DarkSideOfLucca
10.10.17 | Shit, I have too many. I may have to make some of these 4.5's. |
porcupinetheater
10.10.17 | Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds discog is like half 5 |
theBoneyKing
10.10.17 | I only have three currently: Radiohead (4), The National (3), and Wilco (2). Together they make up almost a third of my 5s. |
Rik VII
10.10.17 | Opeth (2), Kamelot (2), Dir En Grey (3).
A band shouldn't be able to pull off more than one 5 in their career, it's basically against reason, but it is still possible obviously. |
theNateman
10.10.17 | Everything the beach boys released between '66 and '71 is a 5 |
Kalopsia
10.10.17 | "I usually don't like 5ing more than one album in a band's discography"
why? if a band does and you think they do, then they do. is there some rule a band can only ever have one 5-rated album? who cares?
Alice in Chains (2) - Jar of Flies, Dirt
Coheed and Cambria (2) - In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3, From Fear Through the Eyes of Madness
Fair to Midland (2) - Fables from a Mayfly, Arrows & Anchors
Metallica (2) - Master of Puppets, Black Album |
bgillesp
10.10.17 | Thats a lot of 5s. I only have Bjork and Devin Townsend with multiple 5s, but I have several with 3-4 4.5s |
AsleepInTheBack
10.10.17 | damn dude yeah you have lots of 5s.
I only have one - Frank Turner with 2. |
kris.
10.10.17 | btmi! and coheed bruv |
DoofusWainwright
10.10.17 | Lambchop/Radiohead/The National/Tiger Lillies [4 each]
Tindersticks/Nirvana/Bowie/Robert Wyatt/The Residents [2 each]
Can maybe see Pink Floyd get another 5 soon, ‘Piper’ is growing on me |
cold
10.10.17 | "I usually don't like 5ing more than one album in a band's discography"
why? if a band does and you think they do, then they do. is there some rule a band can only ever have one 5-rated album? who cares? [2] |
butcherboy
10.10.17 | i've got a whole bunch with multiple 4.5's (The Fall, Tindersticks, Mingus, Tom Waits, Radiohead, Art Blakey, Pavement etc.) But Bowie is the only one I have two 5's for.. |
SandwichBubble
10.10.17 | I have 3 Crass albums 5'd, and it's getting a bit crowded in my classics section |
cold
10.10.17 | Hope you 5'ed dat Christ The Album |
DungeonBoy
10.10.17 | Agalloch and Opeth for sure. |
GreyShadow
10.10.17 | personnel - AFI - Black Sails through STS, La Dispute - Somewhere and Wildlife
Maiden - Powerslave and The Number of The Beast is something I think many would agree on |
Minushuman24
10.10.17 | ^ I think that's the only band I have currently with two 5's |
Kompys2000
10.10.17 | Lol at 11, Manson's aight but none of his albums are a 5.
For me, the Flaming Lips have at least 2 5s (Soft Bulletin and Yoshimi), and Modest Mouse has exactly 2 (LCW and TM&A). |
smaugman
10.10.17 | objectively, several for me, but i try to limit my 5s, even though i shouldnt |
SandwichBubble
10.10.17 | @coldheaven nah that's one of 2 Crass 4.5s for me ;) |
cold
10.10.17 | Manson has at least 2 albums that are solid 5's |
Rik VII
10.10.17 | Manson has probably 2 albums that are solid 3s ;) |
cold
10.10.17 | @greyshadow it's nice to see some Somewhere At The Bottom love |
SandwichBubble
10.10.17 | Manson has probably 2 albums that are solid 2.5s ;) agreed |
butcherboy
10.10.17 | Manson has albums.. that fact is inarguable.. |
Rik VII
10.10.17 | Manson has a.. |
SandwichBubble
10.10.17 | That's debatable |
Rik VII
10.10.17 | Or has he?
Edit: Hah, beat me |
butcherboy
10.10.17 | Hanson also have.. |
cold
10.10.17 | HmmBop bby |
SandwichBubble
10.10.17 | I was responding to butch, but that works better lol |
Avagantamos
10.10.17 | I gave a 5 star rating to 5 albums by the electronic music duo Autechre. Gorguts have a couple 5 star albums too. |
butcherboy
10.10.17 | Ted Danson may or may not have a.. |
SandwichBubble
10.10.17 | Krabs is a... |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.10.17 | Antichrist is a strong 5 and I'm standing by that |
cold
10.10.17 | Antichrist is a strong 5 and I'm standing by that [2]
Also Mechanical Animals. Holywood is insanely close, but it's a 4.5 |
Tundra
10.10.17 | Between the Buried and Me - Colors and Parallax |
cold
10.10.17 | Between the Buried and Me - Colors and Parallax [2]
And Alaska! |
Drifter
10.10.17 | Snoop Dogg |
butcherboy
10.10.17 | Goop Snogg |
neekafat
10.10.17 | qotsa
a7x (probably not for much longer)
Dixie Chicks
Peter Gabriel
TV on the Radio (one's an EP tho)
Brand New |
onionbubs
10.10.17 | alkaline trio |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.10.17 | "Goop Snogg" [2] |
Demon of the Fall
10.10.17 | These all have 2...
