Muisc4Life26: Pink Floyd Ranked!

DominionMM1 05.02.13	lol
demigod! 05.02.13	11 is too low but other than that not a bad ranking I'd also put a few more of the early ones above the wall
YoYoMancuso 05.02.13	agreed w/your top 2 choices after that it kinda derails Piper and Dark Side > The Wall
evilford 05.02.13	disagree w/ most of the placements here but cool
Necrotica 05.02.13	First two are correct
evilford 05.02.13	5 is 1 on any list ever until the end of time
demigod! 05.02.13	i heard us and them on the radio today it was great until they cut off like two seconds into any colour, i was pissed
evilford 05.02.13	THAT MAKES ME SO ANGRY
demigod! 05.02.13	its literally one of the worst things in the world
stabbler 05.02.13	there's radio still?
demigod! 05.02.13	weird eh
Friday13th 05.02.13	Wish You Were Here is definitely first. The only one I can listen to all the way through without getting bored.
StallionMang 05.02.13	14 is extremely underrated in my opinion.
InFiction 05.02.13	1 is correct.
SgtPepper 05.02.13	Everything Evilford said, I agree with. but this ranking is pretty acceptable. Surprised to see 6 so high, most Floyd fans dont like that one, and it's also one I often ignore myself.
akimbo 05.02.13	what yoyo said
JamieTwort 05.02.13	6 is underrated, good to see it so high up for a change.
tempest-- 05.02.13	yoyo is correct listen to him
ViralOblivion 05.02.13	Agree with top 2 not so much after that
Artuma 05.02.13	pretty good list actually
Rowan5215 05.02.13	Yeah 6 is underrated so hard, props for putting it up high where it belongs.
Artuma 05.02.13	12 is a tad too low and 4 is my 1 but otherwise i agree
Aids 05.02.13	pretty good ranking, 10 is too high though. fuck that album man.
JamieTwort 05.02.13	10 is too low*
Penlord 05.02.13	I harshly disagree with Obscured by Clouds and The Wall being better than Piper at the gates of dawn nd Dark side of the moon.
Penlord 05.02.13	the rest i agree with though except the final cut is at the bottom
JamieTwort 05.02.13	Why so much hate for The Final Cut? That album is so much better than The Wall.
Artuma 05.02.13	hahahahaha
JamieTwort 05.02.13	Sorry Artuma, I know you love The Wall but it's really overrated imo and I just connect with The Final Cut more as there's so much more emotion in that album.
BigPleb 05.02.13	VLADIMIR ILYICH ULYANOV.
evilford 05.02.13	Yeah the final cut is much more effective and real than the wall IMO Plus it does have some killer gulmour solos
Artuma 05.02.13	@JT: yeah, i respect your opinion but i think pretty much the opposite, the final cut has a couple of good songs but overall it's not anything special to me, would rank it somewhere around 10th as well
JamieTwort 05.02.13	The solo in The Fletcher Memorial is probably in my top 5 Gilmour solos.
Artuma 05.02.13	"Plus it does have some killer gulmour solos" so do every other PF album too
BigPleb 05.02.13	Final Cut>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>The Wall
JamieTwort 05.02.13	Agreed.
Artuma 05.02.13	i don't get the hate for the wall here, it's about a perfect concept album
Aids 05.02.13	The Final Cut is everything that is wrong with Roger Waters in album form. The Wall was ridiculous and over the top, but it had charm and fell on just the right side of lovable/insane. The Final Cut is just over-indulgent B-side crap.
evilford 05.02.13	If your focus is "man I hate roger waters" then you're just not going to like the final cut Yeah the band was dysfunctional as all fuck at that point. Was roger kind of an ass about some things? Sure... But the writing is so fucking poignant IMO. The wall is a nice story that ends and that's that. The final cut has real life implications that will always exist probably, ie the threat of nuclear war, guilt, PTSD, sadness etc. Idk I guess the way I look at it is that the final cut gets down to the root of roger's issues with his father's death and his feelings on war and government. So yeah. If you hate RW to begin with then you prob won't like the final cut
JamieTwort 05.02.13	"The Final Cut is everything that is wrong with Roger Waters in album form. The Wall was ridiculous and over the top, but it had charm and fell on just the right side of lovable/insane. The Final Cut is just over-indulgent B-side crap." I feel exactly the opposite. The Final Cut is everything that is amazing about Water's song writing. Powerful, emotional and incredibly personal.
Rowan5215 05.02.13	Yeah Final Cut is just out of their top 5 for me, and it definitely beats the Wall in terms of emotion and consistency even if nothing on it touches Comfortably Numb. It's a 4 at the least IMO.
evilford 05.02.13	agreed agreed
ButteryBiscuitBass 05.02.13	Am I seriously the first to come onto this list and say 2 is 1? WTF
evilford 05.02.13	yeah I would have thought that would have happened by now
ButteryBiscuitBass 05.02.13	I was expecting that to be the first comment when I clicked on this list.
LegendofPittman 05.02.13	Wait, who's Pink Floyd?
JamieTwort 05.02.13	"Am I seriously the first to come onto this list and say 2 is 1? WTF" Well I thought it but I didn't say it for some reason. I'll say it now. 2 is 1 [2]
facupm 07.18.13	top 2 is top 2 in that order
jdennis31 07.18.13	i just listened to dark side of the moon for the first time about a month ago. everytime i hear the great gig in the sky, it always reminds me of Dennis Reynolds trying out for the band in his spandex. anyways, dark side should be #1
Inveigh 07.18.13	The Wall's a little high, but I'm on board with basically everything else (outside of 8 being absurdly high)
MosesMalone 07.18.13	Anyone who thinks the wall is too high has bought into too much hive-mind bullshit.
jdennis31 07.18.13	or maybe the album just isn't as good as you think it is
BigHans 07.18.13	12 is underrated hard
MosesMalone 07.18.13	Not possible.
jdennis31 07.18.13	Lol. The Wall was my favorite trip album ever back in the day. Probably the only album I've ever listened to in full while tripping hard.
MosesMalone 07.18.13	Ever heard the butthole surfers while you're tripping? Specifically "my brother's wife". Extremely disconcerting.
jdennis31 07.18.13	Nuh, I've only heard one song by them before, but I can't figure out what it was.
MosesMalone 07.18.13	Well check it out and imagine being balls deep in some really great lucy, tell me it wouldn't make your blood turn to ice.
Inveigh 07.18.13	yeah Division Bell is good, could stand to move up a few spots for sure
jdennis31 07.18.13	I'm going crazy looking for this song, but I'm listening to random tracks and they are pretty good. Some of these would definitely fuck my world up.
wacknizzle 07.18.13	Hey now, hey now, not a bad ranking but don't put The Wall before Dark Side. Props for 1, 2, an 3 doe.