Brabiz
02.28.16 | The only real negative for me was the Rathtar scene. It felt weird. |
tempest--
02.28.16 | "It felt different" lol have you watched it? |
tempest--
02.28.16 | nah but i liked it a lot |
Brabiz
02.28.16 | "Having seen it 5 times"
No. |
Brabiz
02.28.16 | It felt different to me. It had a unique atmosphere, even if a lot of plot points were similar |
LepreCon
02.28.16 | I would have liked to see something a little more original but only because the movie had literally everything else going for it. The massive box office draw and high critical ratings prove that. Anyone who didn't enjoy it needn't bother watching the other ones later on. Anyone who actually thinks the prequels were better should stick their heads down a toilet and flush it. The movie was great. Nobody bitched about Creed basically being a redux of the first Rocky. |
Brabiz
02.28.16 | Saying the prequels were more original (or better) is horrendous. Episode I was just as much a rip-off of A New Hope as The Force Awakens, but it felt different in a shitty way |
InFlamesWeThrash666
02.28.16 | I loved it. |
YetAnotherBrick
02.28.16 | i thought it was perfect. my favorite episode too prolly |
DoofusWainwright
02.28.16 | Film is bad |
hal1ax
02.28.16 | Wait, you liked it more than the original trilogy? |
chinesewhispers
02.28.16 | Yeah the movie wasn't great |
SharkTooth
02.28.16 | I just wish the basic plot wasn't so familiar, I was kinda disappointed that the movie was just a retread of A New Hope, but it was a good movie nonetheless. Not extraordinary, but not bad by any means. The hate for this movie is not really justified.
Empire Strikes Back is still my favorite |
AlexKzillion
02.28.16 | I greatly enjoyed the movie, and this new trilogy has a lot of potential because of it. I can also see it going very down hill with the next two, especially if XIII and XIV are just rehashes of Empire and Jedi like Force Awakens kind of was to the original. I don't think that will be the case but who knows.
'Saying the prequels were more original (or better) is horrendous. Episode I was just as much a rip-off of A New Hope as The Force Awakens, but it felt different in a shitty way'
Force Awakens ripped off A New Hope way more then Phantom Menace did are you serious? It may be the worst one, but it was much more different from A New Hope then Force Awakens was in pretty much every aspect. I bet if Phantom Menace ripped off A New Hope the same way Force Awakens did, Phantom Menace would have been a much better movie. |
SharkTooth
02.28.16 | I don't remember too much about the Phantom Menace, but I remember quite a few things different about it, there was a lot going on about the politics of the galaxy, and the pod racing scene stood out pretty well.
Phantom Menace simply introduced too many elements to be called a "rehash" of A New Hope as far as I am concerned |
AlexKzillion
02.28.16 | Phantom Menace simply introduced too many elements to be called a "rehash" of A New Hope as far as I am concerned.
This can be said for the rest of the prequels too tbh. |
RogueNine
02.28.16 | Good movie and I liked it a lot, but the one thing is of course that it retreads Episode IV too closely. I suppose that was to hook a new generation into Star Wars. |
Ignimbrite
02.28.16 | yeah it was spectacular, people have weird opinions |
TheSpirit
02.28.16 | Yeah it may be my fav SW |
Cryptkeeper
02.28.16 | Last act was disappointing, Rathar scene was forced and the political situation wasn't fleshed out enough. Other than that, it was pretty great. Despite some out-of-character choices. (Phasma lowering the shield, Finn and Rey suddenly changing opinions drastically) |
Calc
02.28.16 | it was aight, but so was every other star wars movie. just aight. |
Cryptkeeper
02.28.16 | U crazy |
Trebor.
02.28.16 | You need to watch more movies if you think The Force Awakens is anything more than a slightly above average low substance action/adventure film |
Trebor.
02.28.16 | Dude check Seven Samurai and Brazil |
ChoccyPhilly
02.28.16 | well it brings nothing new, plot wise. Surely that's not difficult to see why people dislike it? |
SharkTooth
02.28.16 | Last act was disappointing, Rathar scene was forced and the political situation wasn't fleshed out enough. Other than that, it was pretty great. Despite some out-of-character choices. (Phasma lowering the shield, Finn and Rey suddenly changing opinions drastically)[2] |
Calc
02.28.16 | "Dude check Seven Samurai and Brazil"
hate agreeing with treb right now considering he's being a uppity douche about it but these are both really good movies |
Trebor.
02.28.16 | I bet this dude's favorite movie is The Dark Knight |
dbizzles
02.28.16 | It was pretty pedestrian. They played it safe. I hope they follow through with the claims that the second film will be darker. |
Trebor.
02.28.16 | ughh Star Wars isn't supposed to be ultra dark and depression though
Episode III was a dumpster fire and a lot of that is because it was super edgy kill the younglings choke out a pregnant woman yayy remember when this was a fun space adventure franchise? |
SharkTooth
02.28.16 | I thought it was bad due to the scenes with Anakin and his wife, the dialogue there was just too awkward and there was just too much of it. Also III was the best of the Prequel trilogy
Also Empire Strikes Back was pretty dark, and it's the best SW movie |
dbizzles
02.28.16 | That's a fair point. I just miss the old trilogies that didn't cater to the entire family. If you liked them, it was because you liked them for what they were not because they made sure there was something for you... if that makes sense. |
Ignimbrite
02.28.16 | "You need to watch more movies if you think The Force Awakens is anything more than a slightly above average low substance action/adventure film"
http://www.reddit.com/r/moviescirclejerk |
SharkTooth
02.28.16 | Yeah for the time the original movies took giant risks. This was just too safe imo |
Trebor.
