Emeritus
Reviews 149 Approval 97%
Soundoffs 434 News Articles 30 Band Edits + Tags 611 Album Edits 1,574
Album Ratings 3842 Objectivity 79%
Last Active 10-27-22 11:13 pm Joined 01-25-13
Review Comments 19,513
| The Beach Boys
dunno what this is/all reviews on the site bar two of them are shit discog series imminent/don't fuck with the formula | 1 | | The Beach Boys Today!
one of the two albums that gave an idea of what was to come, with songs like "In The Back of My Mind" sounding like a warm up to Pet Sounds with its elaborate orchestral arrangements. The other album... | 2 | | The Beach Boys Summer Days (And Summer Nights!!)
focuses a lot more on the sunnier, pop-focused sound that was prominent on the first side of Today! Aside from California Girls, the whole album is rather upbeat but the vocal arrangements give insight into the Boys' musical progression | 3 | | The Beach Boys Beach Boys' Party!
compared to the albums before it and what was to come, this album more of a breather and showcases Brian Wilson's fascination with "party tracks" that many artists would use on their recordings for years to come (Zappa, Hendrix, Stones, Fab Four). Considered the first "unplugged" album by many, and while not exactly of top quality, bought Wilson time to create.... | 4 | | The Beach Boys Pet Sounds
This album changed music as we know it, and marked the beginning of a new era in music. Pet Sounds prompted many to use the studio to its absolute limits and inspired many to experiment in any way possible. As the Boys' were in Japan during the initial recordings, Wilson brought in the legendary "Wrecking Crew" to record the instrumental pieces that Wilson had written. Met with opposition from a certain Beach Boy, Pet Sounds was a far cry from the hits they had churned out from '62-'64. No surfing songs, no hot rod tunes, but elaborate baroque pop songs about alienation, self-doubt and the loss of innocence. It may have fucked with the formula, but it ensured the Boys' place in music history as pop auteurs. | 5 | | The Beach Boys The Smile Sessions
The most famous unreleased album of all-time (for decades at least), Smile was Wilson's attempt at creating something not only greater than Pet Sounds, but his go at beating The Beatles as well. Had the album come out in '67, it would've been huge. Not in the commercial sense (for what it's worth, the record buying public wouldn't be all too big with something like Mrs. O'Leary's Cow), but with the big name critics who would've undoubtedly championed it as a masterpiece (or as a huge, pile of nonsense - it could go both ways with this album). The biggest tragedy in music was this not making it to the press, and being shelved for decades. Not only that, but it marked the beginning of Wilson's mental decline - which would last for well over a decade. | 6 | | The Beach Boys Smiley Smile
The replacement album: quoted by Carl Wilson as "a bunt instead of a grand slam" and the end result of well over a year of hard work (gone to waste), Smiley Smile came in the wake of a mentally and physically exhausted Brian canning Smile, instead opting to start over with a more simplified album. Featuring "Heroes and Villains" and "Good Vibrations", the album ended up being the band's lowest charting album in the U.S. (#47) yet was a top 10 hit in the U.K. (#9). A few other Smile songs ("With Me Tonight", "Vegetables", "Wind Chimes", "Wonderful") were entirely remade and scaled down. Other songs featured bits and pieces of other pieces from Smile with only "Little Pad", "Gettin' Hungry" and "Whistle In" being entirely new songs. Met with confusion with the press, it went on to be highly influential in the avant-garde and ambient scene oddly enough. | 7 | | The Beach Boys Wild Honey
The Boys' try at rhythm and blues, Wild Honey was the next album in a line of "low-fi" albums (due to the rather low tech equipment at Wilson's home studio during '67). This album marked a change in the direction of the band with Brian relinquishing his role as the sole producer of the band's albums. The album performed rather fine (#24 in the U.S. and #7 in the U.K.) yet it was the lowest selling album the band had put out yet. With the public still expecting the highly experimental Smile, Wild Honey was seen as another stop gap release to hold people over and further alienated the band's audience and critics. It's unfortunate, since it features the Boys' at their most soulful with concise, rhythmic tunes such as "Wild Honey", "Here Comes The Night" and "Let The Wind Blow". | 8 | | The Beach Boys Friends
