DarkSideOfLucca
10.22.18 | Don't cancel this series pls thanksssss |
Divaman
10.22.18 | Agreed. Best Marvel Netflix series yet. |
bloc
10.22.18 | Wtf it's out already?? Sweet |
necropig
10.22.18 | I don't think it will get cancelled, is it not cus disney are doing their own streaming soon so talk of it all going there? (according to friends) |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.22.18 | "Agreed. Best Marvel Netflix series yet."
100% man, there were SO many amazing scenes that I lost track after a while. The finale had one of the coolest moments I've seen in any comic show/movie tbh
@bloc - it came out Friday, I just binged it. Will probably rewatch it with my friends sometime after Halloween. It fucking rules, which is something I needed after the past several shitty Netflix seasons.
As of now, this is my favorite season - I really hope Punisher season 2 takes that place, though.
@necro- Ah, that's good news. Canceling Luke Cage and Iron Fist has made me worried about this universe. |
SitarHero
10.22.18 | So. Fucking. Good.
Luke Cage season 2 was really good too, even though it had a super ambiguous ending. |
artiswar
10.22.18 | I'm halfway through S3 and really impressed. S2 started very strong but shit the bed in the second half. I'm so glad the show is back on track and doing what it does best: Focusing on Vincent D'Onofrio and doing long hallway fight scenes. |
SitarHero
10.22.18 | Daredevil consistently smokes the other Marvel shows for 3 reasons:
1. Better villain(s).
2. Better secondary characters.
3. Much MUCH better action. Holy shit. Only Punisher comes close. |
Dewinged
10.22.18 | I'm mid S2, can't wait to see what's going on in S3, I'm hearing only great things about it lately. |
artiswar
10.22.18 | I honestly slept through the second half of Daredevil S2 it was so dull. Also forgot everything that happened in The Defenders because it was so bad, so I actually forget what happened to Elektra which is a bummer. |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.22.18 | @Sitar - I actually haven't seen season 2 of Luke Cage, I'm gonna start it tonight
@art - agreed about Season 2 man, thankfully season 3 keeps up the quality throughout m/ And yeah, when Defenders was first announced (around DD season 1 time) I was fucking pumpeddddd and am still upset about how shitty that turned out to be. |
Rowan5215
10.23.18 | yeah this is the best season of any of the marvel shows, I'm still amazed that they managed to not only go back to s1 quality but actually top it. that Karen and Fisk scene fuck my fucking life |
artiswar
10.23.18 | I was really into Jessica Jones too for like 5 episodes before it got really stupid. Like all of the Netflix marvel shows are pure trash imo. Daredevil had a rough patch but it's always been 100 miles ahead of its contemporaries. They're taking material that was attempted on film years ago to horrible effect, and actually doing it justice. It's remarkable really. I'm a bit biased because I'm bored senseless by superhero shit but this shit is goooooood. |
XingKing
10.23.18 | Daredevil is the crowning achievement of the MCU, IMO. And yes, that Karen/Fisk scene was so unbelievably intense. I had to rewatch it a few times before moving on because Karen's metaphorical knife twisting was so. fucking. satisfying. |
SitarHero
10.23.18 | My Netflix rankings.
Tier 1 - Great: Daredevil 1, Daredevil 3, Jessica Jones 1, First half of Luke Cage 1
Tier 2 - Good: The Punisher, Luke Cage 2
Tier 3 - Okay: Daredevil 2
Tier 4 - Boring: Iron Fist 1, Iron Fist 2, Defenders
Tier 5 - Aggressively Awful: Jessica Jones 2, Second half of Luke Cage 1 |
Dewinged
10.23.18 | I enjoyed Jessica Jones S2, although I can see it was pretty dumb compared to the Killgrave arc. |
artiswar
10.23.18 | First half of Daredevil S2 with The Punisher and that first chunk of the Elektra stuff was fucking gold though. Just the boring ninja shit in the second half can go fuck itself. |
artiswar
10.23.18 | The Killgrave arc in JJ was mostly dogshit so I can't imagine how bad S2 was, so glad I skipped it. |
SitarHero
10.23.18 | The main storyline in JJ2 was okay, but every other storyline was completely shite and the whole thing was as tedious as Iron Fist. |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.23.18 | @Xing - Daredevil is definitely the best, but I actually really enjoyed the Punisher a lot. I know people gave it shit, but I fucking loved it. First half of Luke Cage season 1 ruled, Jessica Jones pacing was shit but I thought it had a lot of great moments and a phenomenal villain, and all of Iron Fist was terrible.