02.28.16 | "Also III was the best of the Prequel trilogy"
III is by far the worst. Please everyone just watch the plinkett reviews so I don't have to post paragraphs about why III is the worst movie of all time |
SharkTooth
02.28.16 | How can III be the worst when it had the least amount of Jar Jar? |
Trebor.
02.28.16 | Jar Jar is way less cringey because he's supposed to be stupid
Where as the whole tragedy of darth plagues speech is true cringe because it's supposed to be dark and cool and edgy but it's ten times dumber than a cartoon rabbit stepping in the poopy |
Trebor.
02.28.16 | True story of how George Lucas wrote episode III:
Hmm what number should I use for the executive order?
EXECUTE ORDER 666
No that's too obvious, how about
EXECUTE ORDER 6
No, that makes it seem like they don't get a lot of orders, how about
EXECUTE ORDER 66
Yep, good enough, let's move in |
AlexKzillion
02.28.16 | Revenge of the Sith is my favorite movie ever I just dont even give a shit. There's literally nothing I would change about that movie. It's hillarious and emotional at the same time.
Actually nah, I wish Anakin and Obi Wan actually had dialogue during their fight like they did in the ROTS game. |
dbizzles
02.28.16 | Episode 1 was the worst in my opinion, but it is real close. How much pod racing do we need to watch to realize we fucking hate Anakin's bitch ass? |
SharkTooth
02.28.16 | That's a weird choice for "favorite movie ever", I enjoyed it when I saw it in theaters but sitll |
Trebor.
02.28.16 | Hey let's have the final battle be 45 minutes long and have it take place in a video game even though it could be a 2 minutes long and it would have the same emotional resonance as long as it ends with Obi-Wan defeating Anakin
action scenes are supposed to be about the conflict between the characters, but when you don't care about the characters, and the it's just a bunch of CGI crap on the screen for 45 minutes it's easy to get bored |
AlexKzillion
02.28.16 | Yeah I kind of agree with that, I speed runned the ROTS game on my PS2 last week and throughout the whole fight Obi Wan tries to pursuade Anakin to turn back, which was way more emotional then the movie. Either way, I've read so much prequel EU and have watched both clone wars series so many times that I just feel more connected to Anakin and Obi Wan then I ever was to Luke or Han for example. I wouldn't ever try to defend ROTS but my god I love that movie. Has my favorite SW soundtrack too. |
zaruyache
02.28.16 | As a sci-film it was fantastic, but as a Star Wars film the rehashing made its story pretty meh. Still fun, but I think it detracts from the story. Next two films will be different, hopefullym |
Trebor.
02.28.16 | "As a sci-film it was fantastic"
but dude it was barely sci-fi, Star Wars has always been more on the fantasy side |
RogueNine
02.28.16 | Regardless of any review II is the worst. |
Trebor.
02.28.16 | I'd argue II is the best because it contains the only good scene in the whole trilogy, the part where they have to fight the beasts without their lightsabers, cuz there's actual tension, aaaand then it's gone once they have their lightsabers and start wrecking people |
AlexKzillion
02.28.16 | Yeah I thought Anikan and Obi Wan vs. Count Dooku in II had tension too since Dooku was clearly stronger then them, but it was kind of ruined by how horribly shot the scene was. |
Trebor.
02.28.16 | There's absolutely nothing going on between the characters except Dooku is the bad guy and Anikan and Obi Wan are the good guys |
Middle18
02.28.16 | You really got a chip on your shoulder about episode III aye Trebor.? It's the most entertaining of the prequels you have to admit that. |
dathvada321
02.28.16 | I thought it was pretty weak. Unoriginal plot (this movie was wayyy more similar to A New Hope than The Phantom Menace was; not sure how anyone could argue otherwise), terrible pacing, weak score, poorly handled character development, and an extremely disappointing final act. The acting and action scenes were great, but beyond that I wasn't impressed. |
smaugman
02.28.16 | it's on par with episode 5 that's fo sho |
Cryptkeeper
02.28.16 | You can talk shit about the prequels all you want but the score is fucking amazing.
Battle of the Heroes justifies the prequels for me. |
AlexKzillion
02.28.16 | 'There's absolutely nothing going on between the characters except Dooku is the bad guy and Anikan and Obi Wan are the good guys'
Except for the fact that Anakin and Obi Wan would have greatly shortened the Clone Wars (and maybe even stopped them from ever happening) if they defeated Dooku, because the separatist movement would have probably fallen apart since Dooku was it's leader. |
Intothepit
02.29.16 | People ripping on The Force Awakens are ridiculous. Good god. |
Mystletainn
02.29.16 | I don't think it's perfect... but I enjoyed it quite a bit. |
Keyblade
02.29.16 | was very enjoyable, even if u didnt know anything about sw beforehand |
furyroad97
02.29.16 | Probably my favourite one since Empire. |
Intothepit
02.29.16 | Yeah I don't like any of those. |