jrlikestodance
01.30.25 | Agree on 1 and 6. They managed to make hardcore music boring which is impressive |
WalrusTusk
01.30.25 | Agree with literally all of these. |
CottonSalad
01.30.25 | disagree hard on 8 and 12 fam -- otherwise, not too much to complain about here lol
keep up the VIBE CHECKS |
Demon of the Fall
01.30.25 | hmm, these are some solid choices, ngl
12 is my only real bone of contention |
Hawks
01.30.25 | LMAOOOOO HERE WE GO WITH THE PAYSAGE SLANDER FROM SOMEONE WHO HAS ZERO KNOWLEDGE OF BLACK METAL!!! |
BigBlob
01.30.25 | get 14 off here |
AnimalForce1
01.30.25 | It’s funny because some of my favorite albums of 2024 are on this list. So obvious disagree on 1, 2, 6, 7, and 9. Everything else I just haven’t listened to yet so I have no opinion |
Hawks
01.30.25 | " but a girl, wow. It's not even a new thing, either."
Tundra you are so dense its not even funny. Its sad. |
JohnnyoftheWell
01.30.25 | lil prog bitch really picking his moments to care about coherent song structures huh
Boundaries and Counterparts are straight dogwater, and Magdalena Bay/Foxing are shoe-ins for any list of this kind, but everything else is a lifetime's worth of raises above your pay grade (and by all means write another Poppy review to prove it) |
Hawks
01.30.25 | "(and by all means write another Poppy review to prove it)"
12th time's a charm!!! |
Relinquished
01.30.25 | nice tones of sexism too lol, “it’s this, but a girl” wow kid so thought-out |
DadKungFu
01.30.25 | Barring 10 and 12 which are just egregious, uh yeah pretty much |
Calc
01.30.25 | oh lord my jimmies are rightly and fully rustled now... |
Demon of the Fall
01.30.25 | some of these categories make little sense but I can’t argue with results, even if the process was wonky
don’t listen to the naysayers dude, just keeping doing your thing
|
Demon of the Fall
01.30.25 | aren’t you gonna finish your other list tho? |
ThyCrossAwaits
01.30.25 | Yeah after seeing you defend your 5s I dunno how I feel about some of these lol
A lot are better than anything Avenged Sevenfold or All Time Low have ever made ever |
jrlikestodance
01.30.25 | All Time Predators agreed |
NOTINTHEFACE
01.30.25 | Isn't this the guy who continually bleats about genres he doesn't understand/isn't willing to understand bleating about the same albums he's been bleating about all year long?
Yeah, it's him all right. |
CottonSalad
01.30.25 | even though you changed 12, I still agree with what I said before...thanks for that lol |
Demon of the Fall
01.30.25 | Hmm, I now don’t disagree with 12 because I haven’t heard it…
|
jrlikestodance
01.30.25 | Calling 12 pop is a major stretch when it is a modern homage to West Coast hip hop |
bludngorevidal
01.30.25 | Feature this list. Cowards. |
FearThyEvil
01.30.25 | Tundra: Category-Autopilot Continues to vie for peoples attention while condemning great music and then defending the most bland unoriginal artists. |
Ambrosian
01.30.25 | He's not wrong here! |
bellovddd
01.30.25 | lmao. ok bro. nice bait though. No one people don't take you seriously. |
Kusangii
01.30.25 | God damn this list is based as hell |
budgie
01.30.25 | agree 9 & 14 garbage |
budgie
01.30.25 | love that all the ppl who historically call you a troll are the same ones gettin actually upset |
artiswar
01.30.25 | only one I disagree with here is 15. I have no desire for WtR to ever do anything other than what WtR does |
lucazade22
01.30.25 | Agree with all except 7 |
JoyfulPlatypus
01.30.25 | "by all means write another Poppy review to prove it"
Fucking brutal lmao |
Hawks
01.31.25 | Calling 14 garbage is literally so fucking dumb lmao. And the writeup for 8 when you have admitted to knowing fuck all about bm and have written/deleted 97 reviews proving it also is the icing on the cake. You dig yourself into these holes and then cry wolf when wveryone and their mother fucks with you. Its the same cycle over and over and over. I recommend seeing a psychiatrist and get on some good medication, it has done wonders for me. |
ToSmokMuzyki
01.31.25 | wow another trv tvndra list |
ToSmokMuzyki
01.31.25 | God damn this list is based as hell [2] |
GiaNXGX
01.31.25 | 14 was good wdym |
FowlKrietzsche
01.31.25 | Thought this list was based until I saw albums I like and then I realized it was cringe |
DoofDoof
01.31.25 | He hits more than he misses here |
Sharenge
01.31.25 | nice |
pyroflare77
01.31.25 | I mean even if 8 and 14 are good, you kind of have a point. Or rather, if you weren't Tundra you'd have a better point.
