DarkSideOfLucca
06.02.25 | Right under Meshuggah for me as best band ever.
Goddamn, they rule so hard. |
Comatorium.
06.02.25 | Scott Kelly is a piece of shit and cult of Luna has always been better anyway lol |
jrlikestodance
06.02.25 | Yet you were defending Brand New in the other thread^^^ |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.02.25 | "Scott Kelly is a piece of shit" - Agreed. And tbh, I totally get if you can't separate the artist from the art - I can't listen to Burzum or Kanye anymore, so I get it, but Neurosis is my second favorite band of all time and their music means too much for me so despite Scott, I still absolutely love this music - only band that beats them out for me is the Shug.
" and cult of Luna has always been better anyway"
Yeah hard disagree there lol. I love Cult of Luna, don't get me wrong, and I did a discog run of them last year and it was amazing, but I DEFINITELY prefer Neurosis personally. Cult of Luna does rule, though. |
BookoftheFallen
06.02.25 | Neurosis have so much amazing music, but souls at zero and enemy of the sun are my favorites. The sovereign EP is worth ranking as well. |
Comatorium.
06.02.25 | Fuck off with your false equivalency whataboutisms, JR. Scott Kelly beat the shit out of his family regularly and openly admitted it.
I guess I should’ve included that I loved neurosis and Scott’s BS was a big blow to me. I like that response though! Not your typical Sputnik discourse lol |
jrlikestodance
06.02.25 | I think they're both pieces of shit, we just want consistency! |
Comatorium.
06.02.25 | Lmao I guess Lacey, Kelly, Weinstein, Cosby, and Diddy are all the same in your pea brain. |
Demon of the Fall
06.02.25 | Incredible band. I won't quibble too much here. Bottom three are certainly the last tier. TSIB is top 2. Personally I'd drop 2-4 down and raise ASTNS / Souls, but all's good here.
Scott Kelly is a pos but fortunately for those immoral enough to separate the two (hi!) Neurosis's music is still special. I understand if that's not the case tho
idk I've made so many of my own memories listening to their disocg from way before any of this was known, that I don't have those negative associations. I am fortunate! |
jrlikestodance
06.02.25 | Classic Coma reach. I'd still jam Neurosis fasho |
jrlikestodance
06.02.25 | Sorry for derailing your list Lucca |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.02.25 | Lmfao nah dude you’re good
I can’t stop jamming neurosis so ::shrug:: |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.02.25 | Bumping for Times of Grace love |
MillionDead
06.02.25 | Listening to music by people doesn't mean you condone their shitty behavior any more than eating a burger means you condone animal torture, just my two cents. Wouldn't call listening to Neurosis "immoral" on its face, even though I'm never buying any merch. Top 5 would probably be my same order. |
JohnnyoftheWell
06.02.25 | not reading this thread have we reached the part where someone reminds us that scott kelly's shittiness isn't embedded in the aesthetics+substance of neurosis' music as with most comparable examples eg brand new swap 3 and 6 great band |
Hawks
06.02.25 | 5
3
1
6
7
4
8
11
10
9
Lets get back on track lol. |
DadKungFu
06.02.25 | assuming that's top to bottom, hell yeah |
Hawks
06.02.25 | Indeed it is Dad bro! |
SomeCallMeTim
06.02.25 | why does copatorium literally only ever show up to white knight about pearl clutching or clutch their own |
anode
06.02.25 | It’s all some people have |
Spec
06.02.25 | 6 is waaaaaay too low my guy. |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.02.25 | 6 used to be my 1
Reality is that top 6 are all basically 5/5 albums (similar to Meshuggah and Death, almost the entire discog is amazing and better than most albums) |
Spec
06.02.25 | Fair enough tbh. Crawl Back In keeps it number one for me. |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.02.25 | Stones in the sky is my favorite off that one, one of my favorites by them in general |
Emim
06.02.25 | I actually quite like Pain of Mind |
evilford
06.03.25 | Best band ever made yeah
Tsib
Astns
Life
Gttr
Teoes
Saz
Tog
Eots
Fwf
Twal
Hfid
Pom |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.03.25 | "Best band ever made yeah"
Hard to argue that |
Veldin
06.04.25 | Hawks am I blind or did you forget to put Times of Grace on your ranking?
Amazing band for sure |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.04.25 | Yeah I was looking for Times of Grace there as well aha |
