TheSpaceMan
09.01.18 | Melee, rest are garbage |
TheCharmingMan
09.01.18 | U need ADD medication to play melee lol |
Slex
09.01.18 | 6 will always always a l w a y s be last yeah |
Source
09.01.18 | Never played this series tbh |
sonictheplumber
09.01.18 | ive only played the first 3 i forget its like the led zeppelin of games or some shit now |
sonictheplumber
09.01.18 | i know so many retards who do smash tournaments and shit |
mrdogthrow
09.01.18 | So hyped for Ultimate. Mainly because I get my ICE CLIMBERS BACK |
nol
09.01.18 | ADD meds to play melee [2] |
0xME
09.01.18 | "Melee, rest are garbage"
while Melee is obviously the best by a landslide, every entry of the series has its place (yes, even brawl - Subspace Emissary was a lot of fun) |
necropig
09.01.18 | I prefer Garfield kart |
tellah
09.02.18 | Brawl isn't even THAT bad it's just (other than Subspace) WHY play it when there is Smash 4, all the other games have their individual strengths over it |
Slex
09.02.18 | Subspace is phenomenal but dear godddddd the fighting is miserably sluggish in Brawl |
CaliggyJack
09.02.18 | Smash is a party game tho |
ArsMoriendi
09.02.18 | Half of the love for Melee is nostalgia and people who like that you can exploit glitches. It's a great game anyway if you try to account for those biases, but I like the current Smash more overall. High hopes for Smash Ultimate being even better
4 > 2 > 1 > 6 > 5
I have high hopes for the new one |
Slex
09.02.18 | I agree that 4 is the best tbh |
RadioheadIsOverrated
09.02.18 | 4 is 1 |
ramon.
09.02.18 | List is correct. Wish project m was a little more active. Fully understand people’s gripes with Melee’s comp scene but goddamn it’s so fucking sick. Hyped for Ultimate too. |
tellah
09.02.18 | pro Melee sets are pretty hype to watch as long as they aren't Fox mirror matches.
@ramon agreed completely, also playing Ivy in Project M is so blessed |
rodrigo90
09.02.18 | Real men plays king of fighters or marvel vs capcom. super smash bros is for pussies. |
Slex
09.02.18 | Shut the fuck up lmao |
Saros
09.02.18 | Brawl is the weakest Smash but it still has some highlights. For anyone interested I highly recommend Scott the Woz's video on Brawl. He gives a good neutral viewpoint on it without completely bashing it or praising it. He also manages to still be entertaining while doing it, even for a gaming-centered Youtube guy. |
Get Low
09.02.18 | PM is fucking garbage. Brawl will always my second fave after Melee. |
tellah
09.02.18 | fair enough I mean the random tripping mechanics are groundbreaking and amazing |
ramon.
09.02.18 | Kinda agree tellah, though I think Fox dittos have potential to turn into dbz fests in very specific contexts. It’s no fox falco though.
Scott is a lame ass but I agree. Brawl is a fantastic game if you play it for what it is.
Interesting opinion, GetLow. Curious to know why? I don’t see why anyone would play it for any reason other than to get into comp smash but as a comp smash title, it’s pretty slick imo. |
ramon.
09.02.18 | Take: brawl’s main theme is the best in the series |
Saros
09.02.18 | I've heard the Brawl theme so much it's probably burned in my brain until the end of time, so it's definitely got it in lasting power. |
ramon.
09.02.18 | O M E L E T T E
P R E V A I L |
GreyShadow
09.02.18 | Brawl is way more fun than 64 and I personally find more fun in it than Melee despite it being broken.
4 is my favorite (Greninja main, Lucina secondary), then PM. Ultimate is gonna be the best, I'm almost sure of it. |
Get Low
09.02.18 | "Interesting opinion, GetLow. Curious to know why? I don’t see why anyone would play it for any reason other than to get into comp smash but as a comp smash title, it’s pretty slick imo."
I'm actually not sure if this is geared toward PM or Brawl, since I mentioned both. |
Get Low
09.02.18 | Oh, I think you were asking about my Brawl opinion. I just think the game is fun af. Competitive for it is still fun if you play Metaknight, which I do. |
ramon.
09.02.18 | Used to main lucina when the game dropped, eventually moved over to pika and falcon yea. Lucina is dope.
