mandan
05.10.13 | On a sidenote, I skipped the live side of Ummagumma.
I'll add the explanations later.
Would love to see what Notrap, JT and KILL think of this list. |
ViperAces
05.10.13 | 13 is WAY too low |
DominionMM1
05.10.13 | well, you got the first 3 right |
MeatSalad
05.10.13 | 13 should be on the latter half of the list for sure |
Aids
05.10.13 | stopped reading when you put Ummagumma and Piper in the bottom two spots.
fight me |
JamieTwort
05.10.13 | 13 is WAY too low [2]
Good to see some love for 4 and 5 though. |
JamieTwort
05.10.13 | Also 2 is 1. |
DrHouseSchuldiner
05.10.13 | 1 is my fav
13 is way too law
i dont like 5 that much tbh
Sweet list for a great band one of my favs of all time |
DominionMM1
05.10.13 | meddle and saucerful are a little too low for my taste but whatever
and 1 is 1 |
Jeffrulesyou
05.10.13 | The first three could all be contender for best floyd album. I'd probably swap 4 for 6 and 9 for 5. Cool list. |
Zeneren
05.10.13 | Also 2 is 1. [2]
Inevitable this would be said though. |
mandan
05.10.13 | Haven't seen Notrap yet, he's the biggest PF fanboy on the site. |
Chortles
05.10.13 | it's been like 15 minutes |
mandan
05.10.13 | Still no Notrap or KILL. No Jethro or sonic either. |
Titan
05.10.13 | 4 and 10 are the worst imo |
mandan
05.10.13 | ^I've never told you this, but you've probably got the most disgusting username on the site. No
offense. |
kitsch
05.10.13 | should be in reverse order |
StallionMang
05.10.13 | 13 is WAY too low [34235] |
tempest--
05.11.13 | 3 is 1
2 is 2
3 is 3
Meddle is higher
Obscured by Clouds is a little lower
Final Cut is a too high
13 is WAY too low [∞] |
Artuma
05.11.13 | 13 and 9 omgomgomgomgomg |
NeroCorleone80
05.11.13 | 1 would be around 4th for me, and 13 is top 5 |
JamieTwort
05.11.13 | 9 is fine where it is imo. |
Artuma
05.11.13 | 9 is 1
13 is top 5
5 isn't
3 is 2
well goddammit there is too much to fix |
ViperAces
05.11.13 | maybe a little higher |
JamieTwort
05.11.13 | Nah it's not that bad. The lowest I'd have it would be 10. |
Artuma
05.11.13 | 9 has a 4.3 average here, how is it possible that i am the only one who loves it lol? |
DavidScott
05.11.13 | Dark Side of Awesomeness
Wish You Were Here > Animals |
tempest--
05.11.13 | lol Jac I meant 1 is 3 haha holy crap |
JamieTwort
05.11.13 | @Artuma: lol, don't worry you're definitely not the only one who loves it. Notrap loves it, I think he has it 5'd. |
Artuma
05.11.13 | well i added that "lol" in the end for that i wasn't fully serious but it really is weird though imo that people find it to be so mediocre |
JamieTwort
05.11.13 | I know you weren't fully serious but yeah it does seem like a lot of the site's regular users think it's overrated. I personally just find it has far too much filler. There are some fantastic songs on there though. |
Rowan5215
05.11.13 | Jamie knows how it is. Good list, it's really nice to finally see 4 get some love around here. |
Artuma
05.11.13 | sure and as people tend to say, no Floyd is worse than a 3. for me it is the perfect concept album |
ViperAces
05.11.13 | the beatles s/t is better |
TheNotrap
05.11.13 | Yep Danny, The Dark Side of the Moon is their best album.
The Wall is way too low, but everything is subjective.
1 - The Dark Side of the Moon
2 - The Wall
3 - Wish You Were Here |
TheNotrap
05.11.13 | @JT
Indeed, one of my favourite albums.
|
Motiv3
05.11.13 | 13 is WAY too low [3]. 13 is like 4 or 5 for me. |
Aids
05.11.13 | The Wall rules and people who say it sucks are too far up their own asses. Roger Waters is a douche but The Wall is perfect. |
Artuma
05.11.13 | i know i'm not alone with my opinion but the majority of sputnikers seems to consider it highly overrated, what for me it isn't at all |
Artuma
05.11.13 | Roger Waters is a douche tho [2] |
JamieTwort
05.11.13 | "The Wall rules and people who say it sucks are too far up their own asses."
lol, how does someone disliking an album mean they're up their own ass? |
JamieTwort
05.11.13 | Oh and for the record I don't dislike it, I think it's good but somewhat overrated. |
facupm
05.29.13 | Swap 1 and 3 to get the top 3.
13 is way too low |
ButteryBiscuitBass
05.29.13 | 2 is 1. |
evilford
05.29.13 | DUDE 13????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????? |
evilford
05.29.13 | just died |
ButteryBiscuitBass
05.29.13 | RIP |
evilford
05.29.13 | 1 is 1 though agreed but I'd have 13 at 4
agree w/ your 1-3 tho |
Jethro42
05.29.13 | top 3 is top 3 |
BigPleb
05.29.13 | 13 all the way down there? Holy fuck. |
evilford
05.29.13 | glad to see the final cut in the top 5 tho |
BigPleb
05.29.13 | Ye, that's right. |
JamieTwort
05.29.13 | glad to see the final cut in the top 5 tho [2] |
MeatSalad
05.29.13 | How do you have 8 so high but 13 so low |
evilford
05.29.13 | valid question |
Artuma
06.13.13 | ^AMLOR above Piper too i mean that's hilarious |
evilford
06.13.13 | sure roger was a little douchy but so was the rest of the band at points. he's since said countless times that he thought it was arrogant of him to expect the band to stop playing all pink floyd music cuz he wanted nothing to do with it anymore. most people who say they hate roger probably don't even know why he was hated to begin with. |
TheSpaceMan
06.13.13 | meddle isn't given enough credit here, but at least you agree its better than the wall |
rockandmetaljunkie
06.13.13 | 9 and 13 are way too low.
I agree with the first 3. These are the best albums PF made. |
oltnabrick
05.12.14 | this is an awful ranking |
mandan
05.12.14 | Yeah, I actually disagree with it, particularly with 13 being so low. |
TheSpaceMan
05.12.14 | almost any Floyd ranking is fine honestly, the bands got so many great albums |
Rowan5215
05.12.14 | Dannyboy list
Even danny disagrees with it
hahahaha |