QOTSA
Opeth
Death
65daysofstatic
Radiohead
Next closest are Sigur Ros, Converge, Agalloch, At the Drive-In & Cult of Luna (they all have one 5 & one or more 4.5 that's happens to be a borderline 5). |
AlexKzillion
10.10.17 | 3 Metallica (RTL through AJFA)
3 Deftones (WP, DE, Koi)
Kendrick (TPAB and DAMN.)
Lorde (the only two albums she's put out)
This accounts for 10/21 of my 5s
Also used to have two Kanye 5s
|
Conmaniac
10.10.17 | tame impala |
Drifter
10.10.17 | Snoop Dogg has a minimum of 3 5s |
SandwichBubble
10.10.17 | maximum of 1 3.5 more like drifter |
Chortles
10.10.17 | my god. . . . . ..... |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.10.17 | @chortles- What? Too many 5's? |
Confessed2005
10.10.17 | Pig Destroyer's PitY and Terrifyer are both 5's for me. |
Chortles
10.10.17 | nahhhh i was mostly just sad about btbam and some others in the comments. ur good br0 |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.10.17 | m/ |
Kompys2000
10.11.17 | Can't believe no one's said Brand New yet
I mean IMO they only have one 5 but... |
neekafat
10.11.17 | "maximum of 1 3.5 more like drifter" [2]
@Kompys, I did... |
Ryus
10.11.17 | "Snoop Dogg has a minimum of 3 5s"
snoop dogg is still shit sorry pal |
Ryus
10.11.17 | my bloody valentine, boards of canada, and m a y b e talk talk are the only groups that deserve two 5s in my eyes |
Kompys2000
10.11.17 | Ah dammit, I gotta read the comments more carefully... |
Chortles
10.11.17 | "my bloody valentine, boards of canada, and m a y b e talk talk are the only groups that deserve two 5s in my eyes"
fukn 5 spirit of eden already i bet u wont |
Dewinged
10.11.17 | Maiden and Bjork for me, and Neurosis probably. |
tempest--
10.11.17 | judas priest |
StrikeOfTheBeast
10.11.17 | JP and Black Sabbath for more than one five for sure. 1, 9, 12, and 14 possibly. |
ShaquilleONeal
10.11.17 | Can you explain why you 5'd 2 of 11's albums? I'm not trying to bash you or anything, maybe your perception of him will help me appreciate him more. |
Relinquished
10.11.17 | hard facts on 2 |
superluminals
10.11.17 | Pls refer to me as snoop lion |
CaimanJesus
10.11.17 | I only have 1 band: Cult of Luna with 2 |
Drifter
10.11.17 | "Snoop Dogg (The Band)"
Lmaooooooooo |
MyNameIsPencil
10.11.17 | blue album and pinkerton |
Spacesh1p
10.11.17 | Brian Eno if you count his solo and collaborative work. |
ZippaThaRippa
10.11.17 | There are no bands with any 5s |
Rigma
10.11.17 | sufjan and mwY |
MyNameIsPencil
10.11.17 | good picks Rigma |
hasan
10.11.17 | to be a score of 5 points out of 5 on the page... tool more like 5 years when we see another CD LOL |
Kompys2000
10.11.17 | Not gonna lie,the first Meshuggah is the only one I really enjoy. |
cold
10.11.17 | good picks Rigma [2] |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.11.17 | "Not gonna lie,the first Meshuggah is the only one I really enjoy."
That's impossible |
Astral Abortis
10.11.17 | Most of my favourite bands have almost all 5s. |
grannypantys
10.11.17 | Right now the pixies are the only band I have with 2 fives
Bands that are almost there include Edge of Sanity, Bowie, and Eno. |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.11.17 | What would get a 5 from Edge of Sanity other than Crimson? |
Drifter
10.11.17 | R. Kelly |
Astral Abortis
10.11.17 | "What would get a 5 from Edge of Sanity other than Crimson?"
Their superior albums like Purgatory Afterglow and Spectral Sorrows |
DarkSideOfLucca
10.11.17 | There is no way Spectral Sorrows is better than Crimson. I could see Purgatory Afterglow actually, forgot about that one, but I still prefer Crimson. |
Rik VII
10.11.17 | I guess Crimson II. Purgatory Afterglow has Song of Sirens and Spectral Sorrows is an inconsistent album overall imo (mostly stylistically inconsistent, that is). |
grannypantys
10.11.17 | purgatory and crimson II are my highest rated |
Satellite
10.11.17 | i've got 5 bands with 2 5s in my ratings. kind of surprised by that tbh.
bad religion - suffer & no control
radiohead - okc & kid a
the clash - s/t & london calling
the lawrence arms - the greatest story ever told & oh! calcutta!
elliott smith - either/or & xo |
Satellite
10.11.17 | some people are less whorish with their 5s bro |
Rik VII
10.11.17 | Every 5 would perfectly deserve to be called the best album ever if it wasn't for the other 5s that are on the same level (or maybe even top it by a bit). So yeah, I'm stingy with my 5s and I think that's the right way to approach it |
Keyblade
10.11.17 | boards of canada - 3 5's
cam'ron - 2 |
TumsFestival
10.11.17 | b t m i ! |
cold
10.11.17 | I must be too generous with my 5's |