The last in a series of "low-fi" albums, Friends practically tanked upon its release (#126 U.S. / #13 U.K). Despite this, it showed Carl and Dennis Wilson, as well as Al Jardine, making significant contributions to the band's material. While it features new material, it was the second album (in a period lasting until 1971) to borrow from the cancelled (at that time, it was in limbo) Smile album. | 9 | | The Beach Boys 20/20
The final album for Capitol Records, 20/20 did far better than its predecessor (#68 U.S. / #3 U.K.) but in terms of quality, is the weakest they put out since Pet Sounds made waves in the industry three years earlier. With Brian away in a psychiatric hospital, Carl and Dennis retrieved outtakes recorded earlier to fill up the runtime of the album. While probably their most diverse album yet, the quality of the music isn't exceptional. Bruce Johnston makes his first significant contribution with the instrumental "The Nearest Faraway Place", and the Smile outtake "Cabinessence" makes its appearance (complete with the infamous "over and over the crow cries uncover the cornfield" lyric. | 10 | | The Beach Boys Sunflower
Now on the Reprise label (with the Brother Records imprint from the Smile era revived), Sunflower went through several rejections before being deemed fit for release. A more experimental endeavor for the Boys' it features several credits to Dennis Wilson, with what could be his signature song, "Forever". "Cool, Cool Water", an outtake from the Smiley Smile sessions (and attempted again for Wild Honey), featured a minimal instrumental arrangement with the emphasis being on the band's group dynamic as a vocal group. | 11 | | The Beach Boys Surf's Up
The final album to borrow anything from Smile, Surf's Up was the final album Bruce Johnston would feature on as a member until 1979's Light Album. Another diverse album from the band, it features no songs from Dennis, with Carl, Al and Mike's material making up the album with Johnston's "Disney Girls" being his sole contribution to the album. The band's manager, Jack Rieley, even contributes with vocals on Brian's "A Day in the Life of a Tree" as well as Carl's "Long Promised Road" and "Feel Flows". The album is more of a downer in comparison to Sunflower, with a few songs containing an environmental message (especially in the downright depressing "Day in the Life"), and the "Riot in Cell Block #9" rewrite "Student Demonstration Time" from Mike Love that tends to get flak for its confusing message and its attempt to be socially and politically relevant. "Til' I Die" further dampens the mood with Brian's lyrics reflecting his mindset at the time, a man preoccupied with life, death and.. | 12 | | The Beach Boys Surf's Up
...his place in the world. The finale, "Surf's Up", taken from Smile, is often considered his magnum opus, and for good reason. The elaborate arrangements, the vocal work, the lyrics from Wilson and Van Dyke Parks, it's a taster of just what Wilson was promising with Smile. Despite Pet Sounds being his most acclaimed work, "Surf's Up" is considered his single greatest composition. With its ironic title, the song details a man's enlightenment and is in someway autobiographical with the lyric "The father's life is done, and the children carry on" (which was removed), which was written with father Murray in mind. The song was almost left off the album due to Brian's resistance of having it included and was practically forced into including it on the album. | 13 | | The Beach Boys Carl and the Passions - "So Tough"
By 1971, Carl had become the de facto bandleader, and by his decision had decided to bring in two new members - Blondie Chaplin and Ricky Fataar of The Flames, a band that had caught Wilson's interest. This album harkens back in a way to the soulful sound of Wild Honey, with songs like "You Need a Mess of Help to Stand Alone", "Marcella" and "Here She Comes" being examples of the band's venture into roots-based rock. Dennis, who had suffered a hand injury at this time, took up the piano and collaborated with Daryl Dragon (more known as The Captain of Captain and Tennille) on the songs "Make it Good" and "Cuddle Up", hinting at the sound of his solo album Pacific Ocean Blue. During the sessions of this album, Bruce Johnston left the band (or was fired by Jack Rieley, depending on which account you want to believe) due to the direction the band was going in, as well as Brian's lessening influence, | 14 | | The Beach Boys Holland
