|
User
Soundoffs 461
Album Ratings 1056
Objectivity 75%
Last Active 07-12-22 7:18 am
Joined 05-21-21
Review Comments 66
| A perfectER album
If you could put one or two songs onto an album (by the same artist), do you think you could make a MORE perfect album. I was thinking this when I was listening to rain by the Beatles and realising that it would probably make revolver a top 10 album just by being there, and idk how it got snubbed. Below are a few albums that are incredibly highly acclaimed that could be EVEN BETTER with the addition of like one or two of that artist’s snubbed tracks, or just songs that ended up on the wrong album. Definitely missing dozens so feel free to add | | 1 |  | The Beatles
Revolver
Rain | | 2 |  | King Crimson
In the Court of the Crimson King
A Man A City | | 3 |  | Yes
Close to the Edge
America | | 4 |  | Radiohead
Kid A
Pyramid song | | 5 |  | Pink Floyd
The Wall
The Gunners Dream | | 6 |  | The Cure
Pornography
A forest | | 7 |  | Nick Drake
Pink Moon
I’ve always thought that River Man would be so much better suited on this album, which is already a 5. | | 8 | | The Stooges
Funhouse
Your pretty face is going to hell | | 9 |  | Death
Symbolic
My favourite death song, Lack of Comprehension, does NOT land even within 3 years of this album but I had always wondered what if | | 10 |  | Parliament
Mothership Connection
Flashlight should be on this album and I’ve always fought for that | |
zakalwe
08.21.23 | I couldn’t agree more with Rain
| JohnnyoftheWell
08.21.23 | Pyramid Song and A Forest both work best on their respective albums hmm | Ryus
08.21.23 | yeaa rly not sure about “a forest” on porno | SomeCallMeTim
08.21.23 | Alcest - Ecailles De Lune, my only gripe with the album is it feels like it reaches the conclusion / final track quite suddenly / quickly. Feel like before or after track 5 there could be one more strong track, idk if I'd necessarily put a song from another album on it tho | ArsMoriendi
08.21.23 | Flashlight being on Mothership Connection would make 0 sense
It's the summation of the themes of Funkentelechy Vs. The Placebo Syndrome and has no context regarding the themes of Mothership Connection | BillyBrill
08.22.23 | I’ll agree that flashlight is flimsy, it’s only that I think it’s a song that would make mothership connection better for being on it, not that it’s better placed on mothership than funkentelechy. A forest to me just does seem eerie enough to be on pornography in a similar way to something like the hanging garden, it’s just a little more synthetic percussion, whereas pornography’s almost primal drumming is one of the main draws especially on the hanging garden, but I can definitely see a forest AND pyramid song improving the albums listed here. Not necessarily saying they’d be better suited, just that it COULDVE happened, and the album would’ve been better for it imo | ffs
08.22.23 | always thought it was a shame the stoogies couldnt fit lost in the future on to fun house but i dunno if it would be have made that album any perfecter |
|
