JDubb
08.17.26 | 4 would be low down in the list for me. But like this ranking |
Dwap
08.19.26 | 1 and 2 are correct.
Not sure how you gonna do my boy Emperor of Sand like that.
|
Hertzy
08.19.26 | For me it would be 3,1,4,2,7. Did not hear the rest yet. |
Sevengill
08.19.26 | as long as the top 4 are the top 4, it's good |
evilford
08.19.26 | [2] |
Sevengill
08.19.26 | "For me it would be 3,1,4,2,7"
BM at #1 is a mildly hot take but I'm about it |
TheAntichrist
08.19.26 | 4 is top 3 |
ChuckyTruant
08.19.26 | Marrow Deep is shaping up to be a great album, imo. |
NaturalLaw
08.19.26 | Crack the Skye is so damn good. Been forever since I listened to these guys |
Hertzy
08.19.26 | "BM at #1 is a mildly hot take but I'm about it"
Is it? I thought the top 4 was pretty interchangeable. But yeah, I found Blood Mountain to be the absolute best. |
BookoftheFallen
08.19.26 | Blood mountain is amazing. It has some
Of the best mastodon songs like wolf is loose, colony of birch men, sleeping giant. But leviathan and crack the skye are slightl better. |
evilford
08.19.26 | Capillarian crest! |
Hertzy
08.19.26 | Agree with all of those and I'll add This Mortal Soil. Really enjoy this one. But I know it's not a standout like Capillarian Crest, Colony of Birchman or Wolf is Loose. |
Sevengill
08.19.26 | I've had a soft spot for Siberian Divide too. Just teeters on the edge of groovy and crazy. |
budgie
08.19.26 | mortal soil is my fav off blood mountain
such an incredible fkn track |
Gyromania
08.19.26 | I think 1 is so overrated but still good. CtS and BM fs better tho |
Obrotherartthou
08.20.26 | Hushed and grim at 8 below the hunter makes this whole list invalid |
Hertzy
08.20.26 | "mortal soil is my fav off blood mountain
such an incredible fkn track" [2] |
AffableMartyr
08.20.26 | 2 is my fav |
NaturalLaw
08.20.26 | Colony of Birch Men is what got me into Mastodon because it was on Rock Band. Super fun on the drums! |
keaton_86
08.20.26 | OMRTS should be last. its got some good songs but overall as an album its the worst. Their discography is fucking great though. |
