Hawks
07.17.25 | 1. Men
2. Master of Men
3. Fade to Men
4. The Men III
5. Omenon
6. The Men That Never Comes
7. Bleeding Men
8. The Unforgivemen
9. Creeping Men
10. St. Men |
IsisScript80
07.17.25 | "6. The Men That Never Comes"
Poor guys. :( |
Jurtz
07.17.25 | Mentallica |
Kusangii
07.17.25 | Lmfaoo the men that never comes 😭 |
cylinder
07.17.25 | THUNDER GUITAR TAKE CONTROL! |
AlexKzillion
07.17.25 | 1 is one is one is 1 is 1 is one is one is 1 |
AlexKzillion
07.17.25 | 6. The Men That Never Comes
this is up there with "one last shit" |
Hawks
07.17.25 | One Last Shit is amazing!!! |
IsisScript80
07.17.25 | Not listed, but I personally enjoy the song "Ride the Men"... title track of 1984's 'Ride the Men' album.
Same could be said of 1988's '...And Men for All". Great, great stuff! [Thumbs-up emoji that Gen Z purportedly find strangely rude] |
TheSonomaDude
07.17.25 | erm WHY are we talking about METALLICA??? we need to be discussing REAL music like Eliot Smith and Empire Empire (I was a Lonely Estate)!!! |
Zac124
07.17.25 | Pretty great list tbh. Although 10 and 7 are odd choices. 5 is 1 for me. One of my all time favourites. |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
07.17.25 | 10 that's based |
arthropod
07.17.25 | 1. Until Men Sleeps
2. Creeping Men
3. The Unforgiv(m)en
4. Men too Black
5. Men Said
6. The Men Remains
7. (don't) Hit the Men
8. Welcome Men
9. The Shortest Men
10. Man
Honorable mentions: Black(m)ened, Enter Sandmen & If Men Had a Son |
Trebor.
07.17.25 | *Saint Anger on the toilet giving himself a pep talk*
YOU FLUSH IT OUT
YOU FLUSH IT OUT |
arthropod
07.17.25 | I'M MANLY IN ANGER WITH U |
Trebor.
07.17.25 | *When you don't courtesy flush after the first set*
FUCK IT ALL AND FUCKING NO REGRETS |
chemicalmarriage
07.17.25 | Hit the lights on these dark shits |
BookoftheFallen
07.19.25 | Why hasn’t anyone mentioned the four horseMEN |
budgie
07.19.25 | horrible list |
Wildcardbitchesss
07.19.25 | okay, there is some revisionism happening with Load, Reload, and especially St Anger, which is deserved imo, they’re not *AS* bad as a lot of people make them out to be… but bro goddamn none of those songs belong anywhere near a top 10 in a Metallica ranking period end of story. |
Wildcardbitchesss
07.19.25 | There’s legit at least 30 songs from just their first 4 records that go before anything in that little red headed step child trilogy of albums. |
Wildcardbitchesss
07.19.25 | Props for putting All Nightmare long this high, I wouldn’t, but that song does not get its due. That and Spit Out the Bone can hang with their best records imo |
DominionMM1
07.19.25 | no idea what you’re on about. bleeding me is absolutely top shelf metallica. not only that but load clears everything they’ve done since they started pandering to the same people they basically told to fuck off 20 years ago.
reload and st anger do indeed suck though |
Muzz79
07.19.25 | 1. Ride The Lightning
2. Orion
3. Blackened
4. Disposable Heroes
5. Welcome Home Sanitarium
6. Fight Fire With Fire
7. For Whom The Bell Tolls
8. Struggle Within
9. My Friend of Misery
10. Dyers Eve |
arthropod
07.19.25 | "none of those songs belong anywhere near a top 10"
until it sleeps is in top 3, bite me |
Muzz79
07.19.25 | 1. Fade to Black
2. One
3. Master of Puppets
4. Creeping Death
5. The Unforgiven
6. Damage Inc
7. The Four HorseMen
8. …And Justice For All
9. Metal Militia
10. Frayed Ends of Sanity |
budgie
07.19.25 | 1. call of ktulu
2. four horsemen
3. phantom lord
4. for whom the bell tolls
5. ride lightning
6. motorbreath
7. no remorse
8. orion
9. seek & destroy
10. metal militia
|
Wildcardbitchesss
07.19.25 | “not only that but load clears everything they’ve done since they started pandering to the same people they basically told to fuck off 20 years ago.”
I do not disagree if we’re talking about Hardwired and 72 Seasons, I’d take Load over those records any day of the week. Spit Out the Bone still rules. Death Magnetic is just a great record in general imo, easily their fifth best.
Until it Sleeps and Bleeding Me are fine, but I stand by what I said. There’s at least 30 early tallica songs I’d put ahead of them, probably more. |
Wildcardbitchesss
07.19.25 | Oh and Beyond Magnetic rules and would be their sixth best if it were an LP, which it might as well be because the fucker’s 30 minutes lol |
