DarkSideOfLucca
05.05.26 | Maybe testament too i dunno |
bighubbabuddha
05.05.26 | Needs Opeth for metal material |
jrlikestodance
05.05.26 | Defeated Sanity |
Hawks
05.05.26 | Defeated Sanity [2] |
jrlikestodance
05.05.26 | I’d also say Nevermore should be on this list |
DarkSideOfLucca
05.05.26 | Yeah I like Defeated Sanity but I definitely don't love them, honestly they are pretty hard to listen to most of the time
But I used to feel the same way about Ulcerate so ::shrug:: |
Hawks
05.05.26 | WHAT!!!! |
DarkSideOfLucca
05.05.26 | Ahahah I knew I would get that response from Hawks
Honestly they're really good, but the music can be all over the place and the vocals have that one singular tone throughout.
I love death metal vocals, it's my favorite genre, but basically NO highs or mids, man, literally the same exact grunt every song every album |
budgie
05.05.26 | arcturus and finntroll are incredibly consistent like 3.5+ and 4.0+ across the board |
Kimm
05.05.26 | "Needs Opeth for metal material"
...how are we defining consistency tho |
DarkSideOfLucca
05.05.26 | Yeah I can't add Opeth considering I don't really listen to them at all post Ghost Reveries
I wanted to add Mastodon, Gojira and some others but they also fell off for me after their first handful |
jrlikestodance
05.05.26 | Defeated Sanity has had like 4 or 5 different vocalists to be fair |
Donchivo
05.05.26 | Monstrosity & Lost Soul are both incredibly consistent, 5+ albums both and none below a 4 |
DarkSideOfLucca
05.05.26 | "Defeated Sanity has had like 4 or 5 different vocalists to be fair"
Did they just keep firing and hiring the same guy but with a slightly different haircut? |
Orb
05.05.26 | This list is pretty damn on point. I wouldn't call every super consistent band a band that constantly pumps out classics, but at least maintains a certain level of unwavering quality and consistency of sound. In that sense I think Incantation deserves a spot too. |
jrlikestodance
05.05.26 | They become more distinguishable w repeat listens imo but I think they all got their own sauce. Bolt Thrower is also among the most consistent |
DarkSideOfLucca
05.05.26 | I think I've only heard the first 3 Incantation albums, but they are my bottle opener on my keys that I use every time I have a beer and I absolutely adore those 3 albums |
Hawks
05.05.26 | Incantation is top-tier throughout their discog. |
Emim
05.05.26 | Norma Jean |
budgie
05.05.26 | this list is def well made bc it doesnt say consistently good just says consistent |
MementoMori
05.05.26 | Some options I thought of from the top of my head (besides Defeated Sanity) with more than two records: Imperial Triumphant, Cult of Luna, ISIS, Amenra, Intronaut, Ne Obliviscaris, Stargazer, Artificial Brain, and Obliteration. Certainly agree with 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 14. |
BookoftheFallen
05.05.26 | You cant make a list like this without insomnium and dark tranquility |
jrlikestodance
05.05.26 | I think he just did brother |
DarkSideOfLucca
05.05.26 | Oh fuck I'm adding Cult of Luna and Isis, I'm retarded
And I haven't jammed all of dark tranquility or insomnium SO THE LIST STANDS |
Kimm
05.05.26 | Cult of Luna / Insomnium [500]
|
DoofDoof
05.05.26 | Blut Aus Nord I'd put at the top of the pile for most consistent.
Recently ran through the entire Cathedral discog and that was unexpectedly consistent. |
Jmal00
05.05.26 | Anacrusis |
DarkSideOfLucca
05.06.26 | "Cult of Luna / Insomnium [500]"
Bruh Cult of Luna was added already by the time you commented this lol |
Orb
05.07.26 | Cult of Luma |
