Jack Mancuso

Reviews 59
Soundoffs 103
News Articles 7
Band Edits + Tags 38
Album Edits 31

Album Ratings 1328
Objectivity 78%

Last Active 06-18-21 10:03 pm
Joined 04-16-12

Forum Posts 43
Review Comments 14,144

05.13.21 YoYo's Excellent Every Time I Die Ranki05.01.21 YoYo's Spicy Sonic Youth Ranking
04.26.21 YoYo's Definitive Dinosaur Jr. Ranking 01.01.21 YoYo's Top 100 Albums of All Time
11.29.20 Let's Argue About Pizza Toppings10.15.20 YoYo Releases an Album
08.01.20 Voodoo by D'Angelo Ranked07.20.20 YoYo Releases a Song
07.10.20 Favorite Songs of the 2000s05.21.20 Recommend Me an Album I Probably Haven'
08.04.14 Weirdest Dream You Ever Had?07.29.14 Ebola Virus
04.18.14 Just Saw The National03.20.14 March Madness
02.02.14 Favorite Drummers

YoYo's Excellent Every Time I Die Ranking

One of the most consistently great bands to ever do it. Hopefully their upcoming album will land high on a future ranking! Also friendly reminder if you disagree that I am correct and you are not.
8Every Time I Die
Last Night in Town

2.5/5. Plenty of good riffs, barely any good songwriting to the point where most of this album sounds like a continuity error. Keith is a far cry from what he would become on this record, and the production also leaves a lot to be desired. Best track: Here’s Lookin’ At You
7Every Time I Die
Gutter Phenomenon

3.5/5. Gutter Phenomenon starts out incredibly strong, but is unable to maintain this brilliance over its entire runtime. Opener “Apocalypse Now and Then” is one of the strongest tracks ETID have ever released, and the first half manages to keep upping the ante with gems like “Bored Stiff” and “Tusk and Temper”. The second half is a bit more homogenous, with several tracks like “Champing At the Bit” or “Guitarred and Feathered” overstaying their welcome by quite a bit. Also is it just me, or is it hard to hear the bass on this one? Best track: Bored Stiff
6Every Time I Die
Ex Lives

3.7/5. “Underwater Bimbos” is one of their best ever, but Ex Lives has always felt like ETID by the numbers to me. Many of the shorter songs feel like blasts of pointless noise, as opposed to briefer songs with compelling structures like “The Marvelous Slut” from NJA. Longer cuts like “Partying Is Such Sweet Sorrow” and “Indian Giver” deliver big time, but the inconsistency of Ex Lives lands it at #6. Also, one of the best songs from these sessions, “Grudge Music”, can only be found on the deluxe version. Best track: Underwater Bimbos From Outer Space
5Every Time I Die
Hot Damn!

3.7/5. Some might be surprised to see this one at number five, but I have my reasons. Hot Damn! Is an astronomical improvement over the underwhelming Last Night In Town, and the band feels like they’re truly in control of their sound for the first time here; listen to the chaos of “Floater” or “Ebolarama” if you don’t believe me. There are still some jarring transitions and tempo changes that don’t always work, usually short slower sections that feel shoehorned in for no reason at all (see the riff towards the end of “Romeo A Go-Go” that sounds like it’s leading to a breakdown, only to immediately go back into fast blast beats for an example). Also, Buckley’s voice has yet to develop here, which hasn’t aged the record well. Still a very enjoyable listen, though. Best track: Floater
4Every Time I Die
The Big Dirty

4/5. Right from the opening moments of “No Son of Mine” it becomes clear that ETID have reinvented themselves as a band with a more controlled and powerful energy, and from a writing standpoint, this might be Keith Buckley at his wittiest. The Big Dirty was the album that proved ETID could maintain consistency over an entire record, rather than just show occasional flashes of genius. Listeners are granted access to some of the band’s most primal moments, like “Pigs Is Pigs” or the jaw-dropping “Rebel Without Applause”. Best track: Pigs Is Pigs
3Every Time I Die
New Junk Aesthetic

4.7/5. NJA is where Every Time I Die finally realized their full potential. Sporting newly improved production and a tracklist that flows smooth as butter, New Junk Aesthetic would likely be any lesser band’s greatest work ever. This was a rapid evolution of both the band’s harder and softer sides. Opener “Roman Holiday” sees the group slow it down to a grind and sit in the pain, while “Wanderlust” and “White Smoke” boast addictive vocal stacks that illustrate Keith’s marked improvement since his earlier days. NJA also introduced drummer Ryan Leger, whose highly musical playing helps him turn in a performance to remember. Best track: Wanderlust
2Every Time I Die
From Parts Unknown

5/5. From Parts Unknown has only one item on its agenda; pure, unbridled ferocity. Masterfully produced by Kurt Ballou, FPU is easily Every Time I Die’s most punishing album, containing astonishingly heavy moments like “Exometrium” or the unbelievable “Idiot”. Even token slower cut “Moor” packs a heavy emotional punch, only to match that energy with its massive second half. The band manages to keep songs on the shorter side but still give them all their own unique identities; just look at how “Thirst” packs more into a 90-second window than most bands can fit into a 4-minute song. Best track: Idiot
1Every Time I Die
Low Teens

5/5. Somehow the album with the highest Sputnik average seems to have the most vocal haters, but I’m certainly not one of them. Low Teens was an absolute triumph for ETID, not only because of its revelatory lyrical content, but also because of all the risks that were taken from a songwriting perspective. The band have never been more accessible to a non-metal audience than they are on “Two Summers” and “It Remembers”, and despite having their fair share of detractors, these tracks succeed in my eyes and show that the band can still kill it outside of their comfort zone. Also on display are their two most impressive epics, “Religion of Speed” and “Map Change”, the latter of which functions as the album’s emotional apex and cements Low Teens as my #1 pick. Best track: Map Change
Show/Add Comments (8)


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy