tvol
08.06.10 | crack the skye is one of the worst albums i own. leviathon isn't far behind. amazingly overrated band. |
therayder
08.06.10 | You might get some hate for having Crack the Skye as 1, but this list is pretty much what I think also. Although honestly 1, 2, and 3 are all worthy of being their best. |
theacademy
08.06.10 | nope |
TheyTookOurJobs
08.06.10 | List needs Opeth |
bloc
08.06.10 | I motion you change your list to "Mastodon New to Old" |
Deviant.
08.06.10 | Seconded |
londoncalling457
08.06.10 | overrated? yeah, but still great. i loved crack the sky at first but now it's grown off me. 2, 3, 1 for me (haven't heard remission). |
ironmaiden1204
08.06.10 | List needs Opeth
LOL |
MUNGOLOID
08.06.10 | i thought 2 was better than 1. hell, even 4. |
Nikkolae
08.06.10 | leviathan has to be 1, and remission 2, crack the skye 3 and blood mountain fourth, there fixed it for you |
TheBloodTypo
08.06.10 | List lacks good music.
They're awful live, too. |
somberlain
08.06.10 | I find Mastodon to be very similar to Opeth as far as how overrated they are on this site but also how different their albums are and how much disagreement there is as far as what their best album is.
I think Leviathan is their best |
therayder
08.06.10 | I saw them live; they weren't bad. Not fantastic, but average. |
Ire
08.06.10 | HOLY SHIT THIS LIST IS 100% CORRECT |
kangaroopoo
08.06.10 | I agree with order. For me, Mastodon + also BTBAM songs and production have become better, richer and more refined with each album. |
MrBirdoWordo
08.06.10 | you just listed the albums from newest to oldest and forgot call of the mastodon |
Athom
08.06.10 | reverse this list and you've got my stance |
Dryden
08.06.10 | no dont |
qwe3
08.06.10 | best one is leviathan then remission. all their other stuff is shit |
Tw1ster
08.06.10 | CTS is my number one, I like the other three equally. They always switch it up and I respect that especially when it continues to sound different than anything else out there |
austin888
08.06.10 | Thank you, Ire. |
theacademy
08.06.10 | leviathan blows the other 3 away. |
Ire
08.06.10 | np babe
i was going to make a list when i saw the title but you got the correct ordering, brah. |
FadeToBlack
08.10.10 | 4 is the best
the rest are terrible |
ShadowAmI
08.10.10 | i would go 1,3,4,2. i didnt really like blood mountain at all. |
NeroCorleone80
08.14.10 | 3 and 4 are the best here. |
ShadowRemains
08.14.10 | YES! A MASTODON GUITAR SOLO! |
Ire
08.14.10 | Asobi Seksu - Citrus |
KILL
08.14.10 | a mastodon guitar solo was funny but Sludgy, Proggy, intense and one hell of a ride. was way better |
Dwap
08.31.10 | Crack The Skye
Leviathan
Blood Mountain
Remission |
