Brabiz
06.02.26 | Iām sorry |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.02.26 | It took me like a full year of listening to this band to really get into them tbh
It didn't click for me personally until I got to Wavering Radiant, then I worked my way backwards and really understood |
Hawks
06.02.26 | Amazing band yes. |
Christbait
06.02.26 | They get better as you go. Don't worry if your personal ratings don't reflect the majority. I think your appreciation for them depends on which album you start with, honestly. So keep an open mind as you continue since they do change up quite a bit by the time In the Absence of Truth rolls around. |
bananatossing
06.02.26 | You shouldāve listened to Mosquito Control and Red Sea before jumping into Celestial. Also give SGNL>05 a listen if you will. |
gabba
06.02.26 | Their first 3 albums are flawless, the best 3-album run in the ISIS/CoL/Neurosis discog imo. There's not a weak moment on Celestial, and it goes much harder than the rest, it is quite different. |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.02.26 | I mean I like Neurosis way more but yeah all 3 bands are fucking incredible, some of the best bands ever |
budgie
06.02.26 | jam pelican instead |
bighubbabuddha
06.02.26 | Wavering Radiant is their best, closely followed by Panopticon. Celestial is a grower. |
jrlikestodance
06.02.26 | Oceanic and Wavering are my top dogs |
gabba
06.02.26 | Interesting, I like Wavering the least. It's good, but not the level of their earliest ones. But maybe it'll grow on me later. |
Brabiz
06.02.26 | Listened to the first track off Oceanic while on my break at work. Much more interested in hearing this one. Was worried this list would be a Sput nuke with how Celestial went. Donāt want Hawks showing up at my house or some shit. |
Hawks
06.02.26 | Hahahahahahaha |
Brabiz
06.02.26 | My mileage with post-rock / metal varies. So we shall see. Iāve tried numerous times to get into Neurosis and it just never happens. Kind of frustrating actually |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.02.26 | I mean yeah all of these post bands didnāt click immediately with me, but now all 3 of them are like in my top 20 bands of all time (neurosis being #2) |
bighubbabuddha
06.02.26 | Neurosis latest album is easily AOTY, check it if you haven't bro |
Hawks
06.02.26 | Neurosis is my second fav band of all-time. |
bighubbabuddha
06.02.26 | Neurosis are in my top 50 hahaha. Man music rules |
Demon of the Fall
06.02.26 | It took me 15 years to fully appreciate Panopticon. If you like variety and find the vox boring, then Oceanic may be a better bet.
simplistic breakdown...
Big 3 post-metal = top 10 bands of all time, the only metal bands placing this high these days
non top 3 post-metal = gonna struggle cracking top 100... unless I give Fall of Efrafa a pass despite only releasing one post-metal album lol |
unclereich
06.02.26 | Israeli Secret Intelligence Service m/ |
Brabiz
06.02.26 | No way, this band put cameras in my house!! |
IsisScript80
06.02.26 | They're frickin' incredible.
I've listened to them in real-time since around 2003... setting up a listening marathon in order to "get" them, seems needlessly fraught and pressurised. |
Brabiz
06.02.26 | Alright, Oceanic is added. Had to cut down my thoughts because I just kept writing lmao |
Hawks
06.02.26 | LETS GOOOOO!!!! |
Brabiz
06.02.26 | āThis is one of the best songs Iāve ever heardā - me every 2 minutes |
Brabiz
06.02.26 | Onto round 2 immediately. The production alone, goddddd. The drums sound like someone punching the inside of my head |
Hawks
06.02.26 | Can't wait for you to hear Panopticon and Wavering Radiant! |
Shuyin
06.02.26 | Don't skip on Mosquito Control, it slaps |
Sevengill
06.02.26 | bruh the absolute gushing over Oceanic is making my night. I'm reliving my spiritual awakening vicariously through your descriptions. bless. |
HooperD87
06.02.26 | Ooft, gonna check back for your thoughts on Panopticon. Can't really think of a better three track run than the opening three on that one |
Hawks
06.02.26 | Don't skip on Mosquito Control, it slaps [2] |
jrlikestodance
06.02.26 | I also 5'd Oceanic after first/second listen. Wavering Radiant is almost there for me too |
Orb
06.03.26 | Panopticon is gonna break ya! Happy journeys friendo! Couldn't have picked a better band to do this with |
madcowdisease
06.03.26 | āThis is one of the best songs Iāve ever heardā - me every 2 minutes [2]
I also discovered this band recently and its gratifying to see someone else just blown away to the same degree. Hope you're ready for Panopticon and Wavering Radiant |
Demon of the Fall
06.03.26 | "I've listened to them in real-time since around 2003"
imagine NOT using time-travel, ugh |
IsisScript80
06.03.26 | ^ Yeah, the very thought of it!
"Panopticon is gonna break ya!"
I don't know if it's possible to raise expectations too much, but I 100% agree. It's one of the greatest things I've ever heard. |
dbizzles
06.03.26 | Celestial is mad underrated but it's just because of Oceanic and Panopticon lol. |
jrlikestodance
06.03.26 | Agreed Celestial rocks. Love the rawness of it |
Orb
06.03.26 | Aging to an era where a whole other generation is just discovering Isis is a wild feeling tbh. Happy about it though! |
Colliiiin
06.05.26 | Hell ye, happy they're clicking for you. Fave band since I was like 16. I bought In the Absence when I was around 13/14 because I saw Underoath members rocking their merch. Can't say I fully understood it at the time aha, but I did think it was interesting. I latched onto Oceanic in high school and haven't looked back since.
|
DarkSideOfLucca
06.05.26 | Surprised they clicked so fast tbh, this band took me years to "get"
But to be fair, the first time I heard them was 20 years ago when I was 16 so |
Sevengill
06.05.26 | so did he like, just get lost in Oceanic and that's that? |
Confessed2005
06.05.26 | Band are one of the GOAT - and that is in any genre, let alone Post Metal itself. |
Brabiz
06.07.26 | ā so did he like, just get lost in Oceanic and that's that?ā kinda, yeah lmao.
Planning to listen to Panopticon today though |
Larkinhill
06.07.26 | Celestial is the only one I wouldnāt consider to be a great album, and Oceanic and Panopticon are masterpieces. |