biggzhc
10.23.21 | NiN the greatest band of all time ! my list is only slightly different.
1. The Downward Spiral
2. The Fragile
3. Pretty Hate Machine
4. Year Zero
5. With Teeth
6. The Slip
7. Bad Witch
8. Hesitation Marks
Broken (Ep) would fall between the fragile and PHM. Year Zero grew on me, and the songs on with teeth, like Every Day is... and Love Is Not Enough, You Know What You Are have fallen out of favor, still love the second half of With Teeth though. And songs on Year Zero like Zero Sum, In This Twilight, The Beginning of the End have become better, you know besides the obvious ones. |
goblinilbog
10.24.21 | Good on With Teeth being so high, album gets left on so much in my opinion.
Also, NIN is the greatest band of all time for me. |
Assemblage
10.24.21 | I checked their discog the other day and was surprised they had as little full lengths as they do. It just seemed four or five less than I was expecting and it seems like 80% of their stuff has been around for ages. Not a dig at the band, but I was expecting more that I would be unfamiliar with. |
LeisureMuffin
10.24.21 | Imagine thinking With Teeth is better than The Fragile |
combustion07
10.24.21 | 2,1,4,5,3,6,7,8
Pretty Hate Machine was an album I bought after a really bad breakup and I played that album to death during that time period lol |
teamster
10.24.21 | 4
1
5
6
3
8
7
2
Weird ranking I know. I love The Slip and Year Zero so much.
|
JKing92
10.24.21 | LeisureMuffin, my reasoning behind that is pretty simple -- The Fragile, as terrific as it is in its best moments, runs a bit too long, while With Teeth is a tighter, more focused outing from where I sit. |
CottonSalad
10.24.21 | Downward Spiral is the only record I come back to - it's crazy tho |
Zac124
10.25.21 | 8 should be higher imo but good list |
Pikazilla
10.25.21 | With Teeth over Fragile? Bitch, I don't think so |
ArsMoriendi
10.25.21 | But With Teeth is better
Fragile is too much of a mixed bag, and too long, like yeah there's enough amazing content on there for a 4.5 or 5, but there's also a lot of crap so uh 3.5 it is |
Pikazilla
10.25.21 | Noooooooooooo ars why you got to be like that |
goblinilbog
10.25.21 | Hesitation Marks also is super underrated. |
markjamie
10.30.21 | 1 The Fragile 2 Downward Spiral 3 Ghosts V: Together 4 Pretty Hate Machine 5 Hesitation Marks |