Also lol complaining about Opeth's songwriting like that hasn't been an issue for 30 years. |
Demon of the Fall
01.31.25 | 14 is one of the least contentious 'write-ups' here, he literally just said "bored" (okay that's fair) and "autopilot" - harsh, but I can definitely see it because claiming Ulcerate don't have a formula that may sound repetitive or indistinct to some, feels purposefully obtuse |
FearThyEvil
01.31.25 | go figure all those saying based or defending it are some of the worst users with just as bad of taste. Granted, I don't really care about this list as it's expected with Tundra.
Category - indistinct: yeah Counterparts changing their sound is cool on paper, but not when the result ends up being a horribly generic hardcore EP that does nothing to standout in that genre.
This is just ironic at it's core though given you listen to nothing but generic music that every copy cat makes. |
FearThyEvil
01.31.25 | "nice tones of sexism too lol, “it’s this, but a girl” wow kid so thought-out"
but remember, all women are beautiful but only when they meet his expectations |
Hawks
01.31.25 | Tundra has never had a woman. |
brickhed
01.31.25 | honestly kind of funny how every time tundra makes a list he automatically starts a war in the comments, would be even funnier if he wasn't genuine |
ToSmokMuzyki
02.01.25 | fear wouldnt know taste if it licked his calloused face |
efp123
02.01.25 | 6 and 9 fuckin blow |
budgie
02.01.25 | "defending it are some of the worst users with just as bad of taste.
ur mom goes to college! |
Hawks
02.01.25 | Ironic that Smok brings up taste in a Tundra thread considering they're 1A and 1B for worst taste in Sput history. |
ToSmokMuzyki
02.01.25 | fear brought it up
also slapping the highest scores on nearly everything is the opposite of taste |
bach
02.01.25 | “ Category - autopilot: guy could probably record his indescernable growls and make it 2 hrs long and it'd still reach critical acclaim.”
https://youtu.be/L7p_C9OlN40?si=GXkegZAlV1J5ov9l |
Motiv3
02.01.25 | Agreed on 13. |
FearThyEvil
02.01.25 | Smok, you and Tundra have a lot in common actually. You're two of the biggest laughing stocks on this site. Go figure! |
brickhed
02.01.25 | dont know this smok guy but he seems to be projecting based on this info
i've dealt with tundra more personally |
GiaNXGX
02.02.25 | smok has excellent standards |
GiaNXGX
02.02.25 | filosofem can never b a 3, seems like ati-nsbm redditor thing to do |
Hawks
02.02.25 | If excellent means shit then yes. |
ToSmokMuzyki
02.02.25 | fear u genuinely epitomize the most stereotypical core kid there isnt a more stock laughingstock |
budgie
02.02.25 | hey dont b mean |
GiaNXGX
02.02.25 | all women are evil |
GiaNXGX
02.02.25 | could use statistical validation |
GiaNXGX
02.02.25 | — 2 world peace: The Rita |
efp123
02.02.25 | what |
metalphil
02.02.25 | Swap out the Ulcerate album with the latest Blood Incantation |
Hawks
02.02.25 | Tundra is too much of an idiot for that. |
FearThyEvil
02.02.25 | "fear u genuinely epitomize the most stereotypical core kid there isnt a more stock laughingstock"
it's ok to admit you were dropped on your head as a baby. |
ToSmokMuzyki
02.02.25 | nice stock insult can already see what the novel youre currently working on but will never be finished looks like |
GiaNXGX
02.02.25 | found t hottest woman alive, can give link for crypto
telegram [pa/not pensylvania 61468925 |
GiaNXGX
02.02.25 | not a joke, |
Demon of the Fall
02.02.25 | Tundra is playing some of you so bad (it’s hilarious to witness)
the best way to counter this is just to agree with him, or ignore it completely (if that’s how you feel)… he’s feeding off the negative energy
He’s Colin Robinson (no one will get this ref, lol) |
Hawks
02.02.25 | Its fun though Demon!!! :[[[ |
Comatorium.
02.02.25 | Someone dial up daddy t, we need an EO legalizing 80th trimester abortions |