DarkSideOfLucca
05.25.24 | Agalloch was so fucking close to a 6/5 discography, but that damn Serpent album is so much more mid than everything else in their career. RIP
And Cannibal Corpse almost made it but Gore Obsessed and at least one other is pretty meh imo |
Spec
05.25.24 | Cult of Luna and Isis perhaps? |
Ryus
05.25.24 | more like no good albums!
jk but i think the only one i agree with here is 7, colored sands is borderline though |
Spec
05.25.24 | Hard agree with 1, 2, 4, 5 |
DarkSideOfLucca
05.25.24 | I still have to really get into Cult of Luna. Those are one of those bands that's been on my list of shit to jam forever but I never went full into an album undisturbed by them.
Also I just don't really know where to start. |
Spec
05.25.24 | I’d say start with Salvation and listen to it at night. |
FrozenFirebug
05.25.24 | list title would make more sense with any other meshuggah album in obzen's place (except chaosphere or immutable) |
jrlikestodance
05.25.24 | Crowbar are the goats |
Hawks
05.25.24 | Agalloch should count cause Serpent ripz. |
Futures
05.25.24 | emperor |
Uzumaki
05.26.24 | Where Mastodon? |
Hawks
05.26.24 | Mastodon has at least 2 albums that are complete dog shit. |
JohnnyoftheWell
05.26.24 | [2]
6 is an instant DQ for Daughters too |
Hyperion1001
05.26.24 | where’s deicide |
Uzumaki
05.26.24 | Mastodon’s last 2 are close to the “meh” side of anything, as a whole their discog too strong to DQ them from the convo |
cylinder
05.26.24 | Yeah idk about 6, rest is solid tho |
DarkSideOfLucca
05.26.24 | Yeah actually I might replace 6 with someone else
I dont really listen to their first album like ever, and tbh I havent actually listened to them since that story with Alexis Marshall came out - not even once lol |
DarkSideOfLucca
05.26.24 | @Uzumaki - If this was 2009, Mastodon, Gojira and Agalloch would all be on this list
As for Mastodon - The Hunter ruins it for me. It's not terrible or anything, but it certainly ruins a perfect discog |
evilford
05.26.24 | ISIS [2] |
Ryus
05.26.24 | the smiths
arthur russell |
evilford
05.26.24 | Defeated sanity |
DarkSideOfLucca
05.26.24 | Guess I have to check Isis again as well
I havent jammed them since high school which is like a million years ago now - first heard about them when I saw them open up for Tool back in 2006
So ISIS and Cult of Luna are my homework |
cylinder
05.26.24 | Defeated Sanity [2] |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.07.25 | I’ve done my homework and you all were correct
Cult of luna and Isis are annoying as fuck to rank |
Hawks
06.07.25 | Defeated Sanity [3] |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.07.25 | Ugh I’ll jam defeated sanity again after the ocean FINEEEEE |
Hawks
06.07.25 | Good idea!!! |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.07.25 | Ugh I still haven’t heard amenra and Disembowlement and a few others on my list
Damn it |
Scoot
06.07.25 | gorguts |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.07.25 | They’re #7 |
Zac124
06.07.25 | Yeah, Agalloch definitely belongs here. Serpent is definitely their weakest but it ain't bad in the slightest. |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.07.25 | I was thinking about gojira but fortitude bores me
Half of magma is incredible, the other half is underdeveloped ideas |
DarkSideOfLucca
06.08.25 | Had to add converge |