Oh sorry, I meant PM. I love brawl. Personally dislike the comp meta being dominated by one character though but fair enough. |
Get Low
09.02.18 | PM feels terrible to me. It definitely feels like a mod made by non-professionals as opposed to an actual game. Feels and plays nothing like Melee, which is what it's intention was. Every actual good PM player I ever played against just camped. |
SteakByrnes
09.02.18 | 1. 4 (mains are Fox and Sonic with pocket Marth/Cloud)
2. Melee (mains Falco, Fox, and Marth)
3. PM (Fox and Marth)
4. 64 (Pikachu)
5. Brawl (Fox/Wolf, Marth, and Cap Falcon) |
ArsMoriendi
09.02.18 | N64: Ness
Melee: Peach, Ness
Project Melee: Peach, Ness
Brawl: idk haven't played it in years, maybe Ike? I played as Ike a lot when I was 12
Sm4sh: King Dedede, Peach, Ness |
Cygnatti
09.02.18 | PM is amazing, greatly prefer it to melee tbh.
Brawl is secretly good too. Smash 4 is best game. honestly all games are amaze. |
Cygnatti
09.02.18 | daily reminder that L-Cancelling and Wave Dashing were either on the melee website or in the manual -> they're not glitches at all. |
ramon.
09.02.18 | Would love to play PM more.
I feel just as many gripes come from the fact only a handful of stages are viable, bar a couple of outliers very little of the cast is played at a high level, and the current tournament meta requires mods to compensate for controller issues.
Oh and for game mains, I’m a melee falcon main with a falco secondary, a PM g&w main, a smash 4 pika/falcon, probably a brawl snake though I haven’t played it much, and a 64 pika |
Slex
09.02.18 | Falcon main for Melee, Fox for 64, Metaknight/Pit for Brawl, Sonic/Ryu main with pocket Cloud for Smash 4 |
Cygnatti
09.02.18 | wym? PM has way more character diversity than brawl and melee at the top level. everyone of the top 10 PM players have unique characters.
unless you mean melee not PM. melee is in a v cool spot rn imo. |
ramon.
09.02.18 | shit yea I meant melee haha I’m fucking vague as hell, the fact PM has been dominated by a DK expands my dong
yea I love melee’s current state, just doesn’t surprise me people don’t like it. there’s what, 10 different characters in the top 15? Diversity has been stronk these last few years |
TheSpaceMan
09.02.18 | To whoever said melee isn't shit compared to the rest of the FGC
lol |
Typhoon24
09.02.18 | melee #1 woo, falco main since 2007 |
DadJokes
09.02.18 | Whatever Tellah you old fart, try to cast Meteo without dying maybe then I'll listen to you |
MarsKid
09.02.18 | Project M #1, Melee fans just don't like their precious furries getting nerfed |
ramon.
09.02.18 | id probably agree with you if I had more people to play project m with rip
the aussie project m scene is about as populous as the society for tuvalu breakcore |
MarsKid
09.02.18 | Yeah, Ohio's scene is dried up too, unfortunately. |
SteakByrnes
09.02.18 | Only real ones remember how busted Mewtwo used to be in PM |
oneups
09.02.18 | Samus and Young Link main in melee. You could call me a masochist I guess, haha. Really the best of the series, though I'm tentatively looking forward to Ultimate. |
MarsKid
09.02.18 | I remember the days when Pit was a fucking monster
Then he got absolutely decimated by nerfs. |
Rik VII
09.02.18 | Melee - Kirby, Fox, Roy
Brawl - Kirby, Wolf, Ike
Smash 4 - Lucina, Kirby, Toon Link |
Slex
09.02.18 | Damn really holding it down for Kirby lol |
ramon.
09.03.18 | Melee Kirby on Brinstar is essentially S tier |
Veldin
09.03.18 | Sage Tellah? Nice! FFIV is one of my favorites |
Zig
09.03.18 | Melee is the best for sure. |
Cygnatti
09.03.18 | i get why melee people dont like PM, because it plays differently even tho it's "similar". imo i much rather play PM because it's much easier to move for me.
also fox barely got nerfed whatsoever, the problem with PM is that every character in the game is specifically designed to fight vs fox which is kinda bad design tbh. |
theacademy
09.03.18 | this is like ranking the alphabet in alphabetical order bitch haha of course this is the order who would ever disagree lmao |
tellah
09.03.18 | sheesh sorry was gone for a hot minute
@DadJokes username checks out
@oneups I love playing Samus in Melee and PM but I'm horrible with her
@Cygnatti It's similar enough for me to enjoy I guess (I'm a scrub) |