Artuma
11.01.14 | all 5's |
Tyler.
11.01.14 | high five dude |
Artuma
11.01.14 | yay |
frigyourgenre
11.01.14 | death & flylo tbh |
killtaker
11.01.14 | yeah man def |
Froot
11.01.14 | Bungle |
Artuma
11.01.14 | never really got into bungle tbh |
Let
11.01.14 | Boards of Canada.
I would say Flylo too, but I still need to listen to his lasest |
killtaker
11.01.14 | practice absence must be the best song ever btw |
Scoot
11.01.14 | all about no conversationalist
best 36 seconds ever |
YakNips
11.01.14 | brave little abacus |
Avagantamos
11.01.14 | off minor is way up there with fugazi and converge for me. totally awesome band |
Ryus
11.01.14 | Boards of Canada [2] |
wwba
11.01.14 | I'd say it's Dimitri Vegas and Like Mike ...I just added them to the database... though it's kinda
embarrassing that I had to add them, considering they have almost 6m likes on facebook, much more than a lot
of artists who are hyped on this site, are sputnik people really so close-minded that they can't appreciate
electronic music, unless it's a pointless masturbation with outdated synthesizers? |
killtaker
11.01.14 | you're trying way too hard |
Scoot
11.01.14 | yea |
MyNameIsPencil
11.01.14 | I hate to be that guy but I consider Deftones to be practically perfect to me, I have (their full length LP's at least) at 4.5's and 5's. Yes even Adrenaline. SUCK SUCK SUCK SUCK SUCK SUCK SUCK SUCK |
Artuma
11.01.14 | 4.5 =/= perfect |
Ryus
11.01.14 | weakerthans, meat puppets, alice in chains, bathory |
KrazyKris
11.01.14 | Perfect as in always 5 perfect? Sounds like a myth to me. |
MyNameIsPencil
11.01.14 | "Practically" was the key word. Personally I think zero bands can be called straight up perfect. Sure perfect is a very opinioned term to begin with, and I'm sure you may disagree with me on that, but that's okay. I think it's very possible for a band to release one (or even more) "perfect" album(s), but not possible to be on that level through the bands entire discography you know |
KrazyKris
11.01.14 | Completely agree. When it comes to music the term "perfect" can't have the same meaning as usually anyway. There will always be something to criticize, but there's also a reason we 5 things. But it seems pretty difficult even with two albums, because you'll certainly compare them and almost always that exposes the weaknesses of one of them. |
killtaker
11.01.14 | "meat puppets"
ily |
Artuma
11.01.14 | "not possible to be on that level through the bands entire discography you know"
this band tho |
wwba
11.01.14 | What about Mozart? Even his first symphony (which he wrote at iirc 6) was dynamically perfect and full of
nice melodies... and later he just got even better |
hikingmetalpunk
11.01.14 | immolation |
MyNameIsPencil
11.01.14 | some could say he's just background music, which isn't what I think per say, but I will admit that classical music doesn't do much for me.