@art - yeah those subplots of Jessica Jones were REALLY rough lol. I mean I guess I'm not superhero fatigued because I spent my entire childhood in the 90s and early 2000s dreaming of a world where we would have movies like Iron Man, Avengers, Dark Knight, Logan, this Daredevil series, etc where most of these characters are actually given justice on screen so as long as they do them justice I'll probably never get bored of the genre
@Sitar - Tier 1 for me is DD season 1 and 3 and The Punisher. Jessica Jones, DD Season 2 and first half of Luke Cage are tier 2 - dont give a fuck about the rest |
SitarHero
10.23.18 | Artiswar nailed DD2. The first half with The Punisher was great but it got really boring after that.
Luke Cage 1 was great until they killed off Cottonmouth because he was the most sympathetic villain/antihero (until that point, even moreso than Fisk) and it really did bring out the conundrum of a hero who is really good at punching stuff facing problems that he couldn't simply punch. Then they killed him off and replaced him with that fucking Diamondback dude. |
SitarHero
10.23.18 | Also, shout out to Daredevil for being probably THE most accurate legal drama on TV. |
artiswar
10.23.18 | It's amazing to have all these Superheros on TV (If you told me in the 90s I would have laughed) but just hire better writers man. Just cause it's comic-based doesn't mean it has to be mediocre. |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.23.18 | Agreed, artiswar.
It took Thor 3 movies to make a great movie - all you need are some competent workers who care about the material. |
ExhaleTheLight
10.23.18 | Daredevil upped the ante here. Reason why the back half of season 2 sucked was the lack of a good villain. Fisk is awesome |
artiswar
10.23.18 | Yes but Dex is also a fucking compelling-ass villain. He reminds me of The Red Dragon from the final season of Hannibal (he also weirdly resembles Mads Mikkelsen). I'm loving his character so much right now. |
Rowan5215
10.23.18 | Karen (the ep) absolutely stole the #1 spot of these netflix shows imo
Self Control's still on top for overall Marvel tho |
XingKing
10.23.18 | The flashback portion of Karen is actually one of the only real missteps of season 3 for me. I have no problem with learning more about Karen and it was a compelling story, but I do have a problem with an extended flashback absolutely ruining the beautifully crafted momentum the season had built up until that episode. I'm not sure where the flashback would have been better placed, but it sure as hell should not have been placed where it was. |
dimsim3478
10.23.18 | i loved this new season but it wasn't thaaaaat good y'all. tons of unnecessary bs but the main conflict was strong enuf to keep it together right up to episode 12 (last episode was pretty shaky but stuck the landing more or less).
"Dex is also a fucking compelling-ass villain."
actor did a good job but they built dex's entire arc on his childhood trauma and 1) that trauma was shallow to the point of being meaningless (like oooooh his parents and therapist died and that makes him craaaaazy ooooooh so deeeeep) and 2) that trauma was portrayed onscreen in a flat and distractingly pretentious manner (fisk walkin thru the flashback + that one scene with the two spotlights made me lol). like fisk in comparison is not *that* deep of a character but his portrayal is so immediately distinct and his childhood flashback was pretty memorable. i will say that dex's particular issues made for decent plotting, though; like how he manages to get on decent footing with julie so the audience gets just a little glimpse of hope before it's unceremoniously ripped away (would've liked to see more of dex and julie, just to get a bit more of a dramatic build towards his inevitable downfall).
shouts out to ray for being a pretty compelling secondary character; too bad they didnt give him a sendoff in the final episode and instead gave the obligatory funeral sequence to that priest guy
also totally worth highlighting that little "woman in refrigerator" detail ;) |
Divaman
10.23.18 | Vincent D'Onofrio was amazing once again. |
Rowan5215
10.23.18 | "that trauma was shallow to the point of being meaningless (like oooooh his parents and therapist died and that makes him craaaaazy ooooooh so deeeeep)"
I think you kinda missed the point here my dude, it's made pretty clear he was just a psychopath before any of that even happened and all the subsequent stuff just taught him the skills to hide that side of him in public. like the way he integrates the "i'm sorry that must be really hard" into his life is pretty goddamn unnerving. it's an anti-origin story where the traumatic events aren't a catch-all explanation for it all and I like that
"shouts out to ray for being a pretty compelling secondary character; too bad they didnt give him a sendoff in the final episode and instead gave the obligatory funeral sequence to that priest guy"
he was a great character but his testimony forms the backbone of like the entire last episode. the priest was a) a father figure to Matt his entire life and b) a character since season 1, they kinda did the obvious thing there |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.23.18 | " think you kinda missed the point here my dude, it's made pretty clear he was just a psychopath before any of that even happened and all the subsequent stuff just taught him the skills to hide that side of him in public. " [2] Was just about to say that.
