hel9000
07.17.25 | Diary's my top, then each subsequent album goes down .5. Would love to hear something new from them, feel like it's a possibility with how much they've been touring plus the three OGs seem to be in a good place. Ever given that Fire Theft album a listen? |
swallowtales
07.17.25 | I can get behind this, I do think How It Feels is the best - what a record |
Slex
07.17.25 | 100% correct ranking |
Wildcardbitchesss
07.17.25 | Swap 1 and 2 fam |
botb
07.17.25 | Swap 3 and 4 for me and that’s a winner |
SmashIsTheWay94
07.17.25 | 10/10 ranking, no notes |
AffableMartyr
07.17.25 | 1 and 2 are super close, but 1 has slightly better replayability |
swallowtales
07.17.25 | Reckon it also drags less, I always find I'm starting to lose it a bit with Diary towards the end. |
PunkerBlast
07.18.25 | The ranking is about right. I don't really have much of a strong case for ranking it differently without doing something "lame" like a bunch of ties and just for four albums heh A long time ago I would have likely put Diary number one but I HiFtbSO just flows really well and it is such an great listen. The Pink album is incredibly powerful at times and I like the mystique of it. Then there's The Rising Tide which is certainly a good album and has some fantastic songs, I am definitely not putting it in top two.
Just some thoughts since I happened to see the list and I went all; Yep there was a time when this band was everything to me. May as well chime in. |
