Muisc4Life26
10.10.14 | tough but At The Drive-In |
RadioSuicide
10.10.14 | Ah this is a good one. Probably TMV tho, they've pushed a lot of boundaries in prog, especially in de-loused. |
mxbrady
10.10.14 | Personally I love ATDI and can't stand TMV. But I'm pretty sure that's a minority opinion |
Archelirion
10.10.14 | I like both, but ATDI has slightly less seemingly irrelevant crap for me so I'd go with them. |
chinesewhispers
10.10.14 | If TMV quit at Bedlam I'd say them, but since they didn't...ADTI. |
deathschool
10.10.14 | Neither one seems to grab me as much as I wish they would, but ATDI wins by a good bit even still. |
InFiction
10.10.14 | At The Drive-In for sure, although I still really dig The Mars Volta. Mostly their first four records. |
Snake.
10.10.14 | AtDI |
AcidCaravan
10.10.14 | ATDI all the way. And my favourite album of theirs being "In/Casino/Out"... |
NightProwler
10.10.14 | TMV by a bit |
Torontonian
10.10.14 | Amputechre is probably better than any album ATDI made so ya MV for sure. |
Supaduck0
10.10.14 | Relationship of Command is the best album of either bands career and I prefer the style of that album to anything TMV did, but TMV still kick ass |
McMegaMountain
10.10.14 | Well At the Drive-In only has two really solid albums, one of which is an instant classic, whereas the Mars Volta has 2-3 okay albums, and the rest are shit. ATDI by a landslide. |
KingdomOfTyrant
10.10.14 | TMV |
StallionMang
10.10.14 | Fuck that's tough
I'd go with ATDI cuz 1. RoC is the best album between the two bands and 2. they're a hell of a lot easier to listen to and I just prefer their sound |
dcalderon
10.10.14 | ATDI all the way. Despite being a little overproduced, RoC is still one of the more powerful albums I've ever heard |
DikkoZinner
10.10.14 | "Invalid Litter Dept." good tune |
Ryus
10.10.14 | lol absolutely no competition, atdi, tmv sucks ass yeah |
Friday13th
10.10.14 | TMV because it's prog :] |
Torontonian
10.10.14 | TMV because they made amputechre. (Sucha good album) |
jtswope
10.10.14 | TMV by a nose. Both bands rule hard. How is RoC overproduced dcalderon? Sounds perfect to me.
|
Ichangedmynametojeff
10.11.14 | From what I've heard (I'm not completely through their discography, these are estimates). Well, ATDI has two good albums and one great album (don't yell at me yet I'm trying to do this mathematically). The Mars Volta has two great albums, about two good albums (I dunno), and about two less than good albums.
Doing this mathematically, less than good is a -1, good is 0, and great is 1. At the Drive In have 1. The Mars Volta have 0. So I'm going with ATDI by default.
Really, that was probably a shitty estimation (again I'm judging on the songs and albums I've heard, when in reality I haven't heard all albums) so I'm going with ATDI.
And both Deloused and Relationship are 4.5s or higher for me so I love both. |
Funeralopolis
10.11.14 | ATDI easily |
Uranium
10.11.14 | i like tmv exponentially more |
samsquanch
10.11.14 | TMV |
Rice303
10.11.14 | ATDI, The Mars Volta started off great but has 2 hit and miss albums that I really can't decide on |
DrMaximus
10.11.14 | Pick your poison |
FrankieFrog
10.11.14 | I had been listening to ATDI for years before finally giving TMV a shot and I regret the years I missed out.
Deloused is better than anything ATDI ever made. |
drasticaction74
11.24.14 | fuck this is hard |
Lethean
11.24.14 | aTdI |
furpa
11.24.14 | Ehhh! Somebody bumped this. :D |
Ricochet
11.24.14 | well...
In Casino =4.5
Vaya=4.7
Relation=5
Deloused=4.7
Frances...meh..
ATDI wins |
Ricochet
11.24.14 | 5s include Drake, Asap Rocky , you have no power here |
Ricochet
11.24.14 | haha wow those are old 5s also im not afraid of pop as long as its good but Drake sleeps through his albums so im not impressed |
Ricochet
11.24.14 | ive listened to his most appreciated album and i liked a few songs but why wish for potential when i know where to find real talent |
Lethean
11.24.14 | swans |
tcat84
12.05.14 | ATDI - ROC is their only album that really blows me away... believe me i've tried. MV tho when I first hear their first EP i was instantly in love and their 1st 3 albums were fucking amazing... MV for me |
Taxt
12.05.14 | I love ATDI more than just about anything but would still pick TMV even if Frances was the only album they
ever made. |
Rowan5215
12.05.14 | TMV are mostly wank, ATDI ahrd |
