Muzz79
05.09.25 | Winters gate was the gateway for me and been all over em since |
Hawks
05.09.25 | Bro....STDIACD last is blasphemy. |
Hawks
05.09.25 | Mine would be:
6
4
9
2
1
8
5
7
Haven't heard 3 yet. |
Muzz79
05.09.25 | I tried and tried with 9, couldn't click |
Hawks
05.09.25 | ATWW way too low also. :[ Tbf I love all of their stuff. Really gotta jam 3. |
rockarollacola
05.09.25 | I made it 3 albums in and called it a day. So the later albums are actually good? |
CottonSalad
05.09.25 | 6 would be a lot higher for me, but I am all about this love for 1 |
Muzz79
05.09.25 | Rly dig their later stuff |
Hawks
05.09.25 | Oh I'm about the love for 1 too. 1, 2, 4, 6 and 9 are all easy 4.5s for me lol. |
DaveyMonsoon
05.09.25 | I don't find Winter's Gate all that good (still good tho) but it's nice to see someone that knows their last 2 rule. |
Hawks
05.09.25 | Ok fuck it I'm jamming 3 right now then I'll be back with a re-ranking lol. |
ThyCrossAwaits
05.09.25 | I’d be like 1, 2, 6, 5, 4, 3, the rest.
Anno 1696 is great but not that great. I’m interested to hear Hawks’ opinion especially since bro’s already a fan |
Hawks
05.09.25 | Not gonna lie, its shaping up to be my least fav Insomnium so far lol. |
DaveyMonsoon
05.09.25 | Buncha party poopers smh |
Hawks
05.09.25 | Yeah bro I'm not digging this at all. The first time I can say that about an Insomnium album. Damn! |
Hawks
05.09.25 | Ok yeah no need to re-rank. 3 is by far my least favorite of theirs lmao. Its not even close. |
Crysis
05.09.25 | cannot begin to describe how much i disagree with this list
well exception being one for sorrow that album is really meh |
Muzz79
05.09.25 | Knew there'd be some pushback on the early records being lower on the list. Personal prefs.
Hawks 3 takes a few listens and sink in time |
Hawks
05.09.25 | I'll give it a couple tries but first listen was awful. I doubt my opinion will change sadly lol. |
frozencarl
05.09.25 | damn muzzy this is an interesting ranking! 2 is definitely 2 but 6 gotta be 1 for me. |
Ocean of Noise
05.09.25 | Ranking causes me physical pain but I admire the audacity |
Muzz79
05.09.25 | carl dude cheers I hope not to offend above the weeping world
ocean hahaha love it |
mystagogus
05.09.25 | A good reminder to go through the discog, overall agree with at least top three, Anno with EPs is one of the best.
Enjoy the gig Muzz! |
Pikazilla
05.09.25 | 6 sucks, 2 is king |
Muzz79
05.09.25 | Sick show |
Eakflanderyof
05.09.25 | This is damn near my list in reverse order lol. One for sorrow is appropriately low though. Winter's gate is probably around 3 or 4 for me too. Other than that basically polar opposite of my ranking lol.
It probably depends on what album got you into insomnium. I got into them back when stdiacd came out so for me I liked the riffier side of them. Now it's less riffy and more like melancholic soundscape stuff |
mystagogus
05.09.25 | > It probably depends on what album got you into insomnium.
Guess that applies to pretty much everything, not only music. |
Muzz79
05.09.25 | “I got into them back when stdiacd came out so for me I liked the riffier side of them. Now it's less riffy and more like melancholic soundscape stuff”. This is exactly my point. I prefer the latter.
Best songs last night were Lilian, The Witch Hunter and the encore of Primeval Dark into While we sleep and then Heart like a grave. Omnium Gatherum got as a reception as Insomnium and sounded great |
Coast
05.10.25 | I'm seeing Insomnium and OG tonight, saw Massacre + Convulse last night. 2 double headers in 2 nights, already cooked. |
Dedes
05.10.25 | DEATH WALKED THE EARTH TODAY
WITHOUT A SOUND
MOTIONLESS
I appreciate your fandom but STDIACD being mid does sadden me soul
Only Insomnium I don't -love- and only like is Heart Like a Grave so I spose we sit on different ends of the spectrum lol |
Muzz79
05.10.25 | Enjoy Coast sry for the spoilers!
Dedes good band if we can have polar opposite favorites |
SuzyC
05.10.25 | Yeah, "Heart Like a Grave" is their most fantastic album -> not their only wonderful album, but their most wonderful. They caught and held my attention about 15 years ago, when I was 41. |
Muzz79
05.11.25 | 15 years ago would’ve been around Across the Dark - my fav of the 00’s |
