SatanicPeanuts
04.07.14 | Ur overrated motherfucker |
SatanicPeanuts
04.07.14 | Pls explain how they are overrated |
JS19
04.07.14 | Every time someone uses the word 'overrated' a puppy dies |
SatanicPeanuts
04.07.14 | ^the truth |
InFlamesWeThrash666
04.07.14 | Gotta agree with Nirvana's Nevermind |
ValarMorghulis
04.07.14 | 15, 16 and 19 rule |
SatanicPeanuts
04.07.14 | That's about the only one tho. Everything else is fucking amazing |
InFlamesWeThrash666
04.07.14 | Yes pretty much |
ArsMoriendi
04.07.14 | 1, 2, 3, 8, 12 ,17, and 18 are all amazing, but none of them are my favorite by each artist.
|
Friday13th
04.07.14 | omg this is the worst overrated list ever made...but I still agree with 3,5 and 13. |
mandan
04.07.14 | I can agree with 19, 16 (slightly), and maybe 3.
But lol @ quite a few of these. |
emester
04.07.14 | thought this was a pillowguy list until I saw Pink Floyd |
SticksmanTheBored
04.07.14 | Some albums that... "I", subject, find overrated. What albums do... "you"... interpretative-ability-lacking morons... find overrated? =) |
ArsMoriendi
04.07.14 | Also even if Songs in the Key of Life WAS overrated, here on Sputnik, there aren't many Stevie Wonder fans... sadly.
Seriously, Stevie Wonder's albums (especially his albums from 1971-1976) are amazing. |
SatanicPeanuts
04.07.14 | I love stevie, I would turn for him any day |
Riviere
04.07.14 | 18?
Explain yourself. |
SatanicPeanuts
04.07.14 | @stickmanthebored Not these albums |
DikkoZinner
04.07.14 | Nah |
MO
04.07.14 | "What albums do... "you"... interpretative-ability-lacking morons... find overrated? =)"
good one fuckwad
burial - untrue is beyond overrated just so you know |
SatanicPeanuts
04.07.14 | This list has pissed me off |
Relinquished
04.07.14 | good |
TheSpaceMan
04.07.14 | gtfo |
MrSirLordGentleman
04.07.14 | Lol, you deserve dead just because of 20 |
Salvidian
04.07.14 | Seriously though, can we get at least one reason for one of these? |
zakalwe
04.07.14 | MO knows he really does.
Burial is great but Untrue is a fucking over-hyped ,over praised, under worked piece of turd that is essentially shite garage interpreted as a work of genius by total divs. |
Thibs
04.07.14 | I only agree with 13 |
lensag
04.07.14 | not a single one of this albums is overrated |
Relinquished
04.07.14 | butthurt kids itt |
pedro70512
04.07.14 | agree very much with 2, 3, 8, 9, and 16. |
Salvidian
04.07.14 | I just have a hard time believing he dislikes all of these. Or, at least, is indifferent about them out of a historical context. |
MrSirLordGentleman
04.07.14 | He 5'd Animal Collective, lol |
zakalwe
04.07.14 | Untrue
MPP
Funeral
London Calling
Exile on Main Street |
ArsMoriendi
04.07.14 | Well overrated doesn't necessarily mean he doesn't like them. He just thinks they get too much acclaim?
Oh forget trying to defend him, this list is terrible. |
aircycle
04.07.14 | jeff buckley is overrated af |
SharkTooth
04.07.14 | 5,10, 17, and 20 are perfectly rated thankyouverymuch |
JS19
04.07.14 | VALIDATE ME |
Uranium
04.07.14 | i always thought blackwater park was pretty bland myself |
Uranium
04.07.14 | agreed with the downward spiral too |
ArsMoriendi
04.07.14 | "agreed with the downward spiral too"
but but but but but... well I do prefer Year Zero. But still... |
Funeralopolis
04.07.14 | 13 is a hard 5/5 |
Uranium
04.07.14 | "but but but but but... well I do prefer Year Zero. But still..."
There are some really good songs on TDS (same goes for all NIN albums). As a whole though? Not for me. |
SticksmanTheBored
04.07.14 | @Salvidian, hold on there, mate! This list by no means criticizes the albums mentioned on it! I only think they are overrated, I don't appreciate the music contained in these albums as much as other people do, that's why I think these albums are pretty overrated. |
Salvidian
04.07.14 | Like I said earlier, I can't fathom how/why you find them overrated. But I suppose we'll just have to agree to disagree. :P |
facupm
04.07.14 | rip overrated?
