thesystemisdown
09.24.09 | also if you can recommend other albums that seem consistent with this list that would be appreciated. |
qwe3
09.24.09 | 1 3 11 19
and maybe 12 maybe |
qwe3
09.24.09 | oh shit
sorry
those are the ones you SHOULD get. mybaddd |
xNintendoCorex
09.24.09 | get them all then decide for yourself |
rasputin
09.24.09 | get 1, 2, 3 and 19 forget the rest |
qwe3
09.24.09 | nintendo then he would get like 16 crappy albums |
PuddlesPuddles
09.24.09 | qwe, he should actually DEFINITELY get 12 |
WhiteWallStargazers
09.24.09 | I wouldn't get 4 or 10 personally |
qwe3
09.24.09 | mmm 12 is decent |
Waior
09.24.09 | don't get 4
don't get 4
don't get 4
don't get 4
and no matter what people say, 11 and 20 are good. and 13 is amazing |
rasputin
09.24.09 | porcupine tree are horrid |
PuddlesPuddles
09.24.09 | quiet
qwe, deadwing is probably one of their best yet though. what dont you like about it? |
Waior
09.24.09 | i thought deadwing was really poor but i need to listen more |
cirq
09.24.09 | Do NOT get 4 |
PuddlesPuddles
09.24.09 | Whaaaaaaaat
Open Car? Halo? Shallow? Lazarus?
Cmonnn |
bloc
09.24.09 | Shallow's one of my favourite songs from Porcupine Tree. |
qwe3
09.24.09 | sky moves sideways is easily the best thing porcupine tree has done |
Boognish
09.24.09 | Don't get 11. The only Mars Volta anybody needs is the debut |
Yotimi
09.24.09 | I actually agree with you Boognish. |
qwe3
09.24.09 | tmv are kinda lame but imo octahedron is their best. some of de loused was great though |
PuddlesPuddles
09.24.09 | Deloused was great, octahedron and frances are eh. bedlam is pretty great |
Yotimi
09.24.09 | To be fair, I haven't listened to 11 yet but my hopes aren't high. |
qwe3
09.24.09 | frances the mute blows, that ampu whatever blew, bedlam was alright, de loused was good and octahedron was better |
Boognish
09.24.09 | Nah, De-Loused is definitely the best they have to offer. The other albums have their moments, but pretty much everything else they've done since has been self indulgent bullshit. |
LepreCon
09.24.09 | 11 blows. Just sayin |
qwe3
09.24.09 | a lot of deloused is self indulgent, but not as much bullshit as frances was. octahedron for me was much more interesting |
dankeyes11
09.24.09 | TMV and Porcupine Tree are at least worth listening to. I love them both, but obviously not everyone does. They are both worthy of a listen though. |
Baphomet
09.24.09 | Get 3, 9 and 19. You'll soon forget you even had a wishlist with albums other than these. |
Aids
09.24.09 | Scary Kids Scaring Kids is supposed to be really bad. So I'd stay away from that. The rest ranges from OK to awesome. |
stargazer76
09.24.09 | Don't get 11! The worst Mars Volta album yet - Frances the Mute or De-loused are miles better! |
bungy
09.24.09 | Don't listen to the people hatin on porcupine tree. |
TRMshadow
09.25.09 | 2, 3, 4, 11, 15, 17, 18, and 20..... The rest are pretty dang good though |
Mordecai.
09.25.09 | GOJIRA GOJIRA GOJIRA GOJIRA |
xNintendoCorex
09.25.09 | qw3, no.
amputechture is the worst TMV album follwed by octahedron, theyre so weak in comparision.
nothing wrong the music being self indulgent, its almost a necessity in the prog genre.
cmon mannn, cassandra gemini parts A - E. Thats sustained proggy goodness right there |
qwe3
09.25.09 | of course all prog is self indulgent to some degree, but there are bands that just do it better. frances the mute just contains so much bullshit. octahedron was less full of shit i guess. amputechture and frances are my least fav from them
i didnt say de loused was bad, it's just not the amazing masterpiece people claim it to be imo. gets tedious |
Mordecai.
09.25.09 | and by Gojira, i mean you better get it. |
YouAreMySilence
09.25.09 | Get 19 fo sho |
