|
User
Reviews 6
Approval 93%
Soundoffs 54
Album Ratings 678
Objectivity 65%
Last Active 01-05-23 12:08 am
Joined 04-20-18
Review Comments 1,479
| Shadows of Their Former Selves
It was said best in Pet Sematary - "Sometimes they come back" and..."Sometimes dead is better". These are bands that disbanded and reformed; but not near as potent as they once were. | | 1 |  | Orgy
Talk Sick
Great to hear Jay Gordon on the mik again. But, without his original supporting cast, the instrumentals in new Orgy (and this EP) fall pretty flat. | | 2 |  | Powerman 5000
Destroy What You Enjoy
It all comes down to "Anyone for Doomsday?" Talk about a huge mistake - not releasing this album. PM5K was at the top of their game at this time - and then disbanded - and then Spider One rebranded as a shitty punk-influenced band. And PM5K has never been the same ever. | | 3 |  | Guns N' Roses
Hard Skool
Now I admit that I am a fan of Chinese Democracy, understanding that the album is not a GNR album. But taking the dated and leftover songs written by this lineup, and then having Slash and Duff re-record key guitar and bass parts - doesn't work for me. | | 4 |  | Drowning Pool
Resilience
With the revolving door of vocalists - it's hard to take this mainstream band seriously. They certainly have persistence and durability though... | | 5 |  | Ill Nino
Till Death, La Familia
Only one of the OG members remains. So now - the band is anchored by - who, the drummer? Not going to deny that Dave Chavarri lays down some great Latin grooves on drums - but this band no longer makes much sense. | | 6 |  | Queensryche
The Verdict
This is for all the current fans out there. Sorry, no Queensryche w/o Geoff Tate. | | 7 |  | Queens of the Stone Age
Lullabies to Paralyze
Now I will admit - there are some great tracks on this album and "...Like Clockwork". But all in all, none of it touches the prior albums/tracks with Nick Oliveri. Nick brought punk-rock ethic to QOTSA, as well as a varied formula. Recent albums have been 1-D and formulaic. | | 8 |  | Pantera
Far Beyond the Great Southern Cowboys...
Now I enjoyed the reformed Pantera concert. But was it actually Pantera? No, the spector (and absence) of the Abbott brothers looms large over this band. OK with them touring, but don't know if I could buy into a new Pantera album by the current lineup. | | 9 |  | Stone Sour
Hydrograd
I like this album a lot actually. But...it doesn't sound like Stone Sour. More in-line with, but a bit heavier than, Corey Taylor's solo work. Good thing that this band is taking a hiatus - maybe they can regroup in the future with more of the OG members. | |
Butkuiss
11.09.23 | Aside from LC being a QOTSA career highlight I’m not really sure that the absence of noted domestic abuser Nick Oliveri is the reason the band has been floundering in recent years. | Zac124
11.09.23 | I kinda agree with GNR but Hard Skool is a pretty good song ngl. I hope, if they make another album, they are of better quality of the singles they have been releasing recently though. | JDubb
11.09.23 | I'm actually good with the newly formed Fear Factory, Sepultura's current lineup, as well as other bands that have major changes to their main vocalists (e.g., Static-X, Kamelot, Lucid Planet, Nightwish, The Agonist). | JDubb
11.09.23 | @Butkuiss, we do agree they've been floundering. Perhaps it also hurt to lose Dave Grohl - he was great on Songs for the Deaf.
@Zac124 - I don't dislike the new GNR tracks, but they just seem off. Like they are a vintage vehicle mounted on a modern chassis. | Zac124
11.09.23 | Fair. Although Absurd is genuinely awful. | DominionMM1
11.09.23 | 8 is an abomination | Avagantamos
11.09.23 | actually quite terrifying that guns and roses could become worse | JDubb
11.09.23 | @DominionMM1 - the reformed Pantera wasn’t wrong, but it also wasn’t right. Even with the existing members - a lot less energy. | DominionMM1
11.09.23 | its not pantera though. it would be like if david lee roth and michael anthony grabbed a guitarist and drummer not named van halen and toured as van halen. | JDubb
11.09.23 | I hear u. And thats a pretty good comparison. Simply put, no one can replicate/replace Dime and Vinnie. | bellovddd
11.09.23 | lol no idea 3 even happened! | MeatSalad
11.09.23 | Most of these were never good in the first place | Pikazilla
11.09.23 | yeah pantera have always been shite, let's not kid ourselves | mkmusic1995
11.09.23 | I don't mind just about every take here, but Queensryche with Todd is just as good if not better than Geoff Tate Queensryche especially considering how shoddy Tate's voice is now. | Sharenge
11.09.23 | *Sematary | Sabrutin
11.09.23 | Current Queensryche might be a shadow of classic Queensryche, but the recent Digital Noise Alliance album is pretty (mostly) great and surely the best since Promised Land for me | Trebor.
11.09.23 | Pixies is the big one for me | JDubb
11.09.23 | @Sharenge - good catch -revised |
|