I loved everything with Bullseye. They actually gave him a compelling backstory instead of the comics which were just like "he's an assassin that just likes to murder people I guess"
"he was a great character but his testimony forms the backbone of like the entire last episode." [2] Yet another point I was about to make. Rowan is killing it in this thread. |
Rowan5215
10.23.18 | lucca I did it all to make amends for our recent disagreements on horror movies < 3 |
SitarHero
10.23.18 | The biggest strength of Daredevil is how interesting the non-Murdock characters are.
The "woman in refrigerator" should totally have been done a different way though. |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.23.18 | @Rowan - < 3 |
ExhaleTheLight
10.23.18 | Punisher also does good with the Non-Frank characters, Micro, Russo, Madani |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.23.18 | Agreed hard, Exhale. Love The Punisher. |
Divaman
10.23.18 | My only real problem with the series (and I understand that for economic reasons it can't be helped) is the shared universe problem. We've already established that these characters don't exist in a vacuum. So if this were real life:
1. If Karen believes she is going to be hunted down and killed by Kingpin, doesn't she try to find some way to contact her other friend, Frank Castle, for help?;
2. If Foggy believes he is in danger of being assassinated, doesn't he maybe try to hire his new bulletproof buddy Luke Cage to kind of stand next to him when he's giving press conferences, etc.?; and, of course
3. When everything is going to shit, and Daredevil thinks he and the people that he loves will probably be killed, doesn't he reach out to the rest of his friends in The Defenders, and say, "Hey guys, guess what? I'm not dead, but I could really use some help."? |
TheNotrap
10.23.18 | I've been watching Season 1 these last few weeks and I've been enjoying it. The fight scenes are pretty cool and the characters are well-crafted. Good casting. |
artiswar
10.23.18 | @Divaman I choose to pretend The Defenders never happened and I think the characters do too. |
ExhaleTheLight
10.23.18 | Honestly the only shared universe I would like to see consistent are Punisher and Daredevil's worlds. Both characters are synonymous with each other in the comics so why can't we have that same consistency on TV. |
artiswar
10.23.18 | Yeah I would not mind having Punisher come in for an episode, or even Jessica Jones. |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.23.18 | Yeah, the lack of the Punisher this season was very noticeable. There were many scenes (especially involving Karen) where I was thinking "Wait, where the fuck is Frank in this scenario?" Also, his little thing with Kingpin in season 2 of DD when he was like "the next time I see you, one of us is not walking out alive" or whatever. They built that up perfectly for a confrontation here. It makes no sense. |
ExhaleTheLight
10.23.18 | That callback to season 2 of DD with Fisk and Castle pretty much means Fisk will turn up during season 2 of Punisher at some point I hope. |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.23.18 | I hope, but what about Karen?
Season 2 of DD and season 1 of the Punisher basically kept hammering home that Frank has some obsession with her - if she was in as much danger as she was throughout season 2, it doesn't make any sense that he wouldn't have stepped in and gone on a massive killing spree to protect her. |
ExhaleTheLight
10.23.18 | The showrunners did not want these characters in this season from a story standpoint. They wanted us to see Matt struggle. From a logical standpoint however that notion is balls stupid. |
artiswar
10.23.18 | It really irks me when they cross-over characters and then refuse to do so for artificial reasons. However if Punisher was in this season I think he would murder Dex pretty quick and there'd be no story. |
ExhaleTheLight
10.23.18 | Yo what if Dex ends up in the same hospital as Billy Russo? |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.23.18 | "The showrunners did not want these characters in this season from a story standpoint. "
Yeah, I get it but it's just creating such a massively annoying plothole. Agreed that it's balls stupid.
"However if Punisher was in this season I think he would murder Dex pretty quick and there'd be no story."
Lmao, I dunno - I could see them both trying to murder each other for a while, but continuous getting into stalemates since they're both such insane shots.
"Yo what if Dex ends up in the same hospital as Billy Russo?"
I would fucking cheer. |
Divaman
10.23.18 | It's a small complaint, though. I really loved DD Season 3, and the climax in episode 13 was pretty great. |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.23.18 | Oh yeah man, I mean I would give this season a fucking 10. Loved every minute of it, I just missed my boy Frank and thought that considering the characters involved, this would have been the perfect opportunity for him to jump in. But alas.