list needs ok computer most overrated album ever made |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
04.07.14 | lists like these need to fuck off and die |
SticksmanTheBored
04.07.14 | @MO, thank you, you little bastard. Untrue is awesome, at least for me! I do enjoy it more when I'm on the mood for it then in other days, though, so yeah, can't 5 it. But still, a 4-4.5, for sure, but this is just me. My opinion isn't an universal law that everyone should adopt, as isn't anyone's opinion either. Music is interesting to discuss because of all the different existent opinions. |
Salvidian
04.07.14 | "list needs ok computer most overrated album ever made"
I would actually agree with this, but not a popular opinion. Especially not on Sputnik, no sir. |
facupm
04.07.14 | not popular but true |
SticksmanTheBored
04.07.14 | @facupm, actually, yeah you're pretty right, OK Computer is a tiny bit overrated, although Radiohead are prob my favorite band. Airbag isn't that great of an opener neither is The Tourist a perfect closer but yeah it's a hard 4.5 for it's consistency and most of it is brilliant. Kid A still owns, tho. |
NeroCorleone80
04.07.14 | You might as well say every critically acclaimed album is overrated |
facupm
04.07.14 | you might, but none as ok computer |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
04.07.14 | "You might as well say every critically acclaimed album is overrated"
which would be retarded considering 'acclaim' is the accumulation of mass amounts of subjective preferences and to dub that 'overrated' is to emphasize the importance of your own subjectivity over others which is preposterous and pretentious and probably other bombastic words that start with p as well
using 'overrated' and 'underrated' to describe albums is actually so dumb |
pedro70512
04.07.14 | "underappreciated," on the other hand, is a very useful term. |
PunchforPunch
04.07.14 | overheated |
Salvidian
04.07.14 | What about personal acclaim? |
OwMySnauze
04.07.14 | Wu-tang is never overrated. |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
04.07.14 | truth 'under-appreciated' is fine its also fine to say you don't like something as much as the rest of the world but when the entirity of earth gives ok comp a 5/5 and you give it a 1/5 its not overrated, by that logic the 'truth' of this matter is that you severely underrate it. btw i think ok comp is like 3/5 but i still don't think its overrated cuz thats dumb, its just rated |
aircycle
04.07.14 | true over/underrated is maybe only arguable in terms of how influential an album is which is difficult to quantify |
Solaire
04.07.14 | Shots fired. If they are a 5 on here they aren't automatically overrated. The community here tends to favor some not to popular acts. Opeth gets their dicked sucked on this website, but try asking people at your work about them. See how many know them. |
SticksmanTheBored
04.07.14 | I'm pretty surprised that some people are actually using their brains on this thread. |
postrockpaperscissor
04.07.14 | 3, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15 are all absolutely terrific albums.
How dare you put Elliott Smith on an overrated list, you dumbfuck? |
BMDrummer
04.08.14 | If you're going make a bold claim that these albums are overrated, type some descriptions on why they are overrated. |
titanslayer
04.08.14 | not to say that it's bad but 19 is definitely overrated |
Project
04.08.14 | Beatles -- White Album |
TumsFestival
04.08.14 | fuck you on the account of 5 |
Lord(e)Po)))ts
04.08.14 | fuck YOU on my illegal offshore account. |
Faraudo
04.08.14 | Uhm, what the fuck are 9,12 and 19 doing here? What are you doing here? |
mandan
04.08.14 | Does this guy even like music? |
scottpilgrim10
04.08.14 | Blasphemous list. I agree with some of them though. |
aircycle
04.08.14 | hey man fuck u raditude is not overrated |
Gwyn.
04.08.14 | I don't understand why using the word overrated isn't a bannable offense |
mandan
04.08.14 | 1, 2, 8, 9, 10 & 12 have no businness being on this list. |
Necrotica
04.08.14 | You forgot to add Death somewhere on this list |
aircycle
04.08.14 | BEVERLEY HILLS GIMME GIMME LIVING IN BEVERLEY HILLS |
fuckyourneonshirt
04.08.14 | I'm not even gonna read any of these comments. don't care. you're just wrong. |
dimsim3478
04.08.14 | you have Nick Drake on this list
i will kill you |
SticksmanTheBored
04.08.14 | @FiveLeavesLeft , yes, I can't see the appeal to Death either, I don't really care for them like other people do so yeah, they'd fit this list perfectly. And answering @dimsim3478 with this, it's not because it's Nick Drake, it's because it's Pink Moon. The album FiveLeaves takes his name from is so much better for me. |
SticksmanTheBored
04.08.14 | @ProjectFreak, yes! As much as I love The Beatles, The White Album is pretty overrated in my books! |
dimsim3478
04.08.14 | fair enough I got Pink Moon at a 5 and Five Leaves comes in at a 4.5 for me so I'm just naturally your enemy :) |
eddie95
04.08.14 | 1, 2, 6, 7, 8, 10, 11, 15, 18 NOOOOOPE
I might agree with you about 3 and 16... |
ti0n
04.08.14 | oh boy you should watch your back when you go out |
panagiotis
04.08.14 | I will skip the part were I judge your opinion.
Cryptopsy seriously suck. Their albums range for terrible to mediocre. I am listening to death metal since many of the users here were born so watch what you say m**********s |
SticksmanTheBored
04.08.14 | dimsim, hehehe, we're not enemies, it's just that our opinions don't match! We can still be friends. |
Wadlez
04.08.14 | Anyone with any appreciation for rap would dig 5. Downward Spiral was never really my think though. Rest of these albums
are awesome. |
facupm
04.09.14 | 20 is kinda overrated
but where's ok computer most overrated album ever |
Gwyn.
04.09.14 | shut the fuck up already jesus |
deathschool
04.09.14 | Your lists suck donkey dick. |
dimsim3478
04.09.14 | i love your sense of superiority in the art of sputnik list making plz teach us deathschool |
dimsim3478
04.09.14 | "dimsim, hehehe, we're not enemies, it's just that our opinions don't match! We can still be friends."
I was 100% kidding, bro. Our opinions aren't really even that different anyway, considering that I do freaking love "Five Leaves Left". |
Tunaboy45
04.09.14 | Jethro tull? NIN? Opeth? Are you kidding me?
"yeah I only buy albums that have sold less than 1000 copies. Otherwise they're overrated." |
Snacktimeguy
04.09.14 | Totally agree with 8, 13, and 15. |
Tunaboy45
04.09.14 | Seriously though, this list does make sense and I especially agree with Nevermind. Overrated to the point where I can't listen to it anymore. |