At the insistence of Rieley, the band headed to the Netherlands in the hopes of kicking Brian out of his depression and reviving his creative spark. Holland featured more contributions from Chaplin and Fataar, most notably on "Sail On, Sailor" and "Leaving This Town" (the former had Chaplin on vocals, but was written by Wilson and Van Dyke Parks, as well as Rieley and Tadyn Almer and Ray Kennedy). The rest of the album features minimal contributions from Wilson, with the rest of the band writing most of the material. Wilson put most of his efforts into the ten minute 7" EP "Mount Vernon and Fairway", a heavily spoken-word fairy tale about a magical transistor radio. | 15 | | The Beach Boys 15 Big Ones
Marked by the "Brian's Back!" campaign, 15 Big Ones came three years after Holland. Chaplin, Fataar and Rieley were long gone - and in an attempt to follow up on the success of the Endless Summer compilation, tried to get Brian back into the producer's chair. This was met with commercial success, peaking at #8 in the U.S., yet stalled at #31 in the U.K. - and was met with indifference with the critics, who felt the band were exploiting Brian at a critical point where they were relevant once again. The campaign reached a peak (read: low) with their SNL appearance which featured Brian at the center of a "Failure to Surf" comedy sketch in which surf cops played by Dan Aykroyd and John Belushi pull Brian out of bed and force him to ride the waves outside. At this time, the band hired Eugene Landy to supervise Wilson in order to ensure his health. This was the first time Landy would be involved with Wilson, with the second time being far more infamous in Beach Boys lore... | |
Frippertronics
03.26.16 | Hey now, it's a love thing. | Spec
03.26.16 | I've jammed pet sounds numerous times, sometimes it sounds good and sometimes I'm bored out of my mind. | Frippertronics
03.26.16 | I think Sunflower and Surf's Up may be a better starting point if you're looking for the band doing experimental stuff yet sticking with a pop sound like Pet Sounds, but if you're looking for the band doing something very similar to Pet Sounds, Today! is your best bet. | Frippertronics
03.26.16 | tl;dr don't fuck with the formula
correction: Jack Rieley sung on "A Day in the Life of a Tree" only, but co-wrote it, as well as Carl's "Long Promised Road" and "Feel Flows". Van Dyke Parks and Al Jardine respectively appear near the end of "A Day In The Life", Parks being notable due to his southern drawl. | Titan
03.26.16 | i should get in to these guys a bit more.....they remind me of my Mom....never would've thought you were fluent with these guys fripp, thats a lot of info | Friday13th
03.26.16 | frick yeah, Fripp. Finally got around to Holland and it's pretty good. I'm gonna see Brian, Al Jardine and Blondie Chaplin for the Pet Sounds tour, so I wanted to know who this Blondie guy is.
I've been really digging Friends lately. It's silly but endearing in a strange way. All that to say I've gotten to the point where I can with a straight face say the Beach Boys are as good as the Beatles. | LotusFlower
03.26.16 | never listened a beach boys album in full, gonna check out Surfs Up cuz that album art is gloomy | Friday13th
03.26.16 | Pet Sounds is way better but yeah Surf's Up is top 5 for sure | LotusFlower
03.26.16 | Super digging this so far, id prolly even 5/5 it from the 6 tracks ive heard so far | Friday13th
03.26.16 | The last two songs are the best ones too lol make that a 6/5 | LotusFlower
03.26.16 | Student Demonstration Time was out of place so its back to just being a 5/5 | Friday13th
03.26.16 | Yeah, that song honestly blows. Unfortunately even the best Beach Boys albums have a song that sucks except for Pet Sounds (and Smile Sessions if that counts). | Ryus
03.26.16 | unfortunately i disagree
sloop john b sucks :[ | Friday13th
03.26.16 | 0.0 No it doesn't that's one of the best covers ever. How can you not dig that arrangement? | SmileNerd
03.26.16 | we need a sequel to merzbob | Friday13th
03.26.16 | ^ check Smile, nerd ;) | ArsMoriendi
03.26.16 | 6 is perfection :) | guilouzzz
03.26.16 | pets sound is number one imo | Tyler.