Also yeah, the climax of ep 13 was the coolest shit I've ever seen. |
artiswar
10.23.18 | I love the fact that he doesn't have the costume for an entire season, and he doesn't even wear it this season. Same goes with Punisher. A lesser show would just have them in their outfits right away but they actually tie the costumes in thematically and make them relevant to the story which is some next level shit.
And Dex reminds me a lot of The Red Dragon from the final season of Hannibal. If any of you haven't watched it, it's basically the best show of all time. Anyway, I have 2 episodes to go so thanks for not spoiling me too much guys. |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.23.18 | Hannibal fucking rules, agreed. Bring back season 4 pls
And no problem, art |
artiswar
10.23.18 | 'Give me your jacket'
lmao what a guy... |
artiswar
10.23.18 | I'm really not enjoying American Gods at all, kinda hope it gets canned soon and we can get another Hannibal season. |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.23.18 | 'Give me your jacket'
YOOOOOO
That scene rules.
Haven't started American Gods but my cousins are trying to get me to watch it. |
artiswar
10.23.18 | I love how he remains patient and composed for the first part of that scene haha.
And American Gods is super frustrating because it's aesthetically brilliant and has moments of genius but just doesn't work as a whole and I find the majority of the characters really unlikable. The show just has no heart, it just feels really cold and clinical in a way Hannibal never was. |
SitarHero
10.23.18 | American Gods is shite and the showrunner has quit. I felt a fair bit of dissonance because it strays from the path of the book, but yeah, most of the characters are pretty damn unlikable. |
artiswar
10.23.18 | Oh I didn't know that, that's great news. It looks like his next project is adapting Interview With The Vampire which sounds fucking AWESOME. But I'm a bit bitter that he seems to be moving away from Hannibal considering he's been pretty adamant about revisiting it. |
Underflow
10.23.18 | This is the best season of Daredevil yet. |
artiswar
10.23.18 | First season was definitely better. |
Underflow
10.23.18 | Nah, this is the first season that actually needed to be 13 episodes. |
artiswar
10.23.18 | It was very good, I'll give you that. I wish there was one more fight scene like the one in episode 4, but at least there were no ninjas this time. |
XingKing
10.23.18 | S3's story also moves at a monstrous pace for the whole season. The story never stops moving forward and escalating. |
dimsim3478
10.24.18 | "it's an anti-origin story where the traumatic events aren't a catch-all explanation for it all and I like that"
you're right from a plot-analysis point-of-view but i'm speaking to how interesting bullseye was as a character, and how much his backstory added to the character. so i stand by my contention that 1) the flashback failed to make the character more interesting/distinct and 2) it was boring in itself. the backstory did set up a lot of character traits for dex that helped to drive the plot, but that didnt make *the character* more interesting. in the end, the character of dex just felt as simple as "he's a psycho", or at best, "he's a psycho that's tryna hide it" (which also isnt that interesting). like they could have just portrayed him as "he's an assassin that just likes to murder people I guess" as lucca said, completely skipping any backstory, and it woulda amounted to just as interesting of a character. so my point is that all the backstory and the amount of present day plot that tied into the backstory felt like it was tryna get you invested in the character but in the end there wasn't any payoff; dex just turned out as a by-the-numbers psycho.
the only time that i felt they were doing something genuinely interesting with his character was when we were seeing him pullin back from the psychopathy by gettin on good terms with julie, but that ended really quickly.
"he was a great character but his testimony forms the backbone of like the entire last episode."
obviously, again from a plot cause-and-effect point of view, but that doesnt make up for the absence of his character in the last episode or the lack of closure for one of the most compelling arcs in the season. i think the season failed to acknowledge and capitalise on the meaning in his death by adding a bit of reflection on it into the last episode; just feels like he kinda gets swept under the rug. |
artiswar
10.24.18 | He's nowhere near as interesting as Fisk but I really liked him as a villain. He was definitely more fleshed out than psychopathic characters like that tend to be. Also really liked him wearing the Daredevil suit this season, he was super menacing in it. |
dimsim3478
10.24.18 | nothin quite like a superhero fighting a villain who reflects them in some way; part of why the bulletin fight scene was so effective |
artiswar
10.24.18 | That fight had me on pins and needles when he just started throwing shit. Poor Matt getting stabbed with them scissors. |
XingKing
10.24.18 | I'm sorry, that must be really hard |
dimsim3478
10.24.18 | would've been mildly amusing if they repurposed that line for one of his rampages. like he stabs matt with scissors and goes "I'm sorry, that must be really hard" |
XingKing
10.24.18 | I thought it was hilarious every time he repeated that line. Using it in the way you suggested would've just been the cherry on top |