of the tournament, the albums that belong to my first prog league, are A Drop Of Light, Apofenia, Barbaro, Melody Of A Muddled Mason and Visitation. Movin' On, Bateless Edge, Memento Z Banalnym Tryptykiem, Leaving The Land and especially Green Eyed God, an allbum that never cessed to grown up with my listenings, belong to my second prog league.
Of the albums of my first league, besides mine, Apofenia is, to me, the confirmation album of the tournament. I had already read many great things about the album and the band, but I never had the opportunity to check the album before. The other three albums represent to me the three great discoveries of the tournament.
As a conclusion, I agree with Friday, this was one of the best tournaments. And I know that he knows perfectly well what he said. Of the five tournaments that I participated, the five last ones, this was probabbly the best of all, I'm talking only in terms of albums. I think that it can perfecly be seen with the so many tigh journeys, in some cases only decided in the last minute. A real problem to our host. |
e210013
05.18.22 | As a complement to my previous comment, very short as is usual (lol), I must say one more thing.
I need to thanks to Friday, the man who had this magnificent idea. He is the man. And I need to thanks to Jethro too, one of the men that participated in all tournaments and that always live this tournaments with great passion. I really think that he lives his life always with a great passion too. So, many thanks to him too, because he raised the prog torch very high, in the same vein of our first host. He is the right man for the job too.
As a conclusion, we are waiting for the tournament in the next year that surelly will be as great as all the others. And thanks to all of you. Prog deserves this and we all deserves this too. We'll see us in the next tournament. Cheers. |
Mythodea
05.18.22 | 🧡💛💚💜💙🤍
P R E A C H |
e210013
05.18.22 | I think I already lost my opportunity. Lol. |
Jethro42
05.18.22 | Thank you guys for your rankings and comments. Sure, e21, we have to thank Friday13th, the instigator of the tournament since 8 years (8 tournaments), and our loyal and efficient host. He did it with an ease and professionalism. Because of his retirement's announcement, I started to think it's worth a replacement, and here I am, doing what I can, and I ended up liking it. So see you next year for another prog tournament. Hope to see you there again, Friday! I will do my ranking later today.
It's a pleasure to see all the love for Apofenia. It's weird, during the Elimination Round, I had a comfortable advantage over Circus, and then, in the Semi Finals, Circus surpassed me. It's like if there had more people liking Apofenia in the Elimination Rd, and more than half of the contestants definately preferring Circus for the Semi-Finals, which caused Apofenia's loss, all of a sudden. |
Jethro42
05.18.22 | My ranking, approximately;
1. Il Giardino Onirico
2. Frogg Cafe
3. All Traps On Earth
4. Axis
5. Present
6. Supersister
7. Novela
8. The Mercury Tree
9. SBB
10. Steel Mill
11. Maquina
12. Slapp Happy
13. Pekka Pohjola
14. Polis
15. Flaming Row
16. Circus
17. Jono El Grande
18. Sisare
19. Brand X
20. Mezquita |
bgillesp
05.18.22 | I think the people that loved Apofenia loved it as a top 1-3 favorite in the competition while also not always enjoying Circus as much. Those who preferred Circus either also loved Apofenia but not as much, or they didn’t have Circus as their favorite but still preferred it to Apofenia. That would explain the discrepancy in votes between the last two rounds |
Jethro42
05.18.22 | Thanks for these precisions, bgillesp. I understand it still more. Only one thing; the last part of your comment contains two ''it'', and I'm not sure if they concern Apofenia or Circus. |
Jethro42
05.18.22 | @e210013, I haven't realized that this current tournament is one of the best, even if it's only in term of albums. I also thank you to include me as a guy who already makes a difference for the tournaments. You're right, I approach them with passion, and it helps to do a good job as a host. It's not always easy, but the passion wins. Also, I'm glad you place Apofenia among those at your top. Long live prog. Feel it! |
bgillesp
05.18.22 | Remedied. Both “it”s were for Circus |
Jethro42
05.19.22 | Okay, I think I understand now. In the Elimination Rd, going with the tendancy offered, it would be Apofenia - almost - all the way. This changed for the Semi-Finals. Because of the choice left, people tend to vote for Circus as an ultime favorite, even if they liked Apofenia all the same. It's a question of tendancy. I accidentally lost my text, so I had to redo. Sorry for any confusion. |
Jethro42
05.19.22 | I understand your explanation, but i'm not sure with my reply lol. So nothing to add, it's all fine. |
Zig
05.19.22 | Congrats to Jethro for hosting this tourney! You did a fantastic job under the usual preasure!
Also thanks to everyone who participated on this! This was surely one of the best prog tourneys: so exciting and fun, and totaly unpredictable. Lastly, thanks to Friday for being our prog-mentor and pioneer.
here's my ranking:
1. Slapp Happy
2. All Traps on Earth
3. Jono El Grande
4. Present
5. Pekka Pohjola
6. Supersister
7. SBB
8. Novela
9. Máquina!
10. Sisare
11. Circus
12. Il Giardino onirico
13. Mezquita
14. The Mercury Tree
15. Axis
16. Polis
17. Steel Mill
18. Brand X
19. Steel Mill
20. Flaming Row |
Jethro42
05.19.22 | It's my pleasure, Zig. Yes, you're right, it was full of reversals and tiebreaking matchups, and unpredictable events. It wasn't always easy, but it was fun all the time. So I will warn you about another tournament next spring/summer. Thanks to be there! Bravo, Champion! Cheers! |
Sabrutin
05.20.22 | Hooray for Supersister!
No, wait...
Hooray for Axis!
No, wait...
Hooray for Pekka!
Great tournament, full of neck and neck matches. |
Jethro42
05.20.22 | Hahah! Thanks for your participation, Sab. Good nominee, your Novela. An underrated one in the tourney context. |
TwigTW
05.21.22 | Another prog tourney is completed. There are plenty of new discoveries here to keep me busy until next time. Good job guys. Especially you Jethro! |
Pheromone
05.21.22 | slapp happy are goat |
Jethro42
05.21.22 | Cheers Twig! It was a pleasure to have you with us!...Hope you'll have your own entry for the next tournament. I'm adding each album links above to reach them quickly.
Cheers Pheromone! |
porcupinetheater
05.21.22 | Phero join next year u r the prog queen |
Divaman
05.26.22 | R.I.P. to Alan White of Yes, my prog friends. |
Jethro42
05.26.22 | Yes I heard it from SirLord. From illness? |
Divaman
05.26.22 | Yes's website referred to him as dying "after a short illness". |
Jethro42
05.26.22 | That's sad. He drummed for a long while for Yes. Will jam Relayer as a rememberence, and probably Topographic Oceans. R.I.P. |