03.26.16 | Great list dude | Ryus
03.26.16 | "0.0 No it doesn't that's one of the best covers ever. How can you not dig that arrangement?"
i suppose i can appreciate it but i just find it incredibly irritating | ArsMoriendi
03.26.16 | I wouldn't say Sloop sucks, but it's easily the worst on there.
Not a single song on Smiley Smile is weak in my opinion, even if Gettin' Hungry is easily the worst on there... | Friday13th
03.26.16 | yeah not a fan of Gettin' Hungry. Smiley is pretty consistent though the short tracks leave you wanting more imo | Frippertronics
03.27.16 | Sloop has grown on me, but it's certainly the weakest song on Pet Sounds. The vocal arrangement is what makes that song good.
The Brother Records period from '70-'74 are probably the most interesting era in the BB's career, so many changes in sound plus their live shows were some of the best around. | ArsMoriendi
03.27.16 | She's Goin' Bald is so wonderful (pun intended) | Friday13th
03.27.16 | wooooon-won-won-wonderful | ArsMoriendi
03.27.16 | The part in Wind Chimes where they sing "It's so peaceful, close to a lullabye" AND THEN THERE's THIS SUPER ABRASIVE SOUND is such a troll move haha | wtferrothorn
03.27.16 | Sweet list Frip, been getting deeper into these guys other than Pet Sounds. Which of their albums would you consider essentials? | Friday13th
03.27.16 | haha Ars ikr | LotusFlower
03.27.16 | Ferro listen to Surfs Up certified 5/5 | Frippertronics
03.27.16 | Clover's got it, Disney Girls, Long Promised Road and the final three songs on that album are the Boys' at their best arguably. I'd just check everything they did from Shut Down Volume 2 to Holland. 15 Big Ones is decent, Love You is a grower but could be a lot better. Adult/Child is the last good thing they ever put out but isn't up to the quality of the Brother Records era. I'd put it above 15/LY and about just as good as Holland. | Frippertronics
03.27.16 | however if you had to listen to three of their albums that weren't Pet Sounds or Smile: Friends, Sunflower, and Surf's Up are the essentials. | ArsMoriendi
03.27.16 | Friends is meh, Smiley Smile man | Frippertronics
03.27.16 | nope | Frippertronics
03.28.16 | check Surf's Up | Friday13th
03.28.16 | Friends is a grower. One thing you'll miss the first time is that the bass playing is really phenomenal. Probably why it's Brian's favorite. That or Summer Days is their most underrated imo | Friday13th
03.28.16 | Surf's Up is da bomb. Idk if I mentioned this, Fripper, but John Wetton said it's his favorite PROG album...like waaaaaaaaaaaaa kinda wack but still interesting perspective. | Frippertronics
03.28.16 | yeah I see that being quoted round here and that sounds pretty unusual honestly
also, transcendental meditation and little bird are cool songs. I find Friends to edge out Smiley Smile because it feels more like a complete album while SS feels like an album full of odds and ends. I dig the atmosphere and what they're going for, but some bits of it just bore me honestly. Plus, they ruined Heroes and Villains by cutting out that middle section, just bad imo. | Frippertronics
04.18.16 | *correction - California Girls is upbeat so I don't know what I was thinking when I said it wasn't. I'm stupid (song is pre good however) | jtswope
04.18.16 | Today is amazing. | Frippertronics
04.18.16 | yeah dude, the first side is surprisingly a bit of a grower when you compare it with the second half. It's probably one of the few Boys albums that can seriously compete with Pet Sounds (as long as you act like Bull Daddy doesn't exist) | jtswope
04.18.16 | Agreed man it's a superbly written pop album and a perfect warm up for pet sounds. |
|