also Off Minor are really good, if not a tad too chaotic for me at times |
Artuma
11.01.14 | gospel is a perfect band as well but i don't think bands with only one album count |
KrazyKris
11.01.14 | ~What about Mozart? Even his first symphony (which he wrote at iirc 6) was dynamically perfect and full of nice melodies... and later he just got even better~
Since the entertainment factor or my desire to get back to something and even more so the emotional impact something has on me are crucial points in the quality of music, I doubt I could label Mozart perfect, all technical brilliance aside. |
Let
11.02.14 | Yeah, In that case Demilich would be perfect too, but they also have the vanishing sessions and demos which are super good. Also Joy Division |
KrazyKris
11.02.14 | Joy Division might fit, but just as the Sex Pistols, Jeff Buckley or NMH it's debatable if such a small discography really counts. |
insanedrexl1
11.02.14 | Death |
Artuma
11.02.14 | sex pistols suck tho and i don't think many people would say nmh's debut is perfect |
MyNameIsPencil
11.02.14 | Yeah small discographys are tough
Also the moon is a dead world = |
rockandmetaljunkie
11.02.14 | no such thing as the "perfect band" |
Muisc4Life26
11.02.14 | 2 is amazing |
facupm
11.02.14 | Wheres pink floyd |
wacknizzle
11.02.14 | AC/DC |
adarkishman
11.02.14 | use ur own fuckinga ccount lakes |
Negator
11.02.14 | rush [2] |
titanslayer
11.02.14 | Enslaved |
Nud
11.02.14 | Summoning |
cliiint
11.02.14 | dance gavin dance during DBM was perfect
oh yeah
tbh tbh tbh tbh tbh tbh tbh tbh tbh tbh tbh tbh tbh tbh tbh tbh |
Artuma
11.02.14 | with darth's logic swans and floyd would be perfect yea. but i just simply can't find a single flaw from any of off minor's albums, which is what makes them perfect |
Artuma
11.02.14 | disagreed hard but it's all subjective |
Artuma
11.02.14 | oh yeah new pestilence stuff is average as fuck |
ShadowRemains
11.02.14 | consvming impvlse is their only really standout release
malleus is excellent and testimony is solid but they aren't classics |
ShadowRemains
11.02.14 | "Darkthrone. Not a single bad album. Not a single average album. Not a single album less than fucking amazing.
Perfect band."
lol look at this guy |
Artuma
11.02.14 | well it's snox what did you expect? |
Chrisjon89
11.02.14 | John Coltrane's quartet, early to mid 60s. |
JamieTwort
11.02.14 | There is no perfect band. |
ShadowRemains
11.02.14 | demilich...every single track they have ever released has been gold |
Artuma
11.02.14 | it's kind of funny that this list was made to have an off minor fanboy thread but it turned to a legit debate about "perfect" bands |
MeatSalad
11.02.14 | harmonium comes close |
JamieTwort
11.02.14 | It doesn't suck at all. I will never find a "perfect" band and I am fine with that. |
ShadowRemains
11.02.14 | the pursuit of perfection is one of the things that drives us to listen to more and more bands so yeah i'd agree with that sentiment |
zakalwe
11.02.14 | It all depends on what you're looking for in a band.
If it's solely the music, nobodies perfect. |
Wadlez
11.02.14 | Boards of Canada [10]
Agreed. |
Keyblade
11.02.14 | Boards of Canada [∞]
Summoning [2] |
NightProwler
11.02.14 | Actually never got around Off Minor. Maybe I should.
Also, The Smith Street Band. Pretty much perfect band |
Kman418
11.02.14 | btmi is the only one
autechre anco and boc all come close but they all have some non amazing material |
adr
11.02.14 | lol btmi |
Artuma
11.02.14 | just jammed through off minor discog again. it's omg so good i'm dying |
adr
11.02.14 | 2 and 4 are amazing yea, i should prob check 3 ahrd |
Artuma
11.02.14 | it's just good as 2 and 4 yea check it |
Kman418
11.02.14 | btmi are better than u |
adr
11.02.14 | No. btmi are hard 3/5 band yeah, too much sputnik hype bb |
Kman418
11.02.14 | that hype was 60% me |
p4p
11.02.14 | the doobie brothers |
demigod!
11.02.14 | btmi [2] |
brokendogleg
11.02.14 | mewithoutYou
Lungfish |
Snake.
11.02.14 | only heard heat death i really need to jam some blood tho |
Ryus
11.02.14 | "No. btmi are hard 3/5 band yeah, too much sputnik hype bb"
you are so wrong |
Artuma
11.02.14 | "only heard heat death i really need to jam some blood tho"
and innominate. and the ep |
Avagantamos
11.02.14 | fugazi and godspeed are perfect in my eyes |
treeqt.
11.02.14 | off minor and orchid are good opinions |
hikingmetalpunk
11.02.14 | "Darkthrone. Not a single bad album. Not a single average album. Not a single album less than fucking amazing.
Perfect band."
i'd lean toward agreeing